New York 182 - Game Over

[TheFuzzylogic99]

Gork- why claim now. This is odd and has zero benefit Also since you claimed how do we know you are telling the truth and not fake claiming?

Thor..... So why are you and Elusive on the same vote seeing that you two are tunneling each other

[Gorkington]

Welcome to normal games my friend.

[Gorkington]

Tell me about what you like about MD's case on notscience.

Feel free to answer this too bae.

[elusive]

LOL, I didn't start with Thor, at least I don't think so I'm having trouble not mixing up games. Probably in too many of them.

Thor stop soft buddying me, it won't work.

Why is Seo scum and not mnemnic who 1. Didn't read the thread 2. Made cases without reading the thread 3. Sheeped scum's scum reads

I'll vote him once I can spell the name right.

[elusive]

*Wow I don't know why I keep saying "made cases" I mean "made reads list"

[OkaPoka]

mnemonicdevice
vote him up

[Marquis]

Marquis reads town to me

Marquis- Not enough posts for me to be conclusive here

VOTE: mnemonicdevice

[Marquis]

there's literally 2 pages between those

you can't legitimately have a townread on someone and 2 pages later suddenly think "no read, not enough posts"

[mnemonicdevice]

LOL, I didn't start with Thor, at least I don't think so I'm having trouble not mixing up games. Probably in too many of them.

Thor stop soft buddying me, it won't work.

Why is Seo scum and not mnemnic who 1. Didn't read the thread 2. Made cases without reading the thread 3. Sheeped scum's scum reads

I'll vote him once I can spell the name right.

1 and 2 rely on the false notion that I didn't read the thread, where did you get that from?
3 Who's reads did I sheep?

there's literally 2 pages between those

you can't legitimately have a townread on someone and 2 pages later suddenly think "no read, not enough posts"

There were 22 pages of reading done in between these posts.

See, on the first post, I had only read up to pg 8, whereas the other I read up to page 30.
I had a town read on you at pg 8

Well that doesn't work for me since i get reads out of interaction...
Unless you have some sort of deep reason to not want to interact with me.

i just feel whenever i interact with you i become... emotionally compromised

in other words i've formed townreads on you before without incident when you've been arguing things that aren't a scumread on me or that i'm wrong and just. i'm probably going to need some space to breathe. i don't want you to think i hate you but i think playing together works better like this.

because of this post mostly

but then by page 30 I was unsure of that read; I wanted more content before I placed a read on you again.

[elusive]

You 1. Didn't know my gender but claim to have read my posts 2. Didn't realize Sakura was FOSing me or had a 1 vs. 1 with me but backed off until I pointed it out

[mnemonicdevice]

@elusive: Since I assume you have read the thread, can you name the gender of all the players in this game, without looking back?

[elusive]

No, but If I had read my posts then I would be able to tell due to the content. I would not be able to form a read on anyone in thread without reading the content of their posts carefully. You highlighted me as scum, so you must have read my content but from your lack of knowing my gender you did not read the content of my posts or peruse them carefully enough to be able to come up with a scum read.

Ergo, there is something rotten in the state of Denmark. Or perhaps your reads list.

Also from what I can tell Seo is the only femme other then Sakura who died. Everyone else is male or gender neutral.

[Thor665]

Thor why not otolia/mnemoic device?

You have asked me that before.
I answered with 'I don't understand the case for Otolia scum'.
My answer has not changed.

I was arguing that it felt like Sakura might have been annoyed at Otolia playing badly as her scummate and that may have been seeping in to her push on him.

I do not really see that energy there, and it feels like an incredibly archaic hook to hang a case on regardless.
Do you have good accuracy making cases based on that sort of stuff?

Not sure how this is answering the accusation .... This feel like just dismissing the point all together.

Yes...dismissing it does qualify as "answering it" when the accusation itself is kind of a joke.

Can you clarify the "question" of the accusation that you think I need to address?
Or why it makes sense to you?
Or...y'know...anything to justify why I can't dismiss it based on the evidence of me flat out calling out my "scumbuddy" on sloppy distancing and sheeping of me and calling him scummy for doing it - thereby kind of defeating the point of the maneuver and shooting my team in the foot in the process?

Thor..... So why are you and Elusive on the same vote seeing that you two are tunneling each other

Frankly I expect there to be multiple scum teams, so him voting Anti, even if I thought it was an act of distancing (which you seem to fiully expect and understand scum can do) would not translate it as proof that Anti is not scum regardless.

Why, how do you think I should have reacted? Immediately unvote my top scum read to vote my second one because he was voted by the second one?
How does that make sense?

there's literally 2 pages between those

you can't legitimately have a townread on someone and 2 pages later suddenly think "no read, not enough posts"

I mildly like this case, though find the defense reasonable and thus not particularly sheepable.

What's your take on my Anti+Sakura case?

[Thor665]

Thor why not otolia/mnemoic device?

You have asked me that before.
I answered with 'I don't understand the case for Otolia scum'.
My answer has not changed.

I was arguing that it felt like Sakura might have been annoyed at Otolia playing badly as her scummate and that may have been seeping in to her push on him.

I do not really see that energy there, and it feels like an incredibly archaic hook to hang a case on regardless.
Do you have good accuracy making cases based on that sort of stuff?

Not sure how this is answering the accusation .... This feel like just dismissing the point all together.

Yes...dismissing it does qualify as "answering it" when the accusation itself is kind of a joke.

Can you clarify the "question" of the accusation that you think I need to address?
Or why it makes sense to you?
Or...y'know...anything to justify why I can't dismiss it based on the evidence of me flat out calling out my "scumbuddy" on sloppy distancing and sheeping of me and calling him scummy for doing it - thereby kind of defeating the point of the maneuver and shooting my team in the foot in the process?

Thor..... So why are you and Elusive on the same vote seeing that you two are tunneling each other

Frankly I expect there to be multiple scum teams, so him voting Anti, even if I thought it was an act of distancing (which you seem to fiully expect and understand scum can do) would not translate it as proof that Anti is not scum regardless.

Why, how do you think I should have reacted? Immediately unvote my top scum read to vote my second one because he was voted by the second one?
How does that make sense?

there's literally 2 pages between those

you can't legitimately have a townread on someone and 2 pages later suddenly think "no read, not enough posts"

I mildly like this case, though find the defense reasonable and thus not particularly sheepable.

What's your take on my Anti+Sakura case?

[elusive]

ANSWER ME NMENOMIC

Also, Thor what is your take on NEMNOMC

[Thor665]

Also, Thor what is your take on NEMNOMC

I mildly like this case, though find the defense reasonable and thus not particularly sheepable.

[Seohyun]

I'm not good with your vote though.
VOTE: Seohyun

Why did you take so long to get on this wagon given that you were on it on D1?
Why is slightly townreading ZZZX being off the only thing you have to say about him?
Are you going to be a bish like pisskop and ignore questions because you think you're better than everyone else in the game?

Let me know .

But I already said earlier in the thread I love answering questions! It's my hobby.
1. Because I don't like hopping onto wagons when everyone else seems so eager to do so.
2. Because the other people with minimal posts he simply said, "no posts" or some variation. But why is zzzx town for posting less than the other people he mentioned as having no posts? zzzx has basically only posted about how many pages he has to read and that droog's posts give him a headache. I've been suspicious ofc of otolia and now I'm suspicious of the replacement. So there's my vote now.

Is ZZZX the only one of my reads you disagree with?

No, I disagree with your elusive and house read so far.
Which zzzx post was it that made you think town?

[Seohyun]

I guess ill take marquis word here

What if he was lying though

[Flubbernugget]

Also, Thor what is your take on NEMNOMC

I mildly like this case, though find the defense reasonable and thus not particularly sheepable.

You have no response to what marquis pointed out?

[ika]

elusive, calm down for a moment.

stop getting all riled and do the simple question game agian with people and talk to me about who you think is scum right now

[Thor665]

Also, Thor what is your take on NEMNOMC

I mildly like this case, though find the defense reasonable and thus not particularly sheepable.

You have no response to what marquis pointed out?

You are literally reading my response to what Marquis pointed out.

elusive, calm down for a moment.

stop getting all riled and do the simple question game agian with people and talk to me about who you think is scum right now

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 0#p6697100
http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 2#p6697112

???

[TheFuzzylogic99]

Unvote Thor

I am ok with your answers.... Not sure if your are town or not but I feel no need to pressure you anymore

Gork
Again why claim.... Bc its a Norm game is a pretty weak answers. Also you could be lying... Why shouldn I lynch you up???? It seem very very likely there is a second scum team in this game

[Gorkington]

http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Normal_Game

Mechanics which are explicitly Non-Normal include:

Those affecting a role's alignment

(no Cults)

.

I wonder whether I'm lying or not.

[Gorkington]

Fuzzy is playing so awkwardly that it makes my head spin trying to imagine him as town or mafia.
Zzzz.

[ika]

@thor im not going to get into smatic battles. so im going to cut it altogether and ask you one simple question: do you think shes scum even though she is voting with you? simple yes or no.

as for her offsite games thats entirely her if she wants to bring them or not she has told em before that she rather not bring up her past for [reasons here]