In post 630, droog wrote:i called you out for being inconsistent
so you have a few options
you could take a step back
explain why youve been inconsistent
you could deny being inconsistent
but hell even if inconsistent isnt the right word
you know what i mean
you could explain your reads
you could put words in my mouth
you could take back your vote
Having fluid reads isn't being inconsistent. Just because I change a vote doesn't mean I've completely dropped a read. However, at yours and Tiershift's request I will provide a reads list.
In post 636, TierShift wrote:Okay, so here's my alchemist read:
I had him as strong town day 1, due to his
21 and his knack for resolving arguments. I especially like
319.
But his day 2 consists of doing pretty much nothing. He first sheeps shos and then comes to arcangel with a pretty weak vote. I do like that his reads change without him really explaining every step inbetween (trajectory, I can elaborate on this if someone wants).
All in all, town, but with *some* reservations. Can I see some reads out of ya, alch?
My strongest Townread is Anen. I know people don't like his tunneling on Tier, but he's shown paranoia about it that I'm pretty sure comes from Town because I've been there plenty of times before. (Seriously though, Anen you do need to ease up and focus elsewhere. At least consider where you reads will be at if Tier flips Town.)
Shos is a Townread of mine now, partly because of his gunsmith claim, but more because he has the same idea about the Tier wagon that I do. I'm seeing things more his way in regards to the flavorclaiming, and I'm sure if he hadn't been forced to claim yesterday he would be refusing to nameclaim now too.
Tiershift is another Townread because of that EoD wagon. Like I said before I'm sure scum would have liked that lynch pushed because he was V/LA and couldn't defend himself.
Droog/This Christmas are the ones I feel are the scum candidates on the Tier wagon by the nature of how they joined the wagon (no explanation for voting a V/LA player is super scummy). It actually doesn't help that they're both breathing down my meck right now. (Inb4 omgus accusations)
AA9 is a scumread for the reasons I've already given. She's almost certain the game can be broken in some manner by flavorclaiming. I think she wants the nameclaims because she can match them to PRs, so this is a form of rolefishing from her. It might not be so bad if there was an attempt tohunt with other means as well, but she's been super focused on the flavor claims here.
