*which* posts, specifically, are making you think this? cos I'm pretty fucking sure none of my posts this game have been above par in terms of how much effort I've put in - so you thinking this doesn't make sense. it feels more like you're attempting to come up with fake paranoia on me in order to hopefully get me to town read you (or otherwise look town) as opposed to legitimately believing this.
In post 197, pieguyn wrote:viewtopic.php?f=23&t=61111 (Endless Possibilities hydra) - he just fluff posts and has fun early game until he starts pushing Om. there were only I think 3 or 4 posts before that, the rest of them were me.
viewtopic.php?f=56&t=60046 (mental somnic hydra) - he just ignores everything (and says as much) until he starts getting reads. all the other posts that were about stuff were Om.
it might be difficult to tell individual posts apart bc both of those are hydra games. most of his games he does the former as opposed to lurking the game out, but regardless (I can link more games if you want).
Scum examples would be more helpful, as I don't have the expectation for players to be that consistent in their town games. ff was the only game I could kinda see what you're saying, but I'll have to look harder later today or tomorrow.
FFX AU and Organic Chemistry (http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=56&t=54597) were the 2 games of his I was loosely following. I don't have any direct experience with scum-MS, but that's the impression I got from the posts of his I saw in both of those games.
*which* posts, specifically, are making you think this? cos I'm pretty fucking sure none of my posts this game have been above par in terms of how much effort I've put in - so you thinking this doesn't make sense. it feels more like you're attempting to come up with fake paranoia on me in order to hopefully get me to town read you (or otherwise look town) as opposed to legitimately believing this.
That's not true. I think this is your best posting I have ever seen in a long time.
In post 195, Honey bee wrote:nah, I don't know pie's meta, so from the thread. My reads are varying from townie feeling to slightly scumish.
Which players are you finding slightly scummish?
In post 197, pieguyn wrote:elaborate on both of these? (in MS' case, I don't disagree, but I want to know your specific reasoning)
I wish I could but they're both gut reads really. With MS he just doesn't seem as comfortable as I've seen him elsewhere, and post 21 felt a bit odd as I'd assumed his vote in 14 was just rvs. It's not strong but it's the best I've got so far. With Honey bee it's even weaker but it started with 48; I don't see how anyone could get a townread on MS at that point and the explanation in 50 wasn't really very convincing.
@ Doduo:
Can you tell me which posts are by Marquis please?
In post 208, Doduo wrote:I think its funny that the two people who seemed kinda adamant on gaiden's post being a townslip are the two who are voting us though!
I don't actually understand what this is supposed to mean or say but OK.
If it makes you feel any better, I'm not really suspecting you all that much anymore.
Pie, the initial reason I started pushing Doduo was because it feels like they were falling into the background. I don't really feel that's the case anymore, and like the general push on MS so far.
Vote: Alchemist
"Playing with Nacho is like playing with a religious conservative." ~UncertainKitten
-- Fate, Vanilla Townie, was brutally stabbed by a throwing sword in endgame.
In post 173, Alchemist21 wrote:Also, I'm getting a gut scumlean on Gaiden. He feels more talkative than I remember his early games being.
VOTE: Gaiden
:/
This is such a weak reason for voting someone. Why do you think that he'd be more likely to post as scum than town? Why are you completely ignoring the MS push (which has much much stronger reasoning than this)? What do you think of the Gaiden townslip that's been discussed? Who do you think would have recruited Gaiden?
In post 221, Alchemist21 wrote:Who knows Gaiden well? How does he usually react to suspicion in him?
This is something you could very easily check yourself. Is he doing something that you find suspicious? If so, why not make a case out of it instead of asking other people to do your meta research for you?
"Playing with Nacho is like playing with a religious conservative." ~UncertainKitten
-- Fate, Vanilla Townie, was brutally stabbed by a throwing sword in endgame.
In post 6, Nachomamma8 wrote:Hi guys, I'm the Old North Wind, and any town player I hammer becomes an Edlewood tree instead of outright dying. As a result, I should be hammering all lynches unless anyone else has a better hammer power than I do.
People who would be in my recruitment shortlist:
Pieguyn
Metal Sonic
People who maybe included me in their recruitment shortlist:
Pieguyn
Metal Sonic
ActionDan
Doduo
This is why I'm not voting my strongest scumread, just as a friendly reminder.
"Playing with Nacho is like playing with a religious conservative." ~UncertainKitten
-- Fate, Vanilla Townie, was brutally stabbed by a throwing sword in endgame.
anyone who would want to troll the hell out of town.
also, what's negative utility?
You're not going to make a silk purse out of a sow's ear. S*Gaiden will not make long cases, write stunning insights, or sugar coat his words. He is not the man for multi-paragraph eloquence. He is, however, being honest to a fault, and it comes across in his writing.
sorry, that was directed at Doduo asking what in particular was negative utility. though i now believe them to mean "not voting your strongest scum read"
You're not going to make a silk purse out of a sow's ear. S*Gaiden will not make long cases, write stunning insights, or sugar coat his words. He is not the man for multi-paragraph eloquence. He is, however, being honest to a fault, and it comes across in his writing.
In post 195, Honey bee wrote:nah, I don't know pie's meta, so from the thread. My reads are varying from townie feeling to slightly scumish.
Which players are you finding slightly scummish?
In post 197, pieguyn wrote:elaborate on both of these? (in MS' case, I don't disagree, but I want to know your specific reasoning)
I wish I could but they're both gut reads really. With MS he just doesn't seem as comfortable as I've seen him elsewhere, and post 21 felt a bit odd as I'd assumed his vote in 14 was just rvs. It's not strong but it's the best I've got so far. With Honey bee it's even weaker but it started with 48; I don't see how anyone could get a townread on MS at that point and the explanation in 50 wasn't really very convincing.
@ Doduo:
Can you tell me which posts are by Marquis please?
I play mostly by gut, so I am going by my twinges and he twinged townish early.
You were one of the slightly scummish people but I like this post. The others I will reveal later, i have to ponder some more. It's nearing deadline and I haven't figured out who I'd be good with lynching.
