(Hilariously) Unbalanced Mafia 2 [Over]

[Muffin]

Also, there is literally no role I can think of that I would explicitly just trust that shos is confirmed town over. Nuh uh.

I don't think anyone said he was confirmed town?

Just that we are townreading him based partly on what he's said in the PT

[Awesome]

MUFFIN ANSWER MY GODDMAN QUESTION.

no

i am ignoring you

you and blizzard are both quite arrogant and it bothers me

lol

at least three heads of both hydras are pretty much the least arrogant people you will meet, so I'm just going to laugh.

[Awesome]

Is there a logical explanation as to why town Shos would ask mastin this:

I asked the mod what a normal cop would get if he investigates me, conisdering that I am neither fascist nor communist. Mastin said he cannot answer.

hmmmm

[BlizZard]

Also, there is literally no role I can think of that I would explicitly just trust that shos is confirmed town over. Nuh uh.

I don't think anyone said he was confirmed town?

Just that we are townreading him based partly on what he's said in the PT

actually not bullshit
we have role related reasons why shos is near confirmed town

so back the fuck up

onto toon

[BlizZard]

Also, there is literally no role I can think of that I would explicitly just trust that shos is confirmed town over. Nuh uh.

I don't think anyone said he was confirmed town?

Just that we are townreading him based partly on what he's said in the PT

In what parts of Shos' play are you basing the rest of your read on, then?

[Awesome]

I'm considering following onto shos, in part because he seems eh and I don't buy his "when I'm scum I'm building cases on townies and shiz" line and I also can't think of a role he has that would make him confirmed, so I do not buy it. It probably doesn't help that I don't trust anyone in that neighborhood completely either, so not taking their word for anything.

I had a bit to drink tonight, and going to bed soon, and HAVE NOT HEARD FROM ESPY (ESPY DO YOU HEAR ME, RESPOND TO ME!!!). But, if he doesn't respond to me, I'll just take control of our vote tomorrow.

[Muffin]

Is there a logical explanation as to why town Shos would ask mastin this:

I asked the mod what a normal cop would get if he investigates me, conisdering that I am neither fascist nor communist. Mastin said he cannot answer.

hmmmm

I'm neither fascist nor communist either, so

[Muffin]

Also, there is literally no role I can think of that I would explicitly just trust that shos is confirmed town over. Nuh uh.

I don't think anyone said he was confirmed town?

Just that we are townreading him based partly on what he's said in the PT

actually not bullshit
we have role related reasons why shos is near confirmed town

so back the fuck up

onto toon

near confirmed != confirmed

lots of people exaggerate when they say shit like that, and FIN3 certainly hasn't said anything about it in the QT

[mastin2]

Huh. Coulda sworn we were at only 70 a few hours ago......

VC 40

:

Toon Fighter - 9 (Fluminator, Frightened inmate number3, guille2015, ArcAngel9, Bulbazak, Ankamius, farside22, alivechihiro, Titus)

shos - 8 (BlizZard, Pine, theelkspeaks, Klingoncelt, Pirate Ika, ProHawk, DrippingGoofBall, Nobody Special)

DrippingGoofBall - 3 (shos, Muffin, Wisdom)
Klingoncelt - 2 (EddieFenix, eyestott)
ArcAngel9 - 1 (Toon Fighter)
alivechihiro - 1 (PeregrineV)
Pine - 1 (Jackel98)
Fluminator - 1 (Alchemist21)

Not Voting: 1 (Awesome)

With 27 alive, it's 14 to lynch.

Day One's deadline is Thursday, January 29th, @ 4:15 PM PST.
Toon Fighter for the lynch.

[pirate mollie]

am I the only 1 to think that entire neighbourhood is the scummiest thing to slither out of a truckstop toilet bowl?

muffin looks like scum.
shos looks like scum.
bulba looks like scum.
I didn't think fin did but now I think he does!

[Pirate Ika]

am I the only 1 to think that entire neighbourhood is the scummiest thing to slither out of a truckstop toilet bowl?

muffin looks like scum.
shos looks like scum.
bulba looks like scum.
I didn't think fin did but now I think he does!

sorry

[Tammy]

am I the only 1 to think that entire neighbourhood is the scummiest thing to slither out of a truckstop toilet bowl?

muffin looks like scum.
shos looks like scum.
bulba looks like scum.
I didn't think fin did but now I think he does!

No.

[Awesome]

am I the only 1 to think that entire neighbourhood is the scummiest thing to slither out of a truckstop toilet bowl?

muffin looks like scum.
shos looks like scum.
bulba looks like scum.
I didn't think fin did but now I think he does!

No.

I agree!

[Muffin]

am I the only 1 to think that entire neighbourhood is the scummiest thing to slither out of a truckstop toilet bowl?

muffin looks like scum.
shos looks like scum.
bulba looks like scum.
I didn't think fin did but now I think he does!

baseless

[Fluminator]

My town read on Titus has evaporated. What is up with her? Her swearing and freak out doesn't look genuine. Granted I've only skimmed the exchange.

So it doesn't look genuine, but you haven't read it, i.e. you wouldn't know if it was genuine or not. I think my initial read on you was right.

Are you even trying?
Last game you were scum you tunneled me for terrible reasons. This game you are going after me for terrible reasons? I can't help but think you are just trolling or something.

I sometimes wonder if I'm just picking up on a playstyle thing, which is why I'm not pursuing it. However, I've noticed that you didn't actually address my point.

I didn't address your point because it's so forced and bad. Skimming =/= Not reading.

Don't recall you having a scum read on Jack, shos.


Anyways here is what I have on Alchemist.


town game
town game

Above are links to the games in question but for me Alchemist has always been more open and talkative about his reads on players and has a very forceful behavior in both games. There is a thought process and questions, thinks he get to the heart of.
Plus as you see both games I was scum and we haven't played any other games then those two I would think he would be more paranoid of me after I had tricked him twice.

He talks a lot more in his scum games too. http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=51&t=59178

So whatever. Just lynch me. I rolled vanilla again, everyone has powers, and I'm bored.[/b]

Did you really get vanilla? LOL

Don't recall you having a scum read on Jack, shos.


Anyways here is what I have on Alchemist.


town game
town game

Above are links to the games in question but for me Alchemist has always been more open and talkative about his reads on players and has a very forceful behavior in both games. There is a thought process and questions, thinks he get to the heart of.
Plus as you see both games I was scum and we haven't played any other games then those two I would think he would be more paranoid of me after I had tricked him twice.

Go read check my play in GIF's Tohou II game. I was pretty aloof in that game (hence my replace out) due to the size and volume of it. I was hesitant to even join this game, but Mastin asked nicely. I probably would be more paranoid of you if it hadn't been for Titus' and Ank's early push on you. Of course, if this is multiball, maybe I should be more wary of you. :p

Also, there's something I noticed about Flum. When I first claimed, he believed the claim 100%. Now that there are a few people doubting me, he suddenly talks about how I'm "not being completely honest." To me this looks like scum that wanted to push a scumread on me for something that could be viewed as suspicious, but didn't want to push it until a few other players also had suspicions so he wouldn't draw attention to himself over it.

VOTE: Flum

Uhhh, what?
1. I didn't believe you 100%. You better re-read the convo again.
2. I'm not scumreading you. I've been very clear in my thoughts on you. Have you read them?

I've been having this totally Gut feeling that Flum is scum. Just saying.

Alch, thoughts on Shos and Toon?

Is it because I'm not the emotional, aggressive, rage-quitter I was in our last game? Please don't remind me of that game.

[Fluminator]

I like Toon wagon more then Shos wagon anyway. I'm also the first one on it.

[Pirate Ika]

am I the only 1 to think that entire neighbourhood is the scummiest thing to slither out of a truckstop toilet bowl?

muffin looks like scum.
shos looks like scum.
bulba looks like scum.
I didn't think fin did but now I think he does!

baseless

tbh you look like butthurt scum as in you are not getting your way as far as lynches go.

[Awesome]

Okay yeah, flum looks kinda town from his last couple posts.

My main concern is still the multi ball thing which could throw off some of my town reads based on pure scumhutning.

[Muffin]

am I the only 1 to think that entire neighbourhood is the scummiest thing to slither out of a truckstop toilet bowl?

muffin looks like scum.
shos looks like scum.
bulba looks like scum.
I didn't think fin did but now I think he does!

baseless

tbh you look like butthurt scum as in you are not getting your way as far as lynches go.

cool story, i'll quote this post at the end of the game after i flip green

[Pirate Ika]

am I the only 1 to think that entire neighbourhood is the scummiest thing to slither out of a truckstop toilet bowl?

muffin looks like scum.
shos looks like scum.
bulba looks like scum.
I didn't think fin did but now I think he does!

baseless

lets see:

you refuse to claim
you say you guys are not masons
you refuse to divulge anything about the hood
you are just basically going "do your own shit" instead of helping by communicating with us

ya i can see a lot more reasons why its not as baseless as you think.

basicly shos is claiming to be another cop (or someone in the supposve hood claimed it and hes revering it)

i wouldnt be surprised to see a 4-way PR hood where its one of each type (invest, protect, kill, and misdirection?)

i also wouldnt be surprised to see if you guys are a 4-way PR cop hood either with one of them being scum

[Pirate Ika]

am I the only 1 to think that entire neighbourhood is the scummiest thing to slither out of a truckstop toilet bowl?

muffin looks like scum.
shos looks like scum.
bulba looks like scum.
I didn't think fin did but now I think he does!

baseless

tbh you look like butthurt scum as in you are not getting your way as far as lynches go.

cool story, i'll quote this post at the end of the game after i flip green

is there another reason as to why you look so butthurt then?

[Pirate Ika]

what mollie sees vs what you are are 2 diffrent things jsyk, shes saying what you look like not what you are

pedit: maybe he didnt want to out the hood?

[mastin2]

<<< Epic mod fail, in that I sent a poke to Fluminator asking for a post...and it took me long enough to write that Fluminator actually did.
...EddieFenix got poked, though. >>>

[Awesome]

am I the only 1 to think that entire neighbourhood is the scummiest thing to slither out of a truckstop toilet bowl?

muffin looks like scum.
shos looks like scum.
bulba looks like scum.
I didn't think fin did but now I think he does!

baseless

tbh you look like butthurt scum as in you are not getting your way as far as lynches go.

cool story, i'll quote this post at the end of the game after i flip green

You know I don't care what kind of troll you think you are, or what kind of important arrogant piece of muffin you think you are, DO SOMETHING worthwhile because the shit you have been doing is scummy as fuck and derailing the game. If you're town FUCKING ACT LIKE IT.

[Bulbazak]

You know i'm expecting a fullclaim now from you 4

Nah.

From the wiki, there's a saying about hoods. In a group that size, there's bound to be scum.

I invite everyone to read the spoiled QT from the last game, as I think it has a lot of information that will make this game easier. Suffice to say that Mastin has a very unique view of neighborhoods, and she tends to treat them as masonries when she plays in one. Given the subtitle of the neighborhood, I think she copied that philosophy into the game design just to make people paranoid over an all town neighborhood. There's another reason why I think the neighborhood is all town, but I don't want to go into it at this time.

Muffin, shos, FIN3, and Bulba, what do you think of your three neighbors? If you knew you had 1 scum in your hood, who would you think it is? If there were 2, who would you think it is?

They're all town. 'Nuff said.

What are people scumreading Toon for?

The thought process is not one of a town player looking for scum. Instead, he's trying to seal a lynch, is sometimes apologetic while still calling players scum, pushes on trivial non-reasons, and over justifies his pushes. He's looking more for a lynch than scum, and you can see it if you actually read his posts.

am I the only 1 to think that entire neighbourhood is the scummiest thing to slither out of a truckstop toilet bowl?

muffin looks like scum.
shos looks like scum.
bulba looks like scum.
I didn't think fin did but now I think he does!

That's a pretty sudden reversal, and one that I actually find alarming. Can I ask what caused your sudden switch on Shos and myself (I believe you were more nullish on Shos before this point.)?