Butcher, Baker, Pastry-Maker Mafia - Dogged

[Nobody Special]

but who in this game actually brings the town wow

Hi.

[Andrius]

VoteCount

Seraphim [3] - Espeonage, tn5421, Gammagooey
tn5421 [2] - PeregrineV, Seraphim
Nobody Special [2] - Titus, Toon Fighter
Gammagooey [1] - Kalimar
PeregrineV [1] - dramonic

Not Voting [1] - Nobody Special

With 10 alive it takes 6 to lynch.

Deadline will be 3/26/2015, at 6pm PST.

No prods needed! Carry on, chatty pastries!

[Reina]

-gamma's dumb reasons for thinking people are town-

tn's reaction to shadow dancer being hammered seemed pretty genuine, and him 'mocking' shaft actually seemed way more like town poking at another player than actual scum cheekiness

NS looks slightly town just for being more active than he usually is (yes seriously, this is the first game i've ever seen of him where I wouldn't just call him useless), and his reads don't seem manufactured to me even though I think he's super completely wrong about TF

dram seems like the only sane active player left in this game and i'm also used to dram lurking through everything when ive seen him as scum and also maybe town too if i'm remembering right

pere is basically kali's reasons

sera had a good reaction to shadow dancer dying but looking back that could def. still being coming from scum i think. there might be one other reason i thought he was town but i'm not going back to check right now

the way tf was acted in his posts about reck and his claim are for serious town mindset. like i'd be astounded if scum decided to pull a gambit like that against a scumbuddy AND just not bother outing the result day 2. Leaves too much completely unknown about it, if reck gets lynched d2 without TF actually claiming then him saying he tracked reck after he gets lynched loses a lot of credibility in comparison to having him claim the result, especially with titus's filling claim already out there

kali's posts are kind of just gut town when he actually makes decent sized posts

pere looks MUCH better and more like he's scumhunting than when i've seen him as scum

and titus's thought processes just seem more likely to be coming from town than scum to me.

[Gammagooey]

-gamma's dumb reasons for thinking people are town-

tn's reaction to shadow dancer being hammered seemed pretty genuine, and him 'mocking' shaft actually seemed way more like town poking at another player than actual scum cheekiness

NS looks slightly town just for being more active than he usually is (yes seriously, this is the first game i've ever seen of him where I wouldn't just call him useless), and his reads don't seem manufactured to me even though I think he's super completely wrong about TF

dram seems like the only sane active player left in this game and i'm also used to dram lurking through everything when ive seen him as scum and also maybe town too if i'm remembering right

pere is basically kali's reasons

sera had a good reaction to shadow dancer dying but looking back that could def. still being coming from scum i think. there might be one other reason i thought he was town but i'm not going back to check right now

the way tf was acted in his posts about reck and his claim are for serious town mindset. like i'd be astounded if scum decided to pull a gambit like that against a scumbuddy AND just not bother outing the result day 2. Leaves too much completely unknown about it, if reck gets lynched d2 without TF actually claiming then him saying he tracked reck after he gets lynched loses a lot of credibility in comparison to having him claim the result, especially with titus's filling claim already out there

kali's posts are kind of just gut town when he actually makes decent sized posts

pere looks MUCH better and more like he's scumhunting than when i've seen him as scum

and titus's thought processes just seem more likely to be coming from town than scum to me.

alts are still hard

[Titus]

V_V

I suppose it's true. I think I've obvtowned exactly once in my history of playing forum mafia. Interestingly enough it was the time we hydra'd in that diffusion of power game.

That game is probably the closest I have come to obvtowning short of setup spec.

[Titus]

thats not very nice titus

That's just saying you do not obvtown. Hell the only obvtown atm to me makes zero sense.

hi

Hi.

[Espeonage]

try again you put in too much punctuation

[Gammagooey]

the other reason for thinking sera was slightly town was his comments on nika and his reasoning for not believing the miller claim, it sounds kinda like a genuine thought process. looking back it could be scum thinking that genuinely and thinking he was a different type of scum though. and with nikanor dead that might actually be a little in favor of that being the case.

[Gammagooey]

i think im maybe super cautiously actually optimistic about a sera lynch

[dramonic]

my main issue with the sera wagon is that it has espy and tn on it.

[Gammagooey]

espy is confirmed town you...

YOU

[Gammagooey]

like if you want to wait until pere posts some more stuff thats fine

but wagons having scummy people on them should basically never be a reason to not be on those wagons given how often people bus on this site

for serious

[dramonic]

I'm aware Espy is town.
So is the majority of the players.
Doesn't make them magically RELIABLE.
I get that his suspicion is genuine, but

espy

.

[tn5421]

my main issue with the sera wagon is that it has espy and tn on it.

I'm blatantly sheeping the confirmed town. If your problem with me then shouldn't you be poking me with inquiries and stuff?

[Titus]

my main issue with the sera wagon is that it has espy and tn on it.

Dram just obvtowned. I don't see scum pissing off the IC while most everyone is lost.

[Titus]

VOTE: PereV

[Espeonage]

I'm aware Espy is town.
So is the majority of the players.
Doesn't make them magically RELIABLE.
I get that his suspicion is genuine, but

espy

.

I think mastin did a thing once where she said I have among the most accurate gut on site.

[Espeonage]

Although my gut read is gamma.

[Espeonage]

my main issue with the sera wagon is that it has espy and tn on it.

Dram just obvtowned. I don't see scum pissing off the IC while most everyone is lost.

You have obviously never played with Dram and I in the same game together. He did nothing that moved him anywhere from null.

[Titus]

my main issue with the sera wagon is that it has espy and tn on it.

Dram just obvtowned. I don't see scum pissing off the IC while most everyone is lost.

You have obviously never played with Dram and I in the same game together. He did nothing that moved him anywhere from null.

Weren't you in House Party?

[PeregrineV]

guys can we get a bigger wagon going on NS so he stops derping around all the time?

Who are his 2 partners? (making the assumption of 4).

I'd guess gamma and Seph. What do you think and why do you ask?

We're only lynching scum-NS, and your reasons for scum-NS are "derping". That's not a strong argument, so want to see if you've done any other legwork to tie him to his scummates.

[Nobody Special]

The problem is that I

have

no scummates.

[PeregrineV]

my main issue with the sera wagon is that it has espy and tn on it.

I'm aware Espy is town.
So is the majority of the players.
Doesn't make them magically RELIABLE.
I get that his suspicion is genuine, but

espy

.

You just said one of the problems with the Sera wagon is that Espy and tn are on it. That implies you think Sera is town, and Espy and Tn are scum trying to mislynch him.

If your problem was that Espy is clueless, then you would have said your problem is Espy is on the wagon.

You lumped Espy and Tn together on why the wagon is bad. If you think TN is town trying to mislynch, then they would not have been lumped together, since Espy can't be scum.

Therefore, your 1159 does not match with your 1162.

[Gammagooey]

these assumed implications are dumb and not worth giving a damn about.

pere what makes tn a better lynch than Sera in your opinion?

[tn5421]

its because im glamorous