Battlestar Galactica Mafia - Game over!

[sangres]

And I think I would probably lynch snowstorm for the "oh I would have lynched BRO if I knew was a show cylon" reason alone

[sangres]

but also wrong is a bad lunch. Much tastier options.

Like who?
Werent you just talking about wrong lynch was a great lynch because they weren't doing anything?

[Bookitty]

And I think I would probably lynch snowstorm for the "oh I would have lynched BRO if I knew was a show cylon" reason alone

Why? I don't follow your reasoning here.

[sangres]

Although RIP policy lynch was brought up and that doesn't seem like a bad idea at all

[sangres]

And I think I would probably lynch snowstorm for the "oh I would have lynched BRO if I knew was a show cylon" reason alone

Why? I don't follow your reasoning here.

First of all, you know what post I'm talking about, right?

A good portion of the discussion day 1 centered around BRO was about how "you are a cylon" was in his role PM and it wasn't in Nikanor's role PM and that made absolutely no sense from a moderator discussion. SnowStorm read that discussion and apparently agreed with the reasoning but didn't join in because he didn't know his character was a cylon. That makes absolutely no sense to me coming from town.

[Bookitty]

Yes, I know which post you are referring to. I actually had it quoted before you responded. I look at it differently.

Nikanor repeatedly "misunderstood" the nature of the dispute. Nik knows which characters are show-Cylons but could not wrap his head around the idea that BRO had claimed Cylon flavour in his role PM, not the show. Nik actually showed aggression/claimed to scumread me because I kept pushing that point. Once BRO was lynched, Nik started behaving differently ("joking" with me, for one thing).

SnowStorm apparently isn't familiar with the show, didn't look up her character and didn't get the show-Cylon rolePM-Cylon distinction until Ooba posted the names of the seven Cylons. (Not the final five, which both Nik and BRO claimed.)

Why would scum-SnowStorm link herself to Ooba while saying she didn't understand that she was a show-Cylon before? Why would that be a good move for scum, who presumably know who their buddies are?

[SnowStorm]

You're just blowing it out of proportion, sangres.

First of all, I didn't say "I would have lynched BRO if I knew I was a show cylon". I said I wouldn't have been so reticent to vote him, because I'd have first hand information on what I saw as the biggest point against BRO. I never opposed to the BRO lynch, even though I didn't like the push on him. I always considered it and knowing I was a show cylon with no indication of it in the role PM, confirming the argument that he was lying about his PM, might have given me a small push to realize he was indeed scum and vote him sooner.

And what are your other reasons to suspect me?

I don't like how you're so convincingly pushing for my lynch, with exaggerated negative misinterpretations of my posts and claims of other unknown reasons. I also don't like that you're pushing me but not confronting me with your reasons. You're not trying to understand, but doing the opposite. I don't associate this behavior with town you, especially town Ffery and I'd vote you if you weren't already locked for screening.

[SnowStorm]

And policy lynching RIP IS a terrible idea.

[SnowStorm]

I'm also pretty puzzled about the crusade against LLD vanishing so suddenly. Last day it seemed like everyone wanted it, yet today people barely mention her name.

[sangres]

It wasn't a very good crusade to begin with, so I'm not overly disappointed.

[Toogeloo]

Once the screen is decided, I will be voting for either LLD or Snow personally.

[SnowStorm]

It is decided.

[curiouskarmadog]

I'm also pretty puzzled about the crusade against LLD vanishing so suddenly. Last day it seemed like everyone wanted it, yet today people barely mention her name.

So?

[curiouskarmadog]

I'm also pretty puzzled about the crusade against LLD vanishing so suddenly. Last day it seemed like everyone wanted it, yet today people barely mention her name.

So?

Meaning, what is the point of this post?

[Nero Cain]

but also wrong is a bad lunch. Much tastier options.

Like who?
Werent you just talking about wrong lynch was a great lynch because they weren't doing anything?

I don't eat people bro though I do eats pigs and chickens and the occasional cow. If you eat people for lunch then that's your thing.

[SnowStorm]

I'm also pretty puzzled about the crusade against LLD vanishing so suddenly. Last day it seemed like everyone wanted it, yet today people barely mention her name.

So?

Meaning, what is the point of this post?

Someone mentioned it on the last page, I was adding my voice to theirs in expressing confusion over the fact that a lot of people seemed to want to lynch LLD and now nobody talks about it. It doesn't make sense.

[Nero Cain]

I'm still down to lynch LLD, just wanted to see where things with WL went and see if they started doing anything.

[Nero Cain]

CKD, what games have we played together?

[AngryPidgeon]

Sangres, I'm getting cold feet about this lynch.

but then again I don't feel very strongly about any lynch right now other than a vague distaste for the popular options.

[Lady Lambdadelta]

Jesus. Can we just make a halfway decent screen and quicklynch confirmed trolling scum?

so much anger, so little and useless actions.

Loool. What actions do you want me to take? I'm hammering the first screen wagon to get to L1 and then I'm voting ooba. I'm not voting ooba until the screen is set because I don't trust all you adorable dummies to not lynch him before we get a screen.

Lol @ Axehole.

@Poro:

What did your talk with LLD do for you? Are you townreading her now?

Ya guys, IDK. My reads are all rather nebulous right now. I have townreads that I feel varying degrees of ok about, but nothing is really ironclad in my mind.

LLD could be scum although I'm inclined to believe she is town.

Same with Bookie.

RIP actually has me a little bit concerned, but I'm going to think about that one more. RIP is giving me a fair number of things that look town, but my gut is telling me that the bigger picture with RIP might be to look past such things since he clearly has some idea of what he is doing in this game. Like I could see ME doing the shit he is doing as scum potentially. Axehole is in a similar tier. His whole spheal about Saul Tigh looks mostly pointless to me? I'm not sure where he was trying to go with that and it looks like a potential attempt to distance from inside knowledge about fake claims.

Also Porochaz is a townie and RIP taking a swipe at him for the LLD/Poro walls was dumb and should be talked about.

Still pretty sure on Mantis-town. I'm willing to admit doubt on the WL-slot.

Ffery, what do you think about Axehole Today? How has your read on that progressed this game?

Hello darkness my old friend....

Can we take a look at this please?

Vote: AP

[curiouskarmadog]

Someone mentioned it on the last page, I was adding my voice to theirs in expressing confusion over the fact that a lot of people seemed to want to lynch LLD and now nobody talks about it. It doesn't make sense.

where do you stand on this? did you think LLD was scummy? If an wagon were to surge on her, would you join that wagon?

[curiouskarmadog]

CKD, what games have we played together?

I dont remember, I took 2-3 years off, so there is that. I think we have played 1..maybe two together.

[curiouskarmadog]

CKD, what games have we played together?

I dont remember, I took 2-3 years off, so there is that. I think we have played 1..maybe two together.

or..i might have modded a game you played in?

[curiouskarmadog]

EDITED: I was going to give some crap to Snowstorm about not voting, then I realized I wasnt voting. fucking hypocrite.

vote Mantisdreamz

[RIP]

Lol at losers. Policy lyjch cuz I'm OBV town hahahahahhahahahaha
Yall suck. U couldn't kill me ever.
I scum hunt and u guys policy lynch whoever owns u.
Haha. How sad