I don't like it that the logic you're trying to use to disprove my read is "No one agrees with you.". I've had plenty of reads that no one else agreed with, and I've been right before. I'm not going to just drop a read because I'm the only one holding it.
In post 4591, Winter Skies wrote:
Are you trying to argue that I, as an alien scum faction, would out and out claim alien scum in thread and
ask to be investigated
?
I'm actually not arguing that at all. I'm arguing that alien is not flavor related.
In post 4591, Winter Skies wrote:
I'm not strictly discarding the concept of multiball or sk, I simply haven't seen any proof of either being the case yet.
Seriously? We've had a lot of proof, but people, especially TWOH, keep trying to sweep the evidence under the rug.
In post 4594, The Will of Heaven wrote:Bulbs: in the interest of absolute clarity, the reason why you thought that I was cherry picking your posts was because my wide brush meta of a game I wasn't even in was bad?
No, it's because you select quoted one part of a large explanation out of context to use against me, when the statement was further explained in the quote you took it from. There's no way you would have missed that as town. You were not trying to figure out my alignment. You were selectively quoting me to make me look more suspicious.
I want you to vote TD with me.
Is no one reading my paragraph on how flavor cop doesn't make sense?
In post 4613, Keybladewielder wrote:
ooba has insane results, but if he hits a third party alignment, it automatically registers as town.
Lynch this now. MS/Om, if you don't, I'm going to out everything after I'm completely caught up. We have scum by the balls, but no one is listening to us. I'm going to make sure they do, and then I want a mass claim.
In post 4625, Winter Skies wrote:
I am genuinely insulted that both you and bulbs are claiming that I am so stupid as to claim alien as an alien faction. Like. Really. What the fuck.
Seriously. When did I ever say this?
Same.
In post 4641, Espeonage wrote:I just had an epiphany.
What if Alien is used in the American sense. As in synonymous with foreigner. What if any character that isn't Capcom is thus an Alien?
Ok, now back to bed.
In post 4645, The Will of Heaven wrote:you mean being right about lynching skitty and
right about cult being a thing mafia are using for misdirection
?
In post 4668, Winter Skies wrote: In post 4567, Bulbazak wrote:If the alien result is just flavor, then it would not be talking about non-humans, as the results are alien/not alien, and given the limited amount of aliens that could be pulled for a game like this, alien being a scum faction would still be extremely likely. But we've also seen from the mafia flips that Kise is not using flavor for team names, otherwise, the mafia would be called "Robotic" or "Mechanized" or "Robotic Alliance" or the like. The fact that it's called mafia, and that Muk recruited into a cult, not "slime brethern" or the like, points to Kise using traditional team terminology, even if the themes of the teams lend them to something else. In that case, I think we can say for certain using setup spec and what we've seen that alien is not a freaking flavor descriptor.
I think you missed the entire part about the "alien flavor" being ambiguous. I agree with you that Kise is using traditional names for his scumteams, but there's no guarantee there's an alien faction or that Kise wouldn't include a flavor cop (a role that pops up in non-bastard games, so I don't see why it can't pop up here).
You're making more logical leaps than I am to reach alien being just flavor, especially since results are given as alien/not alien, not alien/human. I also pointed out that Kise has been using standard faction names, meaning that alien cop looking for a faction and not flavor significantly rises due to Occam's Razor. You then agree with all this, but then say that I'm wrong. Is everyone but me high or something?
In post 4668, Winter Skies wrote:
It's not that I don't think there are other factions, I just don't see anything that points to their guaranteed existence (apart from taking TD's role at face value).
This is your second continuous point with double speak, where you say that you believe and don't believe something simultaneously.
I did. TWOH never explained how they knew that aliens don't exist as a faction.
In post 4668, Winter Skies wrote:
In post 4567, Bulbazak wrote:
I think you're cult,
because you're not alien or mafia
, and you're not playing how I'd expect you to as town. It's either you're scum of some sort, or you're playing a horribad game, and I respect you too much to believe the latter. Droog is PoE. TD is mafia due to Ooba's roles and reasons.
Your masonry has cop results on the claimed Survivor and Dram. So why are you eliminating the possibility of them being Mafia?
Because TD is mafia, and he wouldn't investigate his own team mate unprovoked while looking for aliens.
In post 4712, mental somnic wrote:
And also I'm pretty sure the pple who were going "cult obviously exists" were likely the mafia themselves
We need to have a nice long talk tonight.
I am.
Lynch this.
Seriously. Why isn't this dead?
In post 4824, GGG wrote:
We no more have a serial killer than we have aliens. Some of these investigative roles have to be decoys.
On to page 194.
