A 'massive' Demon
An argument for expelling massive back to the firey pits of Hell from whence he came
Written by: Yours Truly
massive 242 wrote:Is it important that you not interact with Bulge? Do you think semantics are something that shouldn't be discussed in general?
Leading question followed up by a pointless one. This wouldn't be so bad if he followed through with it and showed more initiative at trying to read either SH or Bulge. He does not do this.
massive 256 wrote:I could sheep farside.
VOTE: ArcAngel9
I don't know where he's coming from with this. I'm bias as I'm now comfortable coming out in favor of AA9 town, but even at the time this seemed haphazard. Why follow farside (he explains this later after naturally being asked)? Why AA9 over Elbin (farside's other scumread)?
I don't think it's good practice to leave an impression of people having more questions about you than assumptions. Further, at this point it's too late in the day to be coasting like he is. massive knows better than this.
massive 274 wrote:Because I at least trust you to have been following the game completely.
This really sets off a red flag to me. This is not a good explanation, and I said as much in
284. farside following the game completely seems like it says nothing about her alignment. I also don't like that massive has yet to ask one question of AA9 himself, nor has he addressed the Kat-AA9 situation. This vote has scum written all over it.
massive 348 wrote:I've only played with AA9 once before, and she replaced into a game in the late-game stages. Does she always do this ATE stuff? Oh I take that back, twice. Both late replaces, one has the ATE right before getting mislynched as town (but directed at one person). I imagine there's plenty of meta to look at.
He finally brings up an accusation to lob against AA9. He has meta of AA9 doing a lot of ATE. Kind of like she's doing now (regardless as to whether you think she was provoked or not, leave that aside). He then admits that she was lynched in that game and flipped town. As though he subconsciously realizes that might be a silly thing to admit, he hastens to add "but I bet she has a lot of meta!", implying that her meta of ATE as town is useless.
This whole paragraph reads to me like a mistake. I can only imagine that massive assumed that no one would bother to really look into his vote very closely and either lufan or AA9 would be lynched.
His comment about AA9 being scum upset for being caught for the wrong reason is fair, but I just disagree with it.
massive 500 wrote:I mean, you can go ahead and say "OMGUS." It's pretty obvious to everybody else.
Here he non-ironically uses OMGUS as a scumtell.
Further, the guy just hasn't commented on anything relevant that isn't AA9. Nothing about lufan, Kat, Muffin vs Gaiden, any unique ideas about potential plans... nada.
Let me tl;dr this:
1) Very, very little in the way of scumhunting. Ignores responses to questions he's asked of others. Has not taken the time to do any independent scumhunting of his own.
2) Attaches himself prematurely to farside. When confronted about this, is only able to come up with some mush about how he trusts farside to be reading the game (which has no bearing on her alignment).
3) Admits that his only meta experience with AA9 is when she acted very similarly and flipped town due to a mislynch, but tries to confuse the meta situation by asking for "other's experiences".
4) Using OMGUS as a scumtell. Ever.
5) General lurking and neglecting to comment on or participate in discussion surrounding anything relevant that isn't AA9.
