In post 173, Alchemist21 wrote:Also, I'm getting a gut scumlean on Gaiden. He feels more talkative than I remember his early games being.
VOTE: Gaiden
:/
This is such a weak reason for voting someone. Why do you think that he'd be more likely to post as scum than town? Why are you completely ignoring the MS push (which has much much stronger reasoning than this)? What do you think of the Gaiden townslip that's been discussed? Who do you think would have recruited Gaiden?
In post 221, Alchemist21 wrote:Who knows Gaiden well? How does he usually react to suspicion in him?
This is something you could very easily check yourself. Is he doing something that you find suspicious? If so, why not make a case out of it instead of asking other people to do your meta research for you?
I don't have any stronger suspicions at the moment, so that's where my vote is. I've actually meta's Gaiden in the past, but I'm not sure how valid it is these days, and the pattern I noticed isn't exactly related to what I'm asking about here. I'm too busy these days to run another second hand meta on him, and I'm asking for first-hand meta which is better than secondhand anwyay.
PPS. I don't know who if anyone would have recruited Gaiden. That doesn't stop him from being the initial scum that recruited someone, and I don't think he Towntelled just by saying he wouldn't get recruited.
In post 281, Alchemist21 wrote:PPS. I don't know who if anyone would have recruited Gaiden. That doesn't stop him from being the initial scum that recruited someone, and I don't think he Towntelled just by saying he wouldn't get recruited.
In post 268, Nachomamma8 wrote:Explain why pie is playing "so good" when, if you are town, the major thing he's been doing all game is absolute garbage
Whether or not Pie is correct and MS is scum, I think Pie's posts have been pretty solid. Calling his posts garbage seems like an early attempt to try to discredit Pie.
In post 279, Alchemist21 wrote:P.S. I can see the Sonic push, but I don't want him at L-1 yet.
Alchemist21 wrote:PPS. I don't know who if anyone would have recruited Gaiden. That doesn't stop him from being the initial scum that recruited someone, and I don't think he Towntelled just by saying he wouldn't get recruited.
In post 279, Alchemist21 wrote:P.S. I can see the Sonic push, but I don't want him at L-1 yet.
Alchemist21 wrote:PPS. I don't know who if anyone would have recruited Gaiden. That doesn't stop him from being the initial scum that recruited someone, and I don't think he Towntelled just by saying he wouldn't get recruited.
Who do u think picked ms then
Anyone that saw his performance in the Nightless may have recruited him. I'm not sure beyond that.
In post 279, Alchemist21 wrote:P.S. I can see the Sonic push, but I don't want him at L-1 yet.
Alchemist21 wrote:PPS. I don't know who if anyone would have recruited Gaiden. That doesn't stop him from being the initial scum that recruited someone, and I don't think he Towntelled just by saying he wouldn't get recruited.
Who do u think picked ms then
Anyone that saw his performance in the Nightless may have recruited him. I'm not sure beyond that.
