Mini 1626: Duck Tales Mafia (Game Over)

[KittyCupCake]

I'm dying to vote Pine, myself.

I hope he townies his ass up, and soon.

Town does not say this. Ever.

Case closed.

This reminded me of pasch D1, talking to SH.

Pasche: I'm willing to forget everything you've done and start anew. Can you tell me what your scumreads are right now and exactly why? I want to see your full thought process behind each read.

R~

No you aren't, especially since you don't seem to understand what I've done thus far. You know who my scumreads are (one of them is you), and you know why. What no one seems to know, however, is why you're voting for me.

You're the one who needs to rehabilitate their image, not me.

The wagon on me is the most obvious mislynch in a long time, is really really obviously scumdriven, and nobody who's actually paying attention is going to join it.

But you'll be called to answer for it, and you should probably start actually contributing useful content instead of just making noise.

The bolded being parts that don't make sense from a townie talking to a scum read. At the time, I thought this sounded like scum doing a bad job attacking someone they knew was town. Now knowing that SH was town, this is even stronger.

I feel like TW/pasch is a more likely possibility now (576/584).

[mastin2]

You know enough about how I think as scum i.e. NKs to know that Wisdom is the last kill I'd make, since

his making noise would definitely create a workable smokescreen for me

(Plus, I'm a bit of a masochist. You should know that from Maniacal when

I kept Nero alive for so long while fighting him

.). If I really was scum who thought you were a PR, you'd be dead by now. Also, if I was scum in the first place,

picking a fight with you is the last thing I'd want to do

, since it's much easier to just get you to townread me and kill you off.

*cough*

If the emphasis isn't clear enough. Sure you'd keep a player making noise alive to create a workable smokescreen! Sure it'd be masochistic! Doesn't need to be Shiny. In fact...the behavior you describe? Of getting them to townread you and then killing them off? Is pretty much exactly what Shiny ended up having done to them!

[mastin2]

There's just no way wreck is ever town here. No way.

And that is precisely why he is town.

Guaranteed.

Seriously. He's not scum.

[mastin2]

I'm dying to vote Pine, myself. I hope he townies his ass up, and soon.

Town does not say this. Ever. Case closed.

DOMO, you're forgetting something.

Scum had daychat D1.

Why is that important?

Because scum with fucking daychat NEVER, NEVER, EVER IN THEIR ENTIRE LIVES, EVER, would say this in-thread. Why not?

Because that's what their fucking QT/PT (dunno which AA9 used, but I think she still uses QTs) is for. Instead of posting it in-thread, know what an actually-scum-Wreck does? Says in the mafia QT, "Hey, Pine. Town your ass up, or I'm bussing you."

Case closed. Wreck's town.

[mastin2]

You do understand that mastin's argument for me as scum is

entirely

100% dependent on Bulba being scum, right?

Not so!

...It's only

most

dependent on Bulba being scum.

@mastin:

How do you feel about pasch using your VC analysis as reasoning to support a Kitty/

TW

(not Kitty/Bulba) scumteam?

Not quite sure he jumps to exceeding you on the scumlist, but he's at least tied right now.

[KittyCupCake]

Because scum with fucking daychat NEVER, NEVER, EVER IN THEIR ENTIRE LIVES, EVER, would say this in-thread.

This is a very good point.

Not quite sure he jumps to exceeding you on the scumlist, but he's at least tied right now.

Well, that's a step in the right direction.

[Doubleslap]

VOTE: doubleslap

mastin, it's house
he likes to see how far he can push it and be reckless like that as scum
that doesn't apply very strongly to his scumgame

[Doubleslap]

whoops!

VOTE: wreck

[Total Wreck]

VOTE: doubleslap

mastin, it's house
he likes to see how far he can push it and be reckless like that as scum
that doesn't apply very strongly to his scumgame

That is a flat out lie.

I play a conservative scum game, and I'm confrontational as town.

Talk about blatant misrep.

[Total Wreck]

Also, I don't hesitate to bus as scum. There would have been no warning.

Hell, I named both of my scum buddies in my first reads list in NY 177!

[Total Wreck]

Anyone taking Doubleslap's read at face value should remember Marquis flat out admitted wanting me lynched here due to another game.

That other game was NY 177.

I'm just a PL to him.

[Total Wreck]

reading
marquis is watching agents of shield
also he is rly sure that tw is scum "cus of other games" but no other explanation

[farside22]

Oh I thought I posted this, but it seems I left it in preview while I made tea...

Tell me why you think I'm scum.

I don't. I think you're in the scum pool and I would like you to not be.

My big problem is if NM is town, the you were doing your utmost yesterday to shift votes from scum to town. That and the fact you didn't hammer scum when you were obviously frustrated.

Tell me why PN is town, because I'm struggling to shake off my aronis scumread.

Why are you vying so hard for towncred from the Pine flip?

I'm not. My interest is to judge the sincerity of PN's response. I don't give a crap how much towncred I have or haven't got.

But it's cute how you wave your finger at me. You're more or less caught scum and your intereactions now need to be kept under control to give your last buddy the best possible chance. I'm a safe target because it's already obvious that I'm not scum with you and pine.

This line of reasoning makes no sense, and this is the third time you've pulled something like this and is the entire basis of your scumread on me.

Curious, if that is the only reason you have not to trust me, why is guy not on your list?
As for pn: I liked his questions to pasch in 1822 and I see him as trying to figure things out.
Aronis read scummy to me but there is no way anyone could defend someone's play. What has pn done that reads scummy?

Well ok maybe if that was all then I'd be stretching it.

The whole exchange from #655 onto the next page, you're scum scum scum. You're doing your best to discredit shiny while selling us pasch, doing your best to protect pine.

This isn't close. If somehow you are town, well you need to die while we're comfortable because you're a massive liability in late game, and potentially a magnet for multiple PRs. You have to go, and if you were town, you'd realise that and get reading the thread for your final reads. Hint hint.

@tw: I would like to know who your scum reads are and why please.

Note to self read bulba meta links in post 1869

[farside22]

I'm dying to vote Pine, myself. I hope he townies his ass up, and soon.

Town does not say this. Ever. Case closed.

DOMO, you're forgetting something.

Scum had daychat D1.

Why is that important?

Because scum with fucking daychat NEVER, NEVER, EVER IN THEIR ENTIRE LIVES, EVER, would say this in-thread. Why not?

Because that's what their fucking QT/PT (dunno which AA9 used, but I think she still uses QTs) is for. Instead of posting it in-thread, know what an actually-scum-Wreck does? Says in the mafia QT, "Hey, Pine. Town your ass up, or I'm bussing you."

Case closed. Wreck's town.

Also I need to reread day 1 a bit more.

[Total Wreck]

For those of you that were butthurt by me not wanting to vote Pine yesterday, I'm not the only one that felt that way.

pedit i see pine as the kind of player that might kinda tryhard it but if he's town giving him time and space to speak is a helpful good thing plus it's a good thing that doesn't get annoying
he's already made a few analysis posts that i found wellll not exactly intriguing but it's like "good i can follow these hmm hmmm" i want more of them before committing to any reads decision from him

keep in mind he's on the do-not-lynch list, not the town list
i see no reason to consider lynching him today. the risk of lynching pinetown trumps the chance of lynching pinescum

think of it like mastin but maybe more likable

Funny how they didn't get shit for it, but I did.

[Total Wreck]

it was a null read i was ok with lynching
i'm fine as long we don't lynch a townread
and i didn't say all of that

They are fine as long as we don't lynch a town read, but refused to vote scum!Pine, who they admitted was not a town read?

This should die. Obvscum buddy.

VOTE: Doubleslap

[Total Wreck]

Vote Count 1.16

Shiny Hydreigon

- ,

DOMO

-, Pine

KittyCupCake

-

Total Wreck

- Not_Mafia,

farside22

-

Not_Mafia

- GuyInFreezer, farside22, ,

Paschendale

- ,

mastin2

- , Paschendale, , Bulbazak

Pine - mastin2, Shiny Hydreigon, DOMO, Doubleslap, KittyCupCake, Perpetual Nonsense, Total Wreck ( Lynched)

Bulbazak

-

Perpetual Nonsense

-

Doubleslap

-

Not Voting

W

i

t

h

1

3

a

l

i

v

e

i

t

t

a

k

e

s

7

f

o

r

a

l

y

n

c

h

a

n

d

6

f

o

r

n

o

-

l

y

n

c

h

.

Day1 ends in (expired on 2014-12-13 19:40:00)

[Total Wreck]

UNVOTE:

[DOMO]

Curious, if that is the only reason you have not to trust me, why is guy not on your list?

I can't even remember anything he's posted. I had to look to see what slot it is. It's the drjeckle slot. Town by virtue of the fact I would be very surprised to see a scum slot need filling so often. It's a lame reason to town someone but it's what I think.

[DOMO]

Because scum with fucking daychat NEVER, NEVER, EVER IN THEIR ENTIRE LIVES, EVER, would say this in-thread. Why not?

Town doesn't say it ever, either. WHY DOES TOWN WANT SOMEONE WHO IS SCUMMY TO TOWN IT UP?

[DOMO]

I don't know how anyone can think wreck is town with the case I have on him. He blatantly tells pine he's gonna bus him. Why did he say it itt instead of in the scum QT? idk, ask him after the game, but he did it, and then immediately realised how stupid it was, and tried to bullshit his way out of it. It's clear as daylight. That is not town, it's just not.

[Total Wreck]

Because scum with fucking daychat NEVER, NEVER, EVER IN THEIR ENTIRE LIVES, EVER, would say this in-thread. Why not?

Town doesn't say it ever, either. WHY DOES TOWN WANT SOMEONE WHO IS SCUMMY TO TOWN IT UP?

Pune wasn't scummy as of that post, he was at worst null.

[Total Wreck]

I don't know how anyone can think wreck is town with the case I have on him. He blatantly tells pine he's gonna bus him. Why did he say it itt instead of in the scum QT? idk, ask him after the game, but he did it, and then immediately realised how stupid it was, and tried to bullshit his way out of it. It's clear as daylight. That is not town, it's just not.

As invested as you are in your faulty premise, I'm wondering if you just might be Pine's buddy wanting revenge for me hammering without staying intent because it robbed you of the opportunity to jump off the wagon.

[Total Wreck]

Stating*

[DOMO]

mastin could be scum with wreck. I consider it unlikely, seeing as the likes of bulb and pasch, amongst others, also have compelling reasons to be scum. But mastin is committed to a claim involving being blocked n1, so if she's scum the she's also committed to doing everything possible to keep her buddy alive, becuse mastin is vulnerable to a cc. It would explain why she's giving him townpoints for literally the scummiest thing in this thread.

pedit - I wondered how long it would take you to omgus me. Do it. Turn this into a 1 vs 1. I dare you.