Kelbris
- I get what you are saying man, and I think most peoples problem with your statement isn’t the fact that you made it, its how far you went with it. I think that we could all pretty much post that we are going to be active when we can be, but there may be times where we are doing other things. You could probably get away with just saying where you live, or you could go crazy and actually put it in your information instead of putting the Internet. If I saw someone who lived in Australia playing my expectations would already be different for them. Also, no need to designate a vote as RVS during RVS. “that way you do not suddenly see me as "lurking" when in actuality I could be simply busy or preoccupied” Can you show where you were accused of lurking like this? And how would we determine the times where you are otherwise occupied or lurking? #65 ::facepalm::. Just ::facepalm::. Everything anyone said about how bad a decision you made is 100% correct, Wicked put it best though in #79. What makes you think that Slandaars post was a reaction test? How do you know it is a pointless one unless you understand what information he could possibly get from it? Your premise for believing that Slandaar was running a reaction test that early is flawed. Burn and Cheet both misunderstood something that Slandaar thought was self evident. Jesus Christ, it seems like he was making fun of you, that’s how I took it.
Slandaar
- I got the joke man, not sure how so many people were clueless about it. Do you think that was dumbassery or scum trying to jump on something little and missing something bigger?
Burn
- Did you feel the breeze when Slandaars joke flew over your head? Post #24 I need to make sure you didn’t mess up here “In fact I cant remember the last time I was in a game and we lynched someone because of inactivity and that person flipped town” because your first statement sounds like you think scum doesn’t lurk much, but the quoted one sounds like you lynch accurately off activity.
FA_Q2
- Do you find something scummy about voting for a wagon? Is everyone’s funny bones busted in this game? People are missing super obvious jests at people and taking it as scummy. Why did you avoid any of the votes that could have started a wagon? Have you played with Massive before? He will carry his weight, just worry about yourself for the time being and everything will be dandy. Decent questions to Cheet, you get some town points. You do seem to lack the ability to accurately identify OMGUS though. Massive simply looked at your iso to see if you were one to walk the walk or just talk the talk, he appears to have weighed and measured you and you have been found wanting.
Cheetory
- I really hope to see you improve as the game goes, I have read like the first 5 pages and am disappointed in your play so far. I am going to try to not discuss much of the misunderstanding because I saw that it gets cleared by around page 5, but Jesus man that whole line of investigation was all sorts of bad. I am having a hard time believing you didn’t get the joke because it was so apparent to me on my first read through that Slandaar was being facetious. Even in the face of people telling you that you are reading it wrong you kept it up for far longer than you should have. I wonder if this is a case of “scum sticking with a stupid read for longer than scum should, so he must be town” bullshit that most people believe. Also, I do find it funny you tell someone to retrace your thought process, but are unable to do so yourself. I hope you feel like kind of a dick for #31. I love when people are overly dickish because they think they understand something that others have missed and feel superior for it. #88 “Weps. I'm officially being shit this game. Sorry.” Admitting you have a problem is the first step in recovery. We are here for you Cheet. “Slandaar might be scum for how hard he’s trying to seem like he’s doing something useful […]not quicklynching someone who’s at least critically thinking.” These two thoughts don’t match up, explain. Why did you vote Fitz here? And wouldn’t you be an easy target at this point based on how thick you were being? If Fitz was scum you would sure be a juicy mislynch target at this point. Do you have examples of Randomidget being mislynch bait? So your question in #107 is what scum motivation could Randomidget have in his actions, correct? He could be white knighting a townie for cred, he could be soft defending a buddy with meta tells that he could easily explain away later. Those two things seem like decent scum motivation for his current actions. #113 Dat Food scum tell. In #120 you try to explain why you voted Slandaar over kelbris, but you use a post that you made before you realized that Slandaar was joking with his post. Now that you know that Slandaar was mocking Kelbris wouldn’t that change anything.
I probably should have checked the replace list first, goddamnit.
Randomidget
- I’ve heard of you, all good things. What is the “this” that you feel Kelbris does as town? When you made that statement Kelbris had all of one post. Do you have enough history with them to get a solid read off an intro post? #95 “He has a habit of explaining himself and posting weird semi-relevant stuff.” He made one post. You don’t think that he could make that same one post as scum? (I know that he has made more posts by the time you explain this a bit, but your read is based off his first post alone) #138 naked vote on Massive, why?
Seriously the whole Kelbris/Slandaar/Burn/Cheet circle jerk made me want to smash my head into my keyboard. I would also like explinations about where peoples heads were at with their naked votes on Slandaar. So that’d be Randomidget and Kelbris.
Viking
- How do you come in at post #36 and have nothing to say about what had been going on previously? How do you differentiate between scum and newbtown? What does it take to get a scum read for you? Your list had 5 town reads, 3 null reads, 3 nothings, and one possible scum.
Hodor
- How does someone saying that they normally get scumread for certain behavior stop people from scumreading them based off those tells? I have played with too many people who pull the whole “Woe is me… I always get scumread for doing X” schtick and it gets old quickly. If you do something that gets your scumread all the time change it or figure out a way to discern what alignment people are that are reading your that way. Saying I always get scumread for lurking does nothing to clear up alignment, any indication that you think it does should be banished to the land of bad fucking ideas.
Fitz
- Get out of my head man, everytime I pull something to comment on, I find you making the same post a few later on. I don’t see how Cheets replace is being seen as town, in fact I always have a hard time figuring out how anyone can see alignment in a replace out. Can you try to shed some light on this for me? I was scum reading Cheet and kinda see the same in his replace.
I stopped on Page 6. Finish tomorrow.
. Former, basically the only notable things so far is that randomidget isn't contributing that much so far, slandaar and riblet (your predecessor), have been at each other's throats, kelbris stupidly claimed townie on page 3 with absolutely no pressure whatsoever.
