Battlestar Galactica Mafia - Game over!

NotAnAxehole · Post Post #2250 (ISO) » Mon May 18, 2015 2:26 am

In post 2243, Brian Skies wrote:
In post 2229, NotAnAxehole wrote:We already had ValliliaRei confirmed as a power role, thus... Brian not giving out the name makes it seem like he didn't Watch Toogeloo at all. - If he were scum and tried to kill Toogeloo, he would know probably 1 (probably because it could have been more) person visited Toogeloo.

Right, because there's absolutely no protown motivation whatsoever to not want to tell the scumteam who our maybe-protective roles are.

If someone else visited Toog, they're more than welcome to CC me. I'd love another scumlynch.

In post 2229, NotAnAxehole wrote:I don't know what the odds of a watcher being scum are, but there is a ton of town power in this game. I am finding it hard to believe that town has THAT much power... 2 players who can prevent Night Kills? A watcher? The Neighborhoods? Baltar? The other PR which aren't yet revealed which have been soft claimed by more than 1 player?

Right, because we haven't already flipped a scum rolecop and a scum tracker.

Not to mention the person you supposedly share an ability with mentioned the probable existence of town-me (which hasn't been explained but probably should be).

In post 2229, NotAnAxehole wrote:But unless there's another claim for doctor (1-shot or not) , based on the evidence, Brian has to be scum, 100%.

Right, because there's absolutely no other explanation (
roleblockers, jailkeepers, ninjas, attempting to kill not Toog or not attempting to kill at all
) for Valilla being the only person to visit Toogeloo.

Whatever would we do without your invaluable insight? It's not like I'm not already a likely NK or that my existence alone extends Toog's life.

Also, I've already full-claimed. I'm just a watcher.

Roleblocker would claim - kill scum today
Jailkeeper would have role blocked you (or the scum) - You weren't role blocked, if the scum were role blocked, he should claim (the jailkeeper)
Ninja - Why didn't the ninja perform the night 1 kill as well?

NotAnAxehole · Post Post #2251 (ISO) » Mon May 18, 2015 2:31 am

In post 2248, curiouskarmadog wrote:
In post 2243, Brian Skies wrote:

Not to mention the person you supposedly share an ability with mentioned the probable existence of town-me (which hasn't been explained but probably should be).

Axehole should already know why I think this. I will explain once it doesnt matter if the info is hidden.

I do agree with Axehole that the current state of claims dont make sense assuming that we are against competent scum.

I have nothing in my role that makes sense of this, you'll have to enlighten me.

Bookitty · Post Post #2252 (ISO) » Mon May 18, 2015 2:33 am

CKD, what's your read on NotAnAxehole right now? You've probably been watching him closer than anyone.

curiouskarmadog · Post Post #2253 (ISO) » Mon May 18, 2015 2:35 am

In post 2251, NotAnAxehole wrote:
In post 2248, curiouskarmadog wrote:
In post 2243, Brian Skies wrote:

Not to mention the person you supposedly share an ability with mentioned the probable existence of town-me (which hasn't been explained but probably should be).

Axehole should already know why I think this. I will explain once it doesnt matter if the info is hidden.

I do agree with Axehole that the current state of claims dont make sense assuming that we are against competent scum.

I have nothing in my role that makes sense of this, you'll have to enlighten me.

doing it now.

curiouskarmadog · Post Post #2254 (ISO) » Mon May 18, 2015 2:48 am

In post 2252, Bookitty wrote:CKD, what's your read on NotAnAxehole right now? You've probably been watching him closer than anyone.

back and forth, I think he is town though (given his posting here and in our thread). our reads are mostly different which gives me pause. At any rate, if he is scum (now, assuming the sleeper doesnt know he is scum yet) the damage is done (or cant be avoided). This cryptic bullshit will be explained later.

Bookitty · Post Post #2255 (ISO) » Mon May 18, 2015 2:50 am

Okay.

NotAnAxehole: Do you think that both Brian Skies and Val are possible scum? Do you think only one of the two can be? It seems you're leaning toward Brian-scum over Val-scum. Can you explain your thought process there?

NotAnAxehole · Post Post #2256 (ISO) » Mon May 18, 2015 3:52 am

In post 2255, Bookitty wrote:Okay.

NotAnAxehole: Do you think that both Brian Skies and Val are possible scum? Do you think only one of the two can be? It seems you're leaning toward Brian-scum over Val-scum. Can you explain your thought process there?

Val can't be scum because Brian confirmed that Brian & Val were the only 2 to visit Toogeloo last night. Brian can't save people.

Bookitty · Post Post #2257 (ISO) » Mon May 18, 2015 3:59 am

Why is it certain in your opinion that Toogeloo was the one targeted?

AngryPidgeon · Post Post #2258 (ISO) » Mon May 18, 2015 4:26 am

In post 2228, NotAnAxehole wrote:I really wish the screen wasn't used on Sangres at this point.

It's for the greater good. I'll be damed before I let them get mislynched this game.

AngryPidgeon · Post Post #2259 (ISO) » Mon May 18, 2015 4:29 am

In post 2234, Toogeloo wrote:I feel like RIP lost his mind the last couple pages.

last couple pages?!

AngryPidgeon · Post Post #2260 (ISO) » Mon May 18, 2015 4:41 am

People are making some annoying assumptions about setup and night action spec.

Ninjas could be limited shot.
Scum may have no killed.
Valilia could be lying about her role and be god knows what.

Not that any of that is -probable-.

Also the sleeper is just a giant ??? right now.

AngryPidgeon · Post Post #2261 (ISO) » Mon May 18, 2015 4:46 am

Slightly concerned about ckd. Brian still concerns me although his point about a rolecop and tracker being flipped makes sense. If he is a sleeper though, then it makes sense for scum to no kill here potentially.

curiouskarmadog · Post Post #2262 (ISO) » Mon May 18, 2015 5:09 am

In post 2261, AngryPidgeon wrote:Slightly concerned about ckd.
.

well you shouldnt be....at least for now. If I end up being a sleep though, I will be pissed.

I wouldnt mind a screen tomorrow, just to find out if I am a sleeper. I feel like I am working too hard to wrap my mind around the game only to flip sides later would suck.

NotAnAxehole · Post Post #2263 (ISO) » Mon May 18, 2015 6:12 am

In post 2257, Bookitty wrote:Why is it certain in your opinion that Toogeloo was the one targeted?

I'm not, but it's more likely Toog was targeted than Brian at this point, if Toog was targeted, then Brian is scum.

The other most likely possibility that AP brought up is no kill... Which at this stage I think would be a strange approach for scum.

NotAnAxehole · Post Post #2264 (ISO) » Mon May 18, 2015 6:13 am

In post 2262, curiouskarmadog wrote:
In post 2261, AngryPidgeon wrote:Slightly concerned about ckd.
.

well you shouldnt be....at least for now. If I end up being a sleep though, I will be pissed.

I wouldnt mind a screen tomorrow, just to find out if I am a sleeper. I feel like I am working too hard to wrap my mind around the game only to flip sides later would suck.

CKD doesn't concern me at all. I think the odds of him flipping sleeper are low.

AngryPidgeon · Post Post #2265 (ISO) » Mon May 18, 2015 6:34 am

In post 2263, NotAnAxehole wrote:The other most likely possibility that AP brought up is no kill... Which at this stage I think would be a strange approach for scum.

Meh. I had a random thought while reading on the way to work Today which was that if Brian is a sleeper, then maybe scum wanted to wait until he flips before killing. Risking getting watched is a big deal, so maybe they could wait out the threat. I don't know. It seems fairly clear that scum have to get rid of Toogeloo at this point, so I really don't know.

SnowStorm · Post Post #2266 (ISO) » Mon May 18, 2015 1:02 pm

P-P-P-P-P-P-Prod Dodge.

Battlestar Galactica · Post Post #2267 (ISO) » Mon May 18, 2015 1:36 pm

“I want you all to understand this! If you do this, there will be no forgiveness. No amnesty. This boy died honouring his uniform. You, you'll die with nothing.” –

William Adama

VOTE COUNT 3.04

THE WRONG LYNCH (5)

- Nikanor, Nero Cain, Andrius, RIP, Brian Skies

Lady Lambdadelta (2)

- Toogeloo, curiouskarmadog

RIP (1)

- AngryPidgeon

SnowStorm (1)

- sangres

AngryPidgeon (1)

- Lady Lambdadelta

Not voting (6)

- Bookitty, Porochaz, THE WRONG LYNCH, SnowStorm, Mantisdreamz, NotAnAxehole

SCREEN COUNT (CONFIRMED)

sangres (9-SCREENED)

- AngryPidgeon, Bookitty, NotAnAxehole, RIP, Nero Cain, Andrius, curiouskarmadog, Toogeloo, Porochaz

SnowStorm (1)

- Mantisdreamz

Not voting (7)

- sangres, THE WRONG LYNCH, ValiliaRei, Lady Lambdadelta, Brian Skies, SnowStorm, Nikanor

With 17 alive, it'll take 9 votes to lynch. You may no longer vote to screen as a target has been confirmed. ValiliaRei may not vote on the lynch Today.

Nikanor is V/LA. sangres, THE WRONG LYNCH, Andrius and Mantisdreamz are being prodded.

Deadline: (expired on 2015-05-29 12:17:00)

sangres · Post Post #2268 (ISO) » Mon May 18, 2015 1:40 pm

prodded. will catch up in a couple hours.

Mantisdreamz · Post Post #2269 (ISO) » Mon May 18, 2015 1:52 pm

catching up!

THE WRONG WAGON · Post Post #2270 (ISO) » Mon May 18, 2015 2:05 pm

In post 2216, curiouskarmadog wrote:
In post 2204, Battlestar Galactica wrote:

Not voting (6)
-
Bookitty
, Porochaz, THE WRONG LYNCH,
Toogeloo
, SnowStorm, Mantisdreamz

why?

I feel a strange disconnect with this game atm, mainly because nobody will talk to us and only Nero will even talk at us. Lots of votes on us but no real reasonings to dig into and have fun rebutting. Just nothing's happening, it's almost like we're invisible.

Also I want to vote Nik kinda but idk what WS would feel about that.

Or Andrius but I get that that shit is not going down today because people somehow find it impossible for a backup to be opposite sides even though I'm not sure I'd even call it unlikely.

Mantisdreamz · Post Post #2271 (ISO) » Mon May 18, 2015 2:11 pm

i will talk to you^

i saw that you made a post to me, a bit ago, but i was away most of the weekend, so couldn't respond yet

NotAnAxehole · Post Post #2272 (ISO) » Mon May 18, 2015 2:14 pm

In post 2270, THE WRONG WAGON wrote:
In post 2216, curiouskarmadog wrote:
In post 2204, Battlestar Galactica wrote:

Not voting (6)
-
Bookitty
, Porochaz, THE WRONG LYNCH,
Toogeloo
, SnowStorm, Mantisdreamz

why?

I feel a strange disconnect with this game atm, mainly because nobody will talk to us and only Nero will even talk at us. Lots of votes on us but no real reasonings to dig into and have fun rebutting. Just nothing's happening, it's almost like we're invisible.

Also I want to vote Nik kinda but idk what WS would feel about that.

Or Andrius but I get that that shit is not going down today because people somehow find it impossible for a backup to be opposite sides even though I'm not sure I'd even call it unlikely.

Oh, I have no objection to talking to you, I don't think that you're scum necessarily. I think you could very well be town and I was very happy with your last post. I feel like if you want to get into the game, you really have to go for it on your own, because no one is really going to be jumping out to talk to you. I think you would feel the same way if you occupied any of the other slots.

NotAnAxehole · Post Post #2273 (ISO) » Mon May 18, 2015 2:14 pm

In post 2271, Mantisdreamz wrote:i will talk to you^

i saw that you made a post to me, a bit ago, but i was away most of the weekend, so couldn't respond yet

SnowStorm · Post Post #2274 (ISO) » Mon May 18, 2015 2:23 pm

In post 2170, curiouskarmadog wrote:
In post 2165, SnowStorm wrote:
Someone mentioned it on the last page, I was adding my voice to theirs in expressing confusion over the fact that a lot of people seemed to want to lynch LLD and now nobody talks about it. It doesn't make sense.

where do you stand on this? did you think LLD was scummy? If an wagon were to surge on her, would you join that wagon?

As I've said before, I don't have a read on her. I wouldn't oppose to her lynch.

In post 2216, curiouskarmadog wrote:
In post 2204, Battlestar Galactica wrote:

Not voting (6)
- Bookitty, Porochaz, THE WRONG LYNCH, Toogeloo, SnowStorm, Mantisdreamz

why?

Idk. Why not?

In post 2242, RIP wrote:Lunching LLD is good too.

Does it make sense that valilia send a message to Tammy but toogeloo didn't?

Yes.