In post 243, Putin on a Cracker wrote:UNVOTE:
ETL and I have finally found some time to talk about our reads, and since it's getting close to DL we should really be closer to a lynch.
I think in sum, we're most confident on our scum read on tier. I've been guilty of posts like 64 a few times as scum, and have basically only seen it from scum. Because you know alignments, it's easier to tell which argument from town are unlikely to lead anywhere, so you're more likely to call them out as useless.
I also don't like him trying to drive a wedge between us and heartless, and the scum-read on lurker nm.
We agree that anen is town. Heartless is leaning town for both of us, and ETL has bulge as town for mostly meta reasons compared to his walls in SR London.
NM and Kaboose are mostly null, though I have them both as slightly more town than her. Kaboose's
19 makes me think he might be town (though I'm not convinced it's as strong an argument as TTH thinks), and NM isn't really making any effort to make his lurking appear active and engaged, which I would generally associate with him lurking as scum.
We disagree on prawn, whom ETL has as gut-town, while I think his empty questions aren't aimed at figuring out alignments. I don't think he's enough of a newb to justify that lack of direction, not to mention the terrible post 80, where he votes tier after calling his posts "arguably anti-town".
Neither of us have a good handle on esp. He doesn't like my attack of prawn's 80, when I wasn't the only one to call him out for it, which is pretty bad, but it's hard to tell if there's scummy intent with his lack of engagement.
VOTE: tier
-serra
![:]](./images/smilies/icon_smiling.png "Cheerful Smile"){kind=icon}