Once Upon A Winter Night - [Game Over]

[Albert B. Rampage]

beast there's no time. Vote CKD.

[beastcharizard]

Beast,

What do you find interesting about this game?

That Marquis is scum. The last time I thought Marquis was scum I tricked myself into thinking otherwise and I lost because of it. Not going to happen again.

[beastcharizard]

you fucking know me better than that

You should know me enough to know that this isn't my scum game. You are not going to blind-side me this game. You are scum and I am sticking to that read.

[beastcharizard]

beast there's no time. Vote CKD.

We have 4 days for a lynch. What do you mean we have no time?

[curiouskarmadog]

which reminds me.

Because in order for the scum to have a viable chance of actually winning they would need to know more than three people's role names. Hence why I think Marquis is scum. It would be most beneficial for scum to start out with the only ability to target players rather than names.

They could just blindly target names but that would be dumb.

Explain to me this statement? ALL roles names are common knowledge, just not there real names. So what exactly are you concerned about?

But lets say this (scum needed to know people's real name vs. their game names) was a thing, if dear Marquis is indeed town, wouldnt scum want this power in their hands....and wouldnt they be saying something similar to this very post to shed doubt on him to begin the process of eliminating down the line till they got it?

beast can you comment please.

[beastcharizard]

which reminds me.

Because in order for the scum to have a viable chance of actually winning they would need to know more than three people's role names. Hence why I think Marquis is scum. It would be most beneficial for scum to start out with the only ability to target players rather than names.

They could just blindly target names but that would be dumb.

Explain to me this statement? ALL roles names are common knowledge, just not there real names. So what exactly are you concerned about?

But lets say this (scum needed to know people's real name vs. their game names) was a thing, if dear Marquis is indeed town, wouldnt scum want this power in their hands....and wouldnt they be saying something similar to this very post to shed doubt on him to begin the process of eliminating down the line till they got it?

beast can you comment please.

Sorry, I missed this.

Yes they do know everyone's name and there is even a fake one mixed in. What they don't know is who is who. The power would be able to connect a player with a name. Lets say I am deemed a huge threat to scum. They don't know my name so they need the power to figure it out in order to kill me. They could target a name that might be mine but chances are they could kill someone else whom they might have wanted to keep alive.

Also, with your logic we shouldn't lynch anyone who has the power because they could be town and scum could be next in line. That is silly. I am not trying to lynch Marquis just because he is first. I am lynching Marquis because I think he is scum but they first thing does play a part in the reason I think he is scum.

[Kovara]

okay lets get more action going.

VOTE: Nobody special

I think this is where I want my vote the most, and I think beastcharizard might be reaching.

hey there besties. why this vote? what did beast say that seemed to be reaching....dont just repost a quote, explain your line of thinking please....

I don't agree with any of beasts posts at all, and it's almost kinda sorta like he's trying way, way to hard to form a read on marquis instead of letting it form naturally... this cub doesn't like that at all. Reminds me the stories of my great great uncle scar, the big bad lion!

I mean, I can see marquis not trolling as a scum reason, maybe but he's being fairly active which, IMO is a town-tell and I think beast is doing whatever he can to get marquis ran over by a stampede of water buffalo. The post that hit me the most was post 39 because it isn't only scum who need names to learn who they are targeting, it's the PR's as well and he doesn't seem to take that into consideration. I think the entire mechanic is made so that it serves the good lions more than it serves the bad lions

[Kovara]

I also want to play with antihero, but I can only play with good guys so I hope anti shows up to prove himself to be a good guy very soon!

serious liony business stuff, though

VOTE: Beast

I probably should have put my vote there earlier. he's being way to try hard and stuff

[beastcharizard]

Ok, let me meet all of your guys' expectations.

I will lurk out the game, make it to LYLO and probably make the wrong choice.

I mean if yall don't want me to actively try to win the game I will inactively try to win the game.

I am willing to bet this is going to get more people to vote me.

Marquis is freaking scum. I will put it in bigger letters if I have to. I will bold it, change the color. I will do whatever to show yall that Marquis is scum. I will bet my life in this game on it.

[Equinox]

From a very cursory skim, I have no idea what is going on. I hate that Antihero basically gunned for curiouskarmadog and didn't see me jump on the Antihero wagon for essentially no reason, but I think I have to actually read those walls to understand what's going on with the two of them. Sigh. I'm kind of torn on beastcharizard, and I hate every single one of you metagamers for bringing up game after game because there's no time to read them all and gaaaah.

Unvote

I'll come back to this later tonight.

[Equinox]

Oh, actually, beastcharizard, why are you town?

[Tammy]

Sorry that was unclear. Do you typically think he's town when he's scum?

Marquis I also wanted you to answer if you typically town read beast when he's scum.

Anti - when you stop being mad at ckd, can you also answer this question? And tell me what you think of beast?

[Tammy]

But the servants should not name claim in the neighborhood.

Why are you assuming that there is a need for name-claiming within the neighborhood?

I'm not?

I'm assuming that people will always do what they do in neighborhoods and that's claim their characters/roles or suggest it.

It should go without saying, but people shouldn't be claiming their characters in neighborhoods this game.

What I meant was, why do you assume that the neighbors haven't already been told each other's role names?

I don't think fake god makes a game where people have to know character names instead of player names for any actions and then makes a neighborhood where he outs to the group who each persons character is. It pretty much defeats the purpose.

Also, when I was in a neighborhood in his Viscon mansion game, he just told us who we shared a neighborhood with but not who the flavor names were.

[Katsuki]

abr if I give you ckd today will you give me charizard on a spit tmr?

[Tammy]

abr if I give you ckd today will you give me charizard on a spit tmr?

You're voting beast?

[Katsuki]

Pretty sure I have been this whole time.

[Tammy]

Read that question wrong. Never mind. Carry on, nothing to see here *whistling*

[Katsuki]

Wanna join one of those two wagons, tammy?

[Tammy]

Maybe, I'm more interested in figuring out the beast mess right now.

[Katsuki]

You'll end up with a fried brain thinking too much. Much easier to solve with rope.

[Tammy]

Eh

[Bert]

Hello people!

Am here, must. Prioritize. And read up tomorrow morning...

Because 4 days...

Gaiden, if you see this, have something to ask you

/mobile

[SXTLHGaiden]

ask away bert

[Bert]

CKD, why do you feel anti's 'anger' feels authentic?

[Bert]

ask away bert

Will you vote CKD? I fear nothing.