how does "doduo wasn't in my game" make him scum? even discounting the fact it was possible (given you knew Marquis was in another game) he was following along with the other team mafia games - why, specifically, do you think him referencing the game you were in is more likely to come from scum than town?
I'm seeing the case on MS but it's not enough to push for a lynch there yet. I'm getting a couple of twinges about others but nothing worth mentioning yet as I don't know them well enough to know whether it's significant.
elaborate? it's fine if you don't know whether it's significant or not yet
In post 50, Honey bee wrote:Ehh maybe. He's giving me a goofy impression so it's hard for me to state it as forced or just not trying. I don't know him, so i guess I'm taking that impressoin with a grain of salt. I don't think he would have mistaken the recruitment thing as something else as scum though.
In post 132, Metal Sonic wrote:alchey would have been more engaged/excited about this game at this point in time
i dont see that right now
I've had 1 game with him as scum and he was pretty fucking engaged there. and iirc he prefers scum over town (? correct me if I'm wrong)?
I would like him to do more, but I'm not sure the lack of engagement here means anything and I haven't really had a problem with anything he's posted so far. is this a meta read, or... ?
the rest is kind of redeeming, I suppose. I could potentially see myself agreeing on Bee, but I want him to do more first. Doduo's thought process isn't inconsistent; given I don't really intend to read people based on recruiting-related things, I think it makes sense for someone to assume at first you weren't the recruiter and then push you anyway based on play.
there's still a bunch of people who I'd like to see more from -.-
In post 133, pieguyn wrote:I've had 1 game with him as scum and he was pretty fucking engaged there. and iirc he prefers scum over town (? correct me if I'm wrong)?
yea i know he likes scum more than town
but his town game usualy has him figuring out stuff early.
In post 134, pieguyn wrote:Doduo's thought process isn't inconsistent; given I don't really intend to read people based on recruiting-related things, I think it makes sense for someone to assume at first you weren't the recruiter and then push you anyway based on play.
this is the game I played with Alch as scum. it looked like he was capable of figuring shit out early here. I'm waiting to see more from him as well, but either way, I don't particularly think this is a tell by itself.
this is the game I played with Alch as scum. it looked like he was capable of figuring shit out early here. I'm waiting to see more from him as well, but either way, I don't particularly think this is a tell by itself.
I'm looking through it again and I still have no idea what you're seeing here. I think his read on you is a really shit reason for scum reading him (I'm aware you have a lot of experience with each other, but I'm pretty sure I've read you right in every game we've had (?) - so I don't have a problem with him scum reading you for the same reason), and I don't mind the rest of his posts, either.
needless to say this doesn't make him town, but if I scum read him it will likely be for other reasons
i'm decently unhappy with his shift from policy lynching me to "nacho will slay the scumteam", although rationale for that is explained by me having a timer thanks to my flavor claim
i don't really like his townread on pieguy
his townread on honey bee is strange: i had a thought that it could be ms townreading the scumpartner who recruited him,
but honey bee does look ok individually and so it's still mainly a thought in the back of my mind
@Nacho, the bolded part seems pretty specific. What makes you think it could come specifically from a player being recruited? Why was it more likely to be scum-scum?
I've seen scum have flimsy and awkward early townreads on Town before (granted this was typically from a scum player who didn't know the Town player), and I could see this kind of early read coming from Town as well.
In post 134, pieguyn wrote:Doduo's thought process isn't inconsistent; given I don't really intend to read people based on recruiting-related things, I think it makes sense for someone to assume at first you weren't the recruiter and then push you anyway based on play.
doduo is posting garbage lol
and this is coming from me
I smell butthurt
"The brains in its two heads appear to communicate emotions to each other with a telepathic power."
In post 97, Doduo wrote:in team mafia he did the same whole "post a lot in sequence bc hahaha this spam and trolling is typical ms and i dont want to lose this game by mislynching him bc thats way too easy to do" (it's no)
In post 99, Doduo wrote:he's trying to be "what a dumb spammer metal sonic is, posting so much and not knowing anything"
and ms is not dumb
I thought it was safe because I figured me, you, Sonic were going to be on most people's recruit shortlists, and I assumed his reasoning would be something along the lines of play ability, but I'm now informed that assumption wasn't correct.
MS?
really?
You saw him in Team Mafia go pretty damn far in a Nightless game as scum. Why are you surprised by Nacho saying people would recruit Sonic?
This seems like an odd question when you're his biggest scumread.
In post 142, Alchemist21 wrote:@Nacho, the bolded part seems pretty specific. What makes you think it could come specifically from a player being recruited? Why was it more likely to be scum-scum?
Honey Bee seems like a pretty easy target for MS to target as scum, so it seems more likely to me at this point that MS is attempting to clear a partner as opposed to shutting down a very viable mislynch without a real alternative.
"Playing with Nacho is like playing with a religious conservative." ~UncertainKitten
-- Fate, Vanilla Townie, was brutally stabbed by a throwing sword in endgame.
