Open 579: Pick Your (Chocolate) Power -- Game Over

[insanity018]

Votecount 3.2

Ollie

(5): Formerfish, Green Crayons, TheAdrienC, farside22, Flubbernugget

(L-1)

Flubbernugget

(1): Ollie

Not Voting

(4): Aneninen, droog, wgeurts, Mathdino

With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

Deadline

: (expired on 2015-01-10 15:23:28)

[TheAdrienC]

I'm torn between two scumreads voting for one another...

[Mathdino]

I swear to god if droog and wgeurts hammer prematurely, they'll die prematurely by tomorrow.

Need to catch up.

[TheAdrienC]

Unvote
Vote: Flubbernugget

I might put the vote back on Ollie, but this day needs to last longer. And while I feel like both are probably scum, I'm feel a bit more drawn to Flubber now.

[droog]

requesting nobody hammers yet
i will catch up on this game with thoughts
tomorrow

[Ollie]

This Flubbernugget is blatantly scum, asking for permission constantly, really odd. Are you a servant in real life or something? That's the only other explanation. That silly username was the biggest giveaway.

[Ollie]

I'm torn between two scumreads voting for one another...

don't lie, you two are a team.

[Ollie]

4 votes needed to save the doc. Green Mole won't change, I know that.

[Ollie]

[Ollie]

But seriously, Adrien, farside, Fubbernugget, that fish guy, probably 3 out out of the 4, at least 2 of them, scum. I can see this from my POV as I know I'm town. I also still do not get why the doc is getting lynched after declaring his role & who he protected, there's surely a way of testing my role in the night phase? Apparently it's impossible to have protected Green Mole, for some odd reason. & that's why I'm getting lynched. Love it.

[Ollie]

Vote for flubbernugget then vig me overnight if he's town which I doubt. Or is there not an investigation role around? Must be something that can be done that doesn't involve dropping the doc.

[Aneninen]

I'll have a longer post too but, it has just caught my eyes...

Vote for flubbernugget then vig me overnight if he's town which I doubt.

The Vig is dead, Ollie, f-cking dead! We lynched him on Day2 and he didn't even claim that f-cking role!!! What kind of bullshyt was that?!

[Ollie]

Possible Roles:

Night 3 Vigilante

OR Vengeful
1-Shot Vigilante OR 1-Shot PGO (active)
Cop OR 1-Shot Redirector
1-Shot Commuter OR 1-Shot Watcher
Doctor OR Roleblocker
Universal Backup OR Role Cop
Neighborizer OR Fruit Vendor
Jailkeeper OR Tracker

Tonight is night 3.

[Ollie]

tbf flubberdubber culled him before he had the chance to claim.

[Aneninen]

Oh,

that

one. First of all, I can't see why would anyone with a little common sense choose that role over Vengeful. (If that rolepair exists at all in this game.)
Second, if you're aware of the setup and the game that much, why the f-ck you didn't protect Alchemist, or (if you haven't trusted him) Farside. What was the reason for protecting someone who wasn't amongst your townreads and who claimed VT before??!

[Ollie]

I think you mean amongst

YOUR

town reads. Have you been reading my posts? Why would I protect farside, one of the four that I deem most likely to be scum right after that L-1 stuff? Secondly I haven't read all the pages in the thread. I got up to page 14 of another game I'm in on this forum, posted my thoughts up to that point & they were a mess because of all the replacements so I've just been reading people on what's happened since I've been in the game in that one & this one, keeping things simpler. & in that time Alchemist never made an impression on me, there are too many people with similar usernames starting with A in this game I guess, hard to keep track of who is who. So I made a choice between the two most visible scum hunters TO ME. VT could be a survival gambit, it means nothing. I don't see how it can be impossible that I protected GC. Did he die? No. So it's not impossible. In fact IT ACTUALLY HAPPENED.

So what is this now, you're lynching me because I didn't do an effective job of being the doc? Because I didn't protect one of YOUR town reads? I can't win.

[Aneninen]

You didn't even mention Alchemist in your posts while you was alive.
But, I have some weird questions.

Who do you think the Backup or the Rolecop is if that rolepair exists in this game?
If you had been in this game from scratch, which number would you have chosen at the Draft and why?
Are you from England?

[farside22]

Anyone paying attention at home with this argument will note that Ollie has yet to explain why he did not protect alchrmist yet.
Plus calling adrien scum with Flubber after adrien switched votes is completely non-sense.
Finally most of what I see is I'm the doc how dare you want to lynch me, whiling spewing reads on players that are, at least in my view, crappy.

[Mathdino]

/ means or.
I think one or the other for different reasons.

Hey farside, can you expand on this? I'm coming around to the Flubber-or-Adrien-no-matter-what thing but kinda out of PoE.

Alchemist21 - 4 - Cop

davesaz - 6 - Jailkeeper

Ollie - 8 - Doc/Roleblock

Siveure DtTrikyp - 13 - VT doc

Green Crayons - 15 VT tracker
Aneninen - 1 -
Formerfish - 1 -

Victor- 3 - 1-shot Vig

farside22 - 3
Mathdino - 5 -
wgeurts - 5
Flubbernugget - 2
Adrien - 2
droog - 2

I'm inclined to trust farside on the Ollie/GC issue with the exception of the possibility that the team is Ollie/GC/farside. I think Anen and Former are town, mostly. So it pretty much boils down to {Ollie, farside/wgeurts, Flubber/Adrien}.

And yeah, Ollie publicising the whole night 3 vig thing is exactly why I want scumspects for tomorrow.

Universal Backup, if you block this kill, I swear to god I will lynch you on sight.

[farside22]

/ means or.
I think one or the other for different reasons.

Hey farside, can you expand on this? I'm coming around to the Flubber-or-Adrien-no-matter-what thing but kinda out of PoE.

Alchemist21 - 4 - Cop

davesaz - 6 - Jailkeeper

Ollie - 8 - Doc/Roleblock

Siveure DtTrikyp - 13 - VT doc

Green Crayons - 15 VT tracker
Aneninen - 1 -
Formerfish - 1 -

Victor- 3 - 1-shot Vig

farside22 - 3
Mathdino - 5 -
wgeurts - 5
Flubbernugget - 2
Adrien - 2
droog - 2

I'm inclined to trust farside on the Ollie/GC issue with the exception of the possibility that the team is Ollie/GC/farside. I think Anen and Former are town, mostly. So it pretty much boils down to {Ollie, farside/wgeurts, Flubber/Adrien}.

And yeah, Ollie publicising the whole night 3 vig thing is exactly why I want scumspects for tomorrow.

Universal Backup, if you block this kill, I swear to god I will lynch you on sight.

you made a statement in the game here:

Flubber and Adrien cant both be scum, everyone forgets this.

I thought you were referencing the post I made here.

Okay, here's the theory. Keep in mind, that

according to the information we know, it's most probably NOT true.

I also thought that there is a Neighbourhood.
MathDino posted on Day1 that if Siv flipped scum I'd be FoS-ed by him. On Day2 he started advocating that I'm very-super-pro-town.
A possible answer for this change would have been if MathDino had Neighbourized Alchemist and Alchemist investigated me. (From a Neighbourizer it's one of the best strategies to get the Cop and advocate his/her investigations so as to protect him.)
Alchemist was Nightkilled and MathDino posted that HE had been investigated by the Cop at Night1.

This story would make perfect sense if MathDino were Mafia Neighbourizer, regardless of Ollie's alignment.

BUT, if it gets confirmed that both MathDino and Alchemist weren't in the same Neighbourhood, my theory is false. Right now, this seems to be the case.

So, if anyone can confirm that my theory is either true or false, please do so!

Just going to deny this and move on then

But, back to the original topic.
Ollie's Night 2 choice for his protection doesn't make much sense. (Whom did he protect on Night 1? Has he written that and have I missed it?) Therefore, it's probable that he's scum.

But, we have plenty of time. We should get reads on the other players too, as usual. In addition: who's town and who's scum if Ollie flips scum? And what if he flips town?

Still thinking flubber/adrien and finally droog.
Those are my only 3 scum reads at this time.

Also Droog should be on that scum list. Why is he not mentioned?

[Mathdino]

Townread on him and I trust the idea that he gets real stumped at this point in the game.

[Aneninen]

Self-quote.

(1) Formerfish, Wgeurts, Flubber, Druuge. We need more content from all of you. Please, read the whole Day!

This one is still important.

Meanwhile, I've just ISO-ed Alchemist. It seems that either he was Roleblocked at Night1 or he targetted MathDino. Also, unless I'm an idiot who constantly misreads everything, it seems that he's constantly trying to instruct at least two players throughout the chat. This would make zero sense if he were scum, since scums have daytalk in this setup.

[Ollie]

You didn't even mention Alchemist in your posts while you was alive.
But, I have some weird questions.

Who do you think the Backup or the Rolecop is if that rolepair exists in this game?
If you had been in this game from scratch, which number would you have chosen at the Draft and why?
Are you from England?

What the hell is that first sentence supposed to mean?

No idea.

7. Lucky number 7. If I had been in the game at the start, I wouldn't be in this position, dunno what the hell my predecessor did to convince people my slot was scum to this extent.

Yes.

Anyone paying attention at home with this argument will note that Ollie has yet to explain why he did not protect alchrmist yet.

lol you're not paying attention! I already explained that. I do wonder if some of you can read.

So it pretty much boils down to {Ollie, farside/wgeurts, Flubber/Adrien}.

apart from me, you're on the right track, glad to see you've been reading my posts.

[Ollie]

Just lynch me then, my work here is done, Mathdino will avenge my death. He knows who the scum are.

[Ollie]

Don't talk about ongoing games please. ~insanity