Nightingale's Tale - [Game Over]

[Sakura Hana]

Also what's this about a neighborhood with 2 confirmed scum.

[Cho]

But why are you revealing it Cho, if it's true? Will scum not kill you before D5 now?

Because I'm town.

And, assuming Brian is telling the truth (as he should know that this town should absolutely not settle for "oh I just didn't want to get ML'ed" if he's actually choosing to fakeclaim a role like Innocent Child as scum), if scum doesn't think they can sell me as part of a small scumteam that needs an extra kill or something outlandish like that, then it'll be good to lock in two obvious nightkill choices and see how the game plays out based on who they decide needs to die more.

[Cho]

Also what's this about a neighborhood with 2 confirmed scum.

I was joking about that to try and blur the lines between what I said that was real and what I said that was a joke. Then I decided "fuck it I need to claim".

[Sakura Hana]

Hmm k

Unvote
Vote: Kagami

[Katsuki]

Also, I'm a Day 5 Quintuplevoter.

Also wasn't a joke.

Confirmable and, most likely, instantly deadly, should you magically be unable to mod-confirm yourself when that time comes.

So I suppose I can wait.

VOTE: Nacho

I missed this claim.

Cho is a LYING SCUMBIRD, I'm a D5 Double Voter.

[FakeGod]

VoteCount 1.3

Mac [1] - Kagami
Nachomamma8 [2] - borkjerfkin, Cho
Kagami [2] - Mac, Sakura Hana
Cho [1] - Katsuki
notscience [1] - Muffin
Muffin [1] - GuyInFreezer
Sakura Hana [1] - farside22
SXTLHGaiden [4] - notscience, lalaladucks(x2), Brian Skies

Not Voting [5]

- Nachomamma8, zMuffinMan, Natirasha, grapes, SXTLHGaiden

With 17 alive it takes 9 to lynch

.

Deadline is May 25, 2015, at Noon PST.
Countdown to deadline: (expired on 2015-05-25 13:00:00)

[Brian Skies]

I think this game is moving towards a Day 1 massclaim.

[Katsuki]

You already claimed IC. I think we're fine with keeping the other roles under wraps for now.

[Muffin]

I think this game is moving towards a Day 1 massclaim.

I'm not claiming. My role is awesome and I'm keeping it under wraps.

[Mac]

Its a running joke from elsewhere move along.

Also how is it "forced?" Its either demonstrably true or it isn't (hint: it's this one)

the second question is a bit weird if you don't see how a possible scum entrance can look forced?

You're asserting it's a potential scum entrance because it "looks forced"; I'm merely asking for you to quantify what that means in this particular instance (aka what looks "forced" about it)

actually I really thought notsci had cast a naked vote on p1 before announcing this mason thing which made it look like he possibly thought his entrance into the thread was 'notsci' enough so to speak.

i was mistaken so we can probably move past this

[Mac]

that should read "not 'notsci' enough" so basically not the way town notscience would enter a thread

[Mac]

You know I was going to ask you a question before I come back home to explain but I got slammed by work so I didn't have time. And I really want you to answer this first so I make sure your answer is not biased.

Oh just to prove that I actually have something in mind so you don't go "bs you're buying time etc"
It has to do with #27.

why did you feel the need to defend yourself before you were attacked here?

[Mac]

Rabble rabble Fakegod made me join rabble rabble

Me too. I don't even remember /inning.

I don't think I've ever seen Gif post so much so early like ever. I also don't think I've ever seen Gif-scum. Maybe it's a sign.

VOTE: Gif

this feels like an rvs

is it an rvs?

[Mac]

VOTE: Brian Skies

[Katsuki]

Inb4 katsuki fake dayvigs.

You're lucky FG didn't give me a dayvig this time around.

I'm still mildly sour about the game where I got a role that's based on FAKE DAYVIGS as scum only for the setup to be tossed out due to mod error.

(in case anyone is wondering, this is for TM3)

[farside22]

@far: actually I have more behind that and I assure you it's gonna be heck of a more lot better than "omg this is my first time seeing her with naked vote SUSPECT"

I look forward to the reason then.

You know I was going to ask you a question before I come back home to explain but I got slammed by work so I didn't have time. And I really want you to answer this first so I make sure your answer is not biased.

So, which post of Mac did you find scummy? And how did your scumread on him got trumped by your gut/meta read on sakura?

Well since you denied it

His claim was obv fake because you said you hated your neighbor. So with that in mind, his random "hi I'm mason with bork" looks forced joke to me. But then, forced joke is not alignment indicative.

I mean for realsies what did you think was going on here if not him joking or specifically testing my / others' reactions (i.e the claim not being in earnest, with the caveat that I am not saying it would necessarily have been an effective reaction test)

I think he was joking.
I found it awkward/forced.
I think it's not alignment-indicative.
I thought I made myself clear.

It was the way Mac reacted to the wagon on him that sort of read scummy.
I'm on the phone so grabbing post are harder.
But the best I can explain is he seems pretty blah about it and his probing during the first part just was weak.
Also, slight meta on that.

Yes she is changing playstyles

Why?

Actually maybe not why, but why a 180 degree turn?

Eh... i probs just sux at playing in team with someone else, 3 hydra games where my hydra partner flaked, then an hydra game where my partner was townreading my correct scumread, and now this just add up to a lot of "i'm not going to give a F anymore about what other people think" for the rest of my life.

All in all i don't see it, all I see is, it's pointless for me to even try and explain anything, because 1) I sux at explaining stuff and 2) Even if i somehow manage to explain it, people ignore it anyway.

This was literally in the postgame of the most recent game y'all played together.

look what y'all did to this poor girl

Just an FYI I have ADD so I didn't really read everything posted. I tend to skim thing so I missed that.

I did wonder why people were defending sukura, but I like his vote on brian.

Vote: Mac

[Mac]

can you go into more detail about your read on me when you can?

I'm not sure how else I was supposed to feel about an rvs wagon that never took off. I didn't care about it and I wasn't concerned about it, I have no reason to be

[farside22]

And I'm still happy with my vote currently, feel my head exploding with all the day 5 claims and wonder why the flark people are claiming stuff right now.

Bk: why did you feel you needed to claim?

[farside22]

Sure I can explain more, but you get the line of quotes with comments bellow.

Reaction to them as players.

I don't understand what this means

I lile them both, but want to wagon one because it'll be fun.

Of the two I choose Mac to be brought to L-1 in the next 3 pages.

I could get on board with this

but I'm choosing not too

I wasn't talking to you, and I wasn't talking about giving approval. in fact, I'm not even opposing it. what is that all about?

claim masons with bork

i think this feels forced

Its a running joke from elsewhere move along.

Also how is it "forced?" Its either demonstrably true or it isn't (hint: it's this one)

the second question is a bit weird if you don't see how a possible scum entrance can look forced?

Quotes and issues I have with each one.
1) scoff's at wagon and approves it, who does that as town?
2) gets defensive
3) calling a claim forced
4) doesn't explain why it reads forced (by the way no it doesn't read forced)

[farside22]

Rabble rabble Fakegod made me join rabble rabble

Me too. I don't even remember /inning.

I don't think I've ever seen Gif post so much so early like ever. I also don't think I've ever seen Gif-scum. Maybe it's a sign.

VOTE: Gif

this feels like an rvs

is it an rvs?

Just going to add this is a pretty freeking pointless question given what brian said.

[Mac]

well 1) is clearly not serious, why in the world would I seriously approve a wagon on myself? no wait, not a wagon, an rvs wagon.
2) is not really defensive IMO. sakura said something that made zero sense in context, and I questioned her on it.
3) how is calling a clear fakeclaim forced an issue? it's not the claim I have issue with but the manner in which notsci entered the thread.
4) yes I did, when bork asked. gif also said it was forced; why isn't he a scumtell?

inb4defensive

well it's a pointless question now, but I wasn't caught up at the time. now I see brian is probably scum!

tl;dr - your case sucks

[Mac]

scumtell = scumread, I'm still not awake

[farside22]

well 1) is clearly not serious, why in the world would I seriously approve a wagon on myself? no wait, not a wagon, an rvs wagon.
2) is not really defensive IMO. sakura said something that made zero sense in context, and I questioned her on it.
3) how is calling a clear fakeclaim forced an issue? it's not the claim I have issue with but the manner in which notsci entered the thread.
4) yes I did, when bork asked. gif also said it was forced; why isn't he a scumtell?

inb4defensive

well it's a pointless question now, but I wasn't caught up at the time. now I see brian is probably scum!

tl;dr - your case sucks

3) makes you scum still avoiding the question
4) defecting to others is another one.

Thank you
5) pointless question I believe you were done when you voted brian and as far as I read with your post no case on bk.

What did you think of the claim?

[farside22]

that should read "not 'notsci' enough" so basically not the way town notscience would enter a thread

Also you implied it not town here.

Gif stated not alignment indictive

[zMuffinMan]

There aren't enough walls
And there aren't enough haikus
I will fix this now

vote

:

C

h

o

If you or farside are scum again, I've been gypped! I wanted to be evil this time

I don't like this post
It feels like trying too hard
To come across town

The last part mainly
Looks feigned and unnatural
Why would you say this?

Do you not like town?
Feels like, "look, I'm soooooo not scum!!"
... ... ... Need five syllables

Also, I'm a Day 5 Quintuplevoter. That's as high as it goes.

When I first read this
I thought it looked somewhat town
But actwally meh

If this is for real
It's probably a town role
But why claim it now?

Also kind of sucks
That actually's four sounds
Actwally's three, though

Kagami, are you town? Are we town?

I think we're town.

Maybe a town post
Doesn't really feel forced/fake
Marquis could be town

Don't worry, I don't need your approval to wagon you.

This feels kind of town
The attitude seems relaxed
And sounds genuine

(Not the z guy btw.)

To make things easy
Please call me "Captain Awesome"
For less confusion

Why's fake-muffin scum?
His entrance was kind of meh
But not real scummy

Kagami's #30 could be scum.

Meh. It's null really
I thought the same thing as her
Not really that bad

So believable so adorable

Who's this to?

notsci!

Also for srs, nachos town bork is town cho is town Mac is town muffin isn't.

VOTE: muffin
(Not the z guy btw.)

I don't see the town Mac read.
Pretty wah wah to me.
Did sukura change playstyles this game. I don't recall votes without a reason our last game.

And notscience is gone into trollish area.

I'll go with my gut first.

Vote: sukura

Don't like this entrance
Feels really awkward to me
Maybe scum posting

Why comment on mac?
Did you agree with the rest?
SH vote is meh

@far: actually I have more behind that and I assure you it's gonna be heck of a more lot better than "omg this is my first time seeing her with naked vote SUSPECT"

Like this post a lot
Like most of GIF's posts so far
I think GIF is town

lalala is probably town

y y y y y?
y y y y y y y?
y y y y y?

Rabble rabble Fakegod made me join rabble rabble

Me too. I don't even remember /inning.

I don't think I've ever seen Gif post so much so early like ever. I also don't think I've ever seen Gif-scum. Maybe it's a sign.

VOTE: Gif

Happened to me too
"Wanna play in my next game?"
"No time" "K you're in"

Doubt this is GIF-scum
If high volume's all you've got
This is really meh

Gaiden here.
Claim: D1 Doublevoter
i was gonna troll with it, but nah.

Maybe town-gaiden
Feels unguarded and open
Not super-strong though

btw

VOTE: gaiden

Why the gaiden vote?
Filler for more syllables
This is fucking hard

Your reads come so quickly and with no substance. You're a madman and I'm still happy with my vote.

Maaaaaybe Brian town
Don't really like the GIF read
But this feels not faked.

Told you Brian's scum.

Also kagami's #30 awfully looks like "woo whee random info I've picked up but I gotta look town and fake a town looking post" to me. Do you think I'm overthinking it?

While I see your point
It was early in the game
Really not that bad

The simple solution would be making gaiden vote.

It can easily be proven anyway, it shows up in the vote count. So, Gaiden, wanna vote for someone so we can verify your claim?

I doubt he's lying
That would be really stupid
Like, really, really...

Wagon ahoy! Also, third!
VOTE: Gaiden

No, Brian. Bad. Bad
You get no scoobie snacks now
And you sleep outside

I think they're both town.

Bit meh on lala
Lala's reaction felt town
Rest of her posts suck

Cho maybe scum.

Don't really see this
I think your reads are real shit
Don't think you're scum, though

I think this game is moving towards a Day 1 massclaim.

Maybe I'd agree
If it was late in the day
But def not right now

1) scoff's at wagon and approves it, who does that as town?
2) gets defensive
3) calling a claim forced
4) doesn't explain why it reads forced (by the way no it doesn't read forced)

These reasons look weak
And none of these are scummy
This whole post is bad

---

Other thoughts right now,
Liking how bork is playing
He looks kinda town

Cupcake maybe town
But awful choice of pastry
Would policy lynch

Nati maybe town
For that one contentless post
Hard to explain in...
a haiku
... fuck

This post took too long
But I quite liked writing it
CBF more though