Tier read was stated above the list. I'd feel much more confident labeling him as scum after seeing a shos scumflip, though I think he is scum.
tbh, I have two strong scumreads so I'm reading a fair number of players as town by extension of that. I'm certain that you're town, I think rhino is town, and PERKYPHYSICS is probtown too. I haven't read any of reck posts but I expect him to be easy to read. I don't feel Yak will be a problem to read, and ceph is probably dumbtown.
LLD I'm wary of right now. She apparently coined to get scum according to someone?, which differed from my expectations. Her logic right now is not making sense and her insistence on cupcakeblood is suspect and deviates from her usual townplay.
Fluffy fluffy~~~ |
"READING KATSUKI IS LIKE SOME SORT OF POSTMODERN ARTFORM"
- GreyICE
Katsuki is by far more absurdly beautiful than Fate. (hai parama)
Katsuki's Madness coming to you shortly: Nov, 2011!
I do have a weaker 3rd scumread but I don't want to lock myself into it yet because it'll end up with me approaching the game with a confirmation bias.
Fluffy fluffy~~~ |
"READING KATSUKI IS LIKE SOME SORT OF POSTMODERN ARTFORM"
- GreyICE
Katsuki is by far more absurdly beautiful than Fate. (hai parama)
Katsuki's Madness coming to you shortly: Nov, 2011!
YOU KNOW EXACTLY WHAT CUPCAKE IS TRYING TO SAY, AND IF YOU THINK SOMEONE IS SCUM FOR BUSSING, LYNCHING THEM BEFORE THE PERSON BEING BUSSED IS STRAIGHT UP RETARDED. IT'S PRETTY FUCKING CLEAR THAT IF YOU STEP BACK FOR A SECOND, YOU'LL REALIZE THAT THIS'LL BE ONE OF THOSE LYNCHES WHERE YOU GO "WELP, WHY THE FUCK DID WE DO THAT" WHEN YOU END UP WITH A KATSTOWNFLIP IF IT GOES THROUGH.
SHOS PLAY IS
VERY
INDICATIVE OF SCUM AND LYNCHING KATS INSTEAD BECAUSE 'KATSUKI IS BEING KATSUKI' IS REALLY REALLY DUMB.
(also mean things HERE about me for stating that reading the game will negatively affect my reads, which is not dumb at all)
LOVE,
GOOEYGAMMA
Stop breaking the rules and start telling me why shos's play is very indicative of scum.
I am so dumb, how dare I suspect you, that is just the stupidest thing ever.
You seem to be under the mistaken impression that I'm only scumreading you because I think you're bussing shos. Which is yet another demonstration that you aren't reading my posts.
In post 473, Katsuki wrote:(also mean things HERE about me for stating that reading the game will negatively affect my reads, which is not dumb at all)
Yes it is. I have not heard anything dumber today.
Oversoul says kats lurks more as town than scum, which is the basis for my meta book on kats as well. It helped me read kats correctly as town in /invitational 13 but that was 2 years ago. OS and I are both kinda confused about the emotions coming out of kats' posts. OS doesn't know how to read it, but I'm starting to think it sounds more like scumkats in TM2012 than the townkats I know. I'm definitely not getting the warm fuzzies I had playing with townkats. However, Tammy says kats has been doing the aggressive style all caps posting shtick as town lately so it makes me question the reliability of my meta on kats. None of my team has suggested pursuing a kats lynch today. I disagree with LLD, I think kats gets easier to read as the game goes on.
I'm more interested in how the wagon on shos dissolved. LLD at least still seems to think shos is scum but is going after the bigger fish. Is this how others feel as well, or do people think shos is town? I'm completely in agreement with kats feelings regardings shos, in that this going back to page 1 and basically doing a pbpa style rehash of everything is so pointless and really to me comes across as scum trying to appear to be useful but not really doing anything. I mean, we're like not even a week into the game. Things are still be felt out in real time. There is no new information to give context to anything said on page 4 in a reread analysis. The fact he is just trudging on with no care at all of staying current in the thread tells me he's not interested at all in finding scum - only appearing to be scumhunting.
Go read through Cabd's iso then come back to me and with a straight face tell me "yeah that's a town iso"
like it's just bad. it's terrible. half of it is the stupid early game distractothon and half of it is awful reads with very little in the way of reasoning
seriously, after pages of content, he fires back with blanket town reads on me/mollie/Ceph. And his reasons boil down to LOL REACTIONS. Mollie had only been in the game for like one page and Cabd engages in Who WIFOM to explain his read. It's terrible. It's fucking terrible.
"copper fading on me makes sense" turns into "SLEPT ON IT, HE'S SCUM, REASONS LATER"
The Who thing is maybe the one thing I do like from him, but mollie's actual posts were already a much better reason to townread the slot at that point.
I am underwhelmed by him giving me an easy townread, meta or no meta. It's very possible he would think that he had to townread me as scum, but he knows I kick ass at scum, so I would expect much more paranoia on me. There is some possibility this is being overcome by arrogance and I mean that in the most affectionate way possible.
If he was energetic about his copper case and excited about this game changing theory then I'd expect him to have actually come back and posted it last night as promised.
"awful reads with very little in the way of reasoning" is also a pretty good description of shos' posts.
But yeah you're not wrong, I just have bigger fish to fry
