Open 595: Elemental Mafia (Town Wins!)

[Plotinus]

@Bella: right. That's why I used it as an example of the trouble with expecting every newbie to behave like the average newbie. I guess the flip side is that everyone's going to find different things scummy, so in one game you get townread for things and in another you get scumread for the same things.

and yeah, it's a big enough game. flailing about if someone puts you at L-8 is silly. maybe some people do it anyway, but it's still silly.

[Plotinus]

that was regarding 295 if it wasn't clear.

[farside22]

I'm not sure what the issue is with 44, but hey, to each his own and all that.
I think it's unfair to dismiss my suspicions of Bella as an OMGUS purely because she has voted for me. Look at her vote on me: it's very opportunist, and as soon as she drops it, she slithers away from people's suspicions. Speaking very frankly, it's a pain in the arse feeling like you can't provide an opinion on someone because it'll be dismissed out of hand on this basis. I'm also not the first to point out how convenient her vote was.

She didn't slither. That is very misrep's a player big time.

@farside, because what I read is in line with how I'm reading her now.

@ricastle... what? why did i think there were more than one faction? Cause I was just thinking the fire water and whatever other one were not teammates. What's the difference why I thought that?

Your going to have to explain more then that.

[lane0168]

I'm not going to have to explain anything. I have my vote on her for reasons I've already specified clearly. I read around a bit and I'm even more satisfied with my Vote. Simple as that.

[Bellaphant]

@plot, that's clearer, thanks.
@lane, if you weren't going to explain your comment, why make it?

[lane0168]

To let people know I am firm in my reads and my vote wont be going anywhere soon

[farside22]

Well I'm not moving from con so.....

Bela: can you explain why ric reads town.

[Alchemist21]

BlueBloodedToffee replaces Mnemonicdevice.

TheReverend replaces Spartan117.

[Alchemist21]

VC 1.6

(3)ConManMick:

Flubbernugget, Bellaphant, farside

(2)Flubbernugget:

ConManMick, FA_Q2

(2)lane0168:

Ricastle, Wrong Song

(1)Bellaphant:

lane

(1)Vettrock:

Papi Bear

(1)Jeanne:

Vettrock

Not Voting: Jeane11, Spartan117, mnemonicdevice, Choof, Senator, Plotinus

With 16 alive it takes 9 to lynch.

Deadline is in (expired on 2015-05-03 12:00:00)

[Senator]

@FA_Q2

Didn't you

just

say Spartan was V/LA?

This is actually starting to sound bad.

Agreed.

I am beginning to think this was a straight up slip. Con is a good lynch candidate for day one IMHO. We really need to hear from Spartan.

Let's say that Conman really slipped. That would imply that they scum together, right? So why would questioning spartan about this have yielded anything but an easy lie?
Can you summarize your reason for keeping your vote on Flubber?

Conman

Farside, what was my post 244 if not a provision of reads? I thought I made it clear: I suspect flubber and Bella.
I'm also not sure I understand your issue with me being too "wordy".

So you scumread Flubber and Bella, and have 3 weak townreads?
Who are those townreads? Weak townreads are perfectly okay, because they create discussion, and others can see what you do.

Lane

So... quick question. If spartan is replaced. What do we do about con?

I think the 'slip' was a weak reason to wagon him. His response to the pressure is more important.

Bella

I like(d) the questions Ric was asking and I can see him moving the thread on. Apart from wrong's back and forth, I think he's one of the players that has asked the most pertinent questions to try and 'sort' the game. I dunno if he's at times over aggressive with some of his ideas, but with the amount of absent players we need things moving forwards.

What do you think of Wrong Song thus far?

[Senator]

I find Ric, Farside, and Plotinus townier than not.
I'm less sure about FA_Q2, Conman, Bella, and Lane, although I consider them to get scummier in that order.
I am worried about the fixation Wrong Song has over Conman's overreaction to his one vote in RVS. That is literally the only claim to content they have.

[farside22]

With people town reading ric, I wonder if he just rubs me the wrong way with his personality.
That happens with me from time to time.

[TheReverend]

It's REVEREND TIME!!!

Well actually it will be after I've slept.

Sup farside. It's DOMO. Fill me in. Who's scummy?

[Alchemist21]

Papi bear has been prodded. RationalMadman replaces Jeanne11

[RationalMadman]

Please bold my name

Hello all.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Hey, just an ego post so game is in my list.

Will get around to it as soon as I have time.

I haven't read a single word. Just seen the last VC...

VOTE: ConManMick

[choof]

turns out that I'm actually not busy tomorrow so I'm gonna pour another drink and do a comprehensive post
however I will say that this post

I haven't read a single word. Just seen the last VC...

VOTE: ConManMick

is really fucking awful

welcome to the game, somehow you managed to make your first post in the game the most scummiest thing so far

[Papi Bear]

Woah!!! God!!!!... 13 pages already???

I'm really sorry guys... -_-

Well, I've read the thread (from 3-6) and I tried to post my thoughts about it.... but suddenly, duty calls. Anyway, it would be nice to give me your reads up to this point to help me get back on track. I'll be rereading the thread again later today so giving reads will be a LOT of help for me so I can focus on important points only.

If I fail to post tommorow, I would ask for a replacement...

[Papi Bear]

Hey, just an ego post so game is in my list.

Will get around to it as soon as I have time.

I haven't read a single word. Just seen the last VC...

VOTE: ConManMick

dat BS vote tho...

[choof]

Woah!!! God!!!!... 13 pages already???

I'm really sorry guys... -_-

Well, I've read the thread (from 3-6) and I tried to post my thoughts about it.... but suddenly, duty calls. Anyway, it would be nice to give me your reads up to this point to help me get back on track. I'll be rereading the thread again later today so giving reads will be a LOT of help for me so I can focus on important points only.

If I fail to post tommorow, I would ask for a replacement...

I'm writing up a post tonight while drinking
you shouldn't have an issue doing the same

[ConManMick]

Fair enough Bella, I withdraw my comments.
BBT, have you honestly just jumped on the largest wagon purely on the basis of it being the largest? Granted, only three other players but still, that's a hell of a way to enter a game.
Regards to town reads, I thought I posted them already, lemme check really quick.

[RationalMadman]

Tbh, I suggest a policy lynch of a lurker d1. Town that doesn't contribute should be gotten rid of and if they happen to be maf it's a bonus.

[ConManMick]

If we go about policy lynching, however, we could potentially put strain on ourselves. It'll make things easier for the scum players if we lynch people for the sake of it rather than actually suspectung them of being scum. Strikes me as a tad counterintuitive.

[ConManMick]

Suspecting* sorry, predictive text on mobile keeps changing suffixes

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Will be catching up with this soon.

If you don't like my vote, don't complain.

Vote me.