Newbie 1572 - Chicken Parmigiana Mafia (Over)

[Bitmap]

Just gut?

Gut applied Logic. Your "Am I scum?" felt appeasy.

How was mine? Was my "No." less appeasy?

Nah wasn't as appeasy.

Just gut?

Gut applied Logic. Your "Am I scum?" felt appeasy.

I'm the one who said "Are you scum?" and I was making a point. There's no useful read from responses to that question. It's complete WIFOM, so I just pointed your own question back at you

Tryhard.

[DeasVail]

Vote Count 1.01

ika (2)- Kaleidoscope, Drixx
Flamingo (1)- Pramitz
Shockine (1)- Diego1487
Bitmap (1)- Debonair Danny DiPietro
Pramitz (1)- Bitmap

Not voting: Flamingo, Shockine, ika

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

Deadline

4th February, 11pm AEDT. This is in (expired on 2015-02-04 08:00:00)

[Drixx]

Just gut?

Gut applied Logic. Your "Am I scum?" felt appeasy.

I'm the one who said "Are you scum?" and I was making a point. There's no useful read from responses to that question. It's complete WIFOM, so I just pointed your own question back at you

Tryhard.

Is this supposed to be a bad thing?

[Pramitz]

So IRL shit just hit the fan, I'll try my best to keep up, but I just thought I'd let you guys know

[ika]

So IRL shit just hit the fan, I'll try my best to keep up, but I just thought I'd let you guys know

OGC/SE advice:

first off my SE stuff will be this (this is my mod color when i mod)

but if you have rl stuff what i would suggest is do a V/LA (vacation/limited access) or replace out if its something super serious

Just bold it and go "mod V/LA due to family issues" or jsut basic "V/LA"

that being said scripten might be town but will wait on him a bit more

everyone else has varying degress of null.

to try to push this further:

do you prefer scum or town and why?
how good is your scum game?
how good is your town game?

[DeasVail]

Replacing Flamingo and Shockine.

[Diego1487]

@ika,
Who's scripten?

1. I prefer town b/c I enjoy looking for small scum clues. It feels like one of those detective shows.
2. Only town in the forums so far, so I don't feel competent in answering this one.
3. Well, to be honest, not good so far. But I'm working on it!

[Kaleidoscope]

I'm back.
Uh, let's see here.
do you prefer scum or town and why?
Honestly town- I am horrible at scum (and town but town's a little easier)
how good is your scum game? Bad.
how good is your town game? Bad.
I am not a good mafia player.

[Pramitz]

I haven't played as scum yet, and my town game isn't great. Im still learning

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

Can we just assume I said everything Bitmap did? Read a post, start typing a response, see Bitmap made the response I was going to. See the next post, start typing a response, Bitmap did it. It's very rude.

[Bitmap]

Can we just assume I said everything Bitmap did? Read a post, start typing a response, see Bitmap made the response I was going to. See the next post, start typing a response, Bitmap did it. It's very rude.

I'm very sorry. I can't help it when I'm town. :/

Also, which posts were you planning on responding to?

[Bitmap]

@DDD:

Quick question that I would like to be answered, when you play forum mafia, do you read everything that has been posted and then make a post or read a post at a time and respond if need be per post?

[DeasVail]

Zombiekitty replaces Flamingo.

[ika]

@ika,
Who's scripten?

1. I prefer town b/c I enjoy looking for small scum clues. It feels like one of those detective shows.
2. Only town in the forums so far, so I don't feel competent in answering this one.
3. Well, to be honest, not good so far. But I'm working on it!

i meant bitmap, scripten is another player that i know of and have played with...

[zombiekitty]

Hello guys! I am replacing the flamingo. So you're all stuck with a zombiekitty.

[DeasVail]

Fjkldsjh replaces Shockine.

[Drixx]

Welcome to the replacements

[zombiekitty]

Am I scum? I guess we will find out.

This answer just felt off to me. Sort of evading the question in a way.

You are a light town-read.

I'm neutral on you with leaning slight scum.

You've already said why you sllight scumread Pramitz. You haven't explained why you have those reads on them. Care to explain why? Feels/gut?

Just gut?

Gut applied Logic. Your "Am I scum?" felt appeasy.

I'm the one who said "Are you scum?" and I was making a point. There's no useful read from responses to that question. It's complete WIFOM, so I just pointed your own question back at you

Interesting reply though. To somebody who was saying something to somebody else and not you.

What was the point of saying whatever you said to Bitmap here? He was talking to Pramitz about why he read him as slight scum. The way you're explaining how you were making a point about your "Are you scum" question wasn't necessary. Bitmap hadn't even explained why he had slight scumread you. Feels like you're scum hastily trying to defend yourself from something that could've been a slip on your part.

[Bitmap]

You are a light town-read.

I'm neutral on you with leaning slight scum.

You've already said why you sllight scumread Pramitz. You haven't explained why you have those reads on them. Care to explain why? Feels/gut?

ika felt town because scum players are more closed if meta is not applied.

Drixx felt scummy because he's appeasy as well and trying to get confirmation from the town.

[Bitmap]

I have town vibes on zombiekitty.

[fjkldsjh]

hi. Let me read.

[fjkldsjh]

Alright initial thoughts:

Bitmap is leaning scum. She's townreading and scumreading people based on nonsensical reasons and both times they are 'light reads' or 'gut reads' (which apparently warrants a vote). She's reading people based one one post on what on the surface are nothing but null tells.

Primatz seems genuine.


That's all for now.

[Bitmap]

Alright initial thoughts:

Bitmap is leaning scum. She's townreading and scumreading people based on nonsensical reasons and both times they are 'light reads' or 'gut reads' (which apparently warrants a vote). She's reading people based one one post on what on the surface are nothing but null tells.

Primatz seems genuine.


That's all for now.

That's a playstyle, not alignment indicative. Now stop being lazy and give me reads on other people. Also, the "which warrents a vote" is because of Random Voting Stage (RVS) which your IC can elaborate more if need be.

[Drixx]

Am I scum? I guess we will find out.

This answer just felt off to me. Sort of evading the question in a way.

You are a light town-read.

I'm neutral on you with leaning slight scum.

You've already said why you sllight scumread Pramitz. You haven't explained why you have those reads on them. Care to explain why? Feels/gut?

Just gut?

Gut applied Logic. Your "Am I scum?" felt appeasy.

I'm the one who said "Are you scum?" and I was making a point. There's no useful read from responses to that question. It's complete WIFOM, so I just pointed your own question back at you

Interesting reply though. To somebody who was saying something to somebody else and not you.

What was the point of saying whatever you said to Bitmap here? He was talking to Pramitz about why he read him as slight scum. The way you're explaining how you were making a point about your "Are you scum" question wasn't necessary. Bitmap hadn't even explained why he had slight scumread you. Feels like you're scum hastily trying to defend yourself from something that could've been a slip on your part.

I was just pretty sure Bitmap replied to the wrong person but was talking to me. I don't recall anyone else turning the question back around and pointing it at her. That's why I began the post by pointing out that I was the one who said it, not Pramitz. Also ... it feels like you're trying to scrape up some reason to justify a vote. FoS @ Zombiekitty

You are a light town-read.

I'm neutral on you with leaning slight scum.

You've already said why you sllight scumread Pramitz. You haven't explained why you have those reads on them. Care to explain why? Feels/gut?

ika felt town because scum players are more closed if meta is not applied.

Drixx felt scummy because he's appeasy as well and trying to get confirmation from the town.

This looks like poor scum play. Good scum can make cases based upon the behavior of other players and using logic. Bad scum players have to talk about "feelings" and make up reasons to vote.

Unvote

VOTE: Bitmap[/b]

Serious vote. Bitmap is slinging the proverbial pasta all over the place and trying to see what will stick. Classic first day scum play. Bitmap is also trying to claim that reading people for reasons that don't have anything to do with alignment is "a playstyle", which is a laughable defense. Bitmap then goes on the attack and calls someone who just replaced into the game "lazy". Bitmap = Scummy McScumpherson.

[Drixx]

VOTE: Bitmap

I don't understand why phpbb and VB have to have their preview and submit buttons swapped in places. It's just irritating for end users.