Battlestar Galactica Mafia - Game over!

[Porochaz]

Angry so should we lynch all the people who voted bro? Is that ur plan?

Nice of u and nero to come derail.

I have come up with a theory, but it would involve revealing potentially 2 people. If I am correct, and I hope to god(s) I am, then it is a very cool mechanic, a bit mean, but cool.

Oh, the reason I quoted this. Just that their is a lot of drivel coming from this direction, I had hoped it would stop day 2, but if I have to go through another 5 pages of this I may throw another tantrum.

[AngryPidgeon]

Please read the rest of the game.
I'm Ellen Tigh, I'm in the same boat as Snow. We can't both be sleepers. There's no point in him flavourclaiming right now.

I know full well what you claimed. There is a pretty big difference between Ellen and other people in the show.

[Porochaz]

^
useless post

[Porochaz]

i think you might be scum, friend. i particularly didn't like that you flipped your read on sangres after their reads list. i disliked sangres scum reads (in ooba and well, at the time BRO - i thought bro was town).

So why do you still think I'm scum for liking his reads then? You disagreed with his scum reads but he was correct on half of them.

So, back to flavor spec... I think this game takes place mostly during the Pegasus era of BSG.

People were stuck on Caprica for d1 so no. I'm assuming it's just "BSG-themed" with no particular timeframe.

Screen: Lady Lambdadelta.

I stand by the idea that we should screen players with low post counts.
ValiliaRei should claim as well now. Make sure we get a screen in before lynching.

We should not screen players who don't A. play, B. read or C. give a flying fuck about the game.

It's a waste.

[AngryPidgeon]

Whatever, I'm fine with screening Sangres. Anything to prevent Day 2 from becoming a circlejerk when we have a claimed guilty on scum.

[Porochaz]

@Snowstorm: During the discussion of show-Cylon status and Cylon flavour in the rolePM, did you never check your own character to see which it was in the show? Why not, if not?

I never checked. My PM did a pretty good job at convincing me my character was human.

Im opening the same can of worms here but this is the second time today I've gone, "hold on, thats pretty fucking scummy"

Surely your role name along would tell you that?

[ValiliaRei]

I did target Tammy at night. I used a one-shot ability to make her strong-willed for that night. It wouldn't have worked regardless because it only works on people who had ever served aboard Pegasus and she had claimed Helena Cain, but was actually Admiral Adama. The reason I targeted her was because she was mentioning Andrius (who was breadcrumbing Adama) being someone she needed to find, and since I couldn't figure him out and I had a town read on her I was going to help her do whatever she needed to do. If it had worked she also would have been told by the mod that I inspired her, and that would've been helpful, too.

I'm going back and re-reading today's posts, I've just skimmed them so far.

VOTE: ooba

[Porochaz]

So Nikanor also looks scummy, the things that are saving him are the mechanics of his role rather than he is saying.
I cannot stand RIP's posting, its arrogant but probably town (and wrong)
Snowstorm is becoming increasingly scummy but it could be the newb-vibes again.
Im okay with the new players as a whole, they seem to bring sense to the proceedings.
Im not sure what to do with LLD, it really bug me, that she refuses to actually do something in this game.

Here LLD, if you aren't going to actually play, don't take up a slot. I doubt its fun to you, its actively detracting from the game for us and I'm not sure what the point of joining was in the first place, if you are going to do this.

Nero still pings the scumdar for generic reasons.
I don't see the sangres thing, will have to relook.
ooba is likely town, there is the slightest chance it could be Brian but is almost certainly Valilia. The way ooba claimed is pretty town. So I'll leave my vote placeholder here.

As for screening, Im happy with AP or sangres. Again, I don't really care.

screen AP

[Porochaz]

What does making someone strongwilled do?

[ValiliaRei]

They can't be roleblocked.

[Porochaz]

I think I still prefer ooba's claim.

[RIP]

Read up to page 54.
I'm gonna nuke from the Vallilia wagon.
That's a dirty freaking wagon my god.

Nika and Brian making sense.
Btw

Do not get run over here.
Be back later

[RIP]

Screen: Sangres

I do think this is the best idea for today. I could also support a screen on NotAnAxehole.

Boo I have reason to believe u and axe are villager or town. Can we work together?

[Mantisdreamz]

Read up to page 54.
I'm gonna nuke from the Vallilia wagon.
That's a dirty freaking wagon my god.

Nika and Brian making sense.
Btw

Do not get run over here.
Be back later

brian is the one that called out valilia as scum. >.>

[AngryPidgeon]

I'd PL RIP at this point I guess.

[ValiliaRei]

@ooba

- If you were looking for Roslin, why did you target Tammy who was claiming Helena Cain? What made you think she might be Roslin?

[SnowStorm]

@Snowstorm: During the discussion of show-Cylon status and Cylon flavour in the rolePM, did you never check your own character to see which it was in the show? Why not, if not?

I never checked. My PM did a pretty good job at convincing me my character was human.

Im opening the same can of worms here but this is the second time today I've gone, "hold on, thats pretty fucking scummy"

Surely your role name along would tell you that?

What's scummy about it?

I don't see how my role name should provide information on whether or not my character was a cylon on the show.

And I'm not a "newb".

[THE WRONG WAGON]

Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm at VR's claim.

Mulling it over.

Will be back later, still trying to get into contact w/ GM

~WS

[ValiliaRei]

@ooba

- If you were looking for Roslin, why did you target Tammy who was claiming Helena Cain? What made you think she might be Roslin?

And

@Porochaz

- Why didn't this strike you as odd?

My TOWN bloc after yesterday's events:
ValiliaRei (the original vote on BRO for noticing the wincon)
Nikanor (the flavor information was key to my push on BRO)
sangres (pushed BRO when BRO was off the table for a while)

I was not the original vote - Bookitty was. Why isn't she in your town bloc?

^That vote is interchangeable with valila right now.

So reading bro tells me that.

Boo kitty, nikanor most likely, ooba and damn my quote broke so I need to go check who else is like Obv town.
Oh Tammy Obv but she died. She was first pushing bro and bro called her conf town. After his flip she was so she died.

BRO only called Tammy "sort of town" in Post #172. Can you point to where he called her conf-town?
Bookitty was the one he was calling town so much.

Angry so should we lynch all the people who voted bro? Is that ur plan?

Nice of u and nero to come derail.

Probably, yes.

Screen: Val

VOTE: Nikanor

Bad vote I think. Bro was pushing her lots

BRO was calling Nikanor town - what's going on with messing up BRO's reads on people?

Right I went over it briefly in the private PT with Mantis and AP.

I wasn't fond exactly of his first post in the game, although, it was more of a gut read on that part. VR's sheeping of Andy's flavor thing felt scum like bussing over a 'scum slip'.

If I am right I think GM has a scum read on VR too, although I'm not certain about that and would have to dig deeper in our hydra PT in regards to it.

~WS

Are you talking about my post saying I don't think the screen would lie to us? Why is that scummy? I also wasn't sheeping Andrius's flavor thing. I voted for BRO before he did and I've always maintained from the beginning that race = alignment while Andrius went back and forth on that.

[AngryPidgeon]

Actually before we ride this raptor all the way to earth, I'd like to mention that Brian could be a Mafia Watcher.

[Nero Cain]

^
useless post

What do you think of the hydra trying to write Brian's guilty off as fake? If you find this scummy, why is it useless of me to point this out? If you don't find it scummy then explain to me what the town motivation is for WS to try and write of as "this is fake"?

[Brian Skies]

Brian, why did you think it was ooba at first?

They were both similar reads for me and I just decided to gamble and hope I could trap one of them in a botched fakeclaim. I originally thought it was Ooba because I thought Valilla's push against Bro may have been more likely to come from town. Ooba was screened (which would encourage him to make the nightkill if he were scum expecting to be publicly revealed) and he also had a townread on Tammy. He didn't seem to be a protective role (because Tammy died and he was perfectly fine with being the "nightkill" when he screen voted himself), and I couldn't think of many other roles he could be to visit Tammy. A seeking flavor role makes some sense but I have no idea who Elosha or Roslin are. I think Valilla also makes sense as NK'ing scum just because not very many people have suspected her and people have been saying she'd be easy to read.

There were a few options I had in mind for my N1 target, but I chose Tammy because that's who I would have killed if I were scum afraid of a watcher.

I thought about waiting a bit to see what would happen and if "Baltar" wanted to claim his result on Ooba, but I just decided frak it, I'm probably not getting another guilty result and I could probably extend his life for at least another day. Also, look at how adorable my character is in today's opening flavor.

ooba is likely town,

there is the slightest chance it could be Brian

but is almost certainly Valilia.

Yes, I'm going to sacrifice myself to lynch two players I could easily have mislynched on my own.

I could be!

Read up to page 54.
I'm gonna nuke from the Vallilia wagon.
That's a dirty freaking wagon my god.

Nika and Brian making sense.
Btw

Do not get run over here.
Be back later

brian is the one that called out valilia as scum. >.>

And he 'cleared' me too. I'm disappointed in the lack of sheeping from his direction.

Normally I'd be pretty unhappy with the Sangres screen wagon, but I'm probably dying tonight, so I don't really care. AP's a good option if you're looking for a town leader that some people might have trouble reading. I really want screens on LLD, Rip, or Axe, but once again, I'm probably dying tonight, so my opinion is less important.

Valilla never claimed flavor.

I had some flavor in my role PM that expressed self-uncertainty.

[Brian Skies]

Also, if there is a ninja:
1) Whoops.
2) Take a look at this guy.

[Nero Cain]

I would not be that surprised if WS is scum and knew that Ooba was town and was writing Brian's guilty off as "fake" b/c she knew it was town. I think Poro is just fucking junk and not scum.

Sangres may verywell be scum with how she sorta ignored the case on Vallia.

[THE WRONG WAGON]

I've read the first 5 pages, then suddenly life exploded. I just finished skimming the rest of D1 and reading D2. I plan to ISO BRO at some point, but probably not tomorrow because I'm going to the beach for Mother's Day.

SO.

A lot of things I agree with WS on, like sangres and Mantis. I have a slightly stronger townread on AP than WS does I think.
Minor townreads include Nik, maybe Porochaz?
Minor scumreads include Andrius, Boo, Toogeloo, and, most recently, Nero.
Some of these are slightly outdated so idk.

I'd be inclined to vote VR over ooba.

-gm