NY 179: Cute and Fluffy Mafia (Town Win)

[DrippingGoofball]

Guys, I once claimed Masons, as town, with a random townie.

Just sayin'

[DrippingGoofball]

Oh and the random townie went along with it.

[Nero Cain]

why would she trust you to do it, when you could be scum?

this is something you should ask DGB.

Furthermore why would you trust her even if you were town.

AND you had no way of being sure about ABRs alignment yourself or seriously imagine that anyone else can either.

Why wouldn't I? The only reason that you wouldn't buy a cop guilty is if you are scum and know that its wrong (like SC!)

Tell me why I, as town, should have not believed that DGB's guilty soft claim?

Nero, what's your read on DGB

gun to my head? town

[Garmr]

I'm just going to pretend what happened in the last couple of pages didn't happen until I had a strong amount of coffee.

[Garmr]

I'm just going to say nero if your scum like I think and you got away with all this and don't get lynched today. You deserve to win I think this game is lost and I want to try and salvage it but seriously I think you deserve an applause.

[Nero Cain]

Not scum. I just did what I felt was right. Like I told NJ, there's like no reason I should have not believed DGB. I mean, I'm not exactly a fool and I wouldn't be surprised if there's a scummer defending me but there ARE sane town defending me unless you think all of DX, IAI, DGB, and kthx are scum. But to be honest with you? This game is pretty much lost 'cause SC and Flubber scum are sitting there and staring you in the face. And you, DS and NJ pushing things which make absolutely no sense coming from scum.

[Garmr]

I do believe town is defending but I wouldn't consider dex competent. Tbh I thought if he got a universal town read like in last game scum would kill him off like in last game and I wouldn't have to deal with him.

[d3x]

Eat me, Garmr.

[Garmr]

@mafia
take dex not me his tasty

[Kthxbye]

gun to my head? town

Okay....

So.....

Why haven't you been suspicious of DGB if you thought she was dropping some sort of hint to you that she had a result on ABR yet turned out to flip town? I'm not asking why you went along with it, I'm more interested in why, today, you haven't been more curious about her really at all. As it reads now, you're pretty much just saying, 'meh, thought you had a result and needed a scapegoat...ah well'. There's no hint that you think she might be scum using you as a scapegoat to get ABR and now you lynched.

[Kthxbye]

there's like no reason I should have not believed DGB.

See, this is what I'm talking about. Why was there no reason not to believe DGB? Do YOU know she's town somehow? That's the thing I'm having a hard time with the more I think on it. Why were/are you so trusting of DGB that you felt you had no reason to not believe she had some sort of result? On top of that, why are you not questioning that after ABR flipped town?

[Kthxbye]

but I wouldn't consider dex competent.

This made me laugh.

[Garmr]

Happy birthday kthx

[Kthxbye]

And lastly for the quadra-post, still waiting on reasons/a case why anyone else is scummier (by play) than RM.

I'm just not buying the VI crap. He's lurking and keeping up with posts that make zero sense. As town, I'd think (and he has shown in previous games I have skimmed through) that he has the ability and would have the desire to actually know what's going on and help hunt for scum. As it stands now, he's playing up the VI card ultra hard and I think he's being coached by scumbuddies to do so.

p.edit: Thanks. Thirty fucking four..../sigh

[d3x]

Tbh I thought if he got a universal town read like in last game scum would kill him off like in last game and I wouldn't have to deal with him.

This is a blatant fucking lie. I played Doc to the hilt last game. I nailed 2 Protects in 4 Nights and was Killed because I was Watched. I also pegged PineScum when no one else was looking in his direction, among other solid Reads.

What exactly is the purpose of your weak ass attempt at discrediting me, anyway? You still aren't responding to the obvious argument against NeroScum. You're best attempt at defeating the logic is 'derp, Scum are probably just winging it.'

[dragonspawn]

It's hardly a weak argument. If it was he wouldn't have the biggest wagon at the moment.

And what does garmr need to say that hasn't been addressed?

[Nero Cain]

Why haven't you been suspicious of DGB if you thought she was dropping some sort of hint to you that she had a result on ABR yet turned out to flip town?

mainly POEish. SC is deff scum. And then there's flubber (and your link with him) and then crud like NJ and Peace and RM. So she'a bit down my totem pole. TBH though she is being a little lurky and jazz and yea I could see that from scum but I could also see it prtown so lets give her time to see her eat bullets.

there's like no reason I should have not believed DGB.

See, this is what I'm talking about. Why was there no reason not to believe DGB? Do YOU know she's town somehow? That's the thing I'm having a hard time with the more I think on it. Why were/are you so trusting of DGB that you felt you had no reason to not believe she had some sort of result? On top of that, why are you not questioning that after ABR flipped town?

Come on man, you are better than this. I can expect crap like this from NJ and the Vimasons but

you

are better than this. 98% there's no point in questioning a cop claim/hint. Why should I have not believed that her? Why should I suspect DGB when you don't even suspect her?

[Nero Cain]

It's hardly a weak argument. If it was he wouldn't have the biggest wagon at the moment.

If all arguments were "good" this site would be mislynch free. What kind of fantasy world do you live in?

[Kthxbye]

Why should I have not believed that her? Why should I suspect DGB when you don't even suspect her?

Paranoia.

Oh, but I do suspect her....just not as much as certain others atm. I trust nobody in this game. d3x is dropping his town tells all over the place and I have no real reason other than POE to think he scum and yet the only reason I'm not calling him possible scum every other page is because I'm keeping my paranoia in check with him. I got a solid read on him and I'm sticking with it. It's new.

Hell, it makes no sense for scum-you to fake claim like that yet, here I am, being paranoid you're pulling a fast one.

Basically, I prolly shouldn't play this game cuz I assume everyone is a liar-face and scum.

[Nero Cain]

Why should I not have believed her guilty soft claim?

[d3x]

@dragon- You answer me and I'll answer you.

[Garmr]

@Dex ds doesn't need to answer anything from you.

[d3x]

Oh, well if that's how this works...

[Garmr]

Dex there is scum in your hood who is it Nero or TDA.

[d3x]

You answer me and I'll answer you.