Nightingale's Tale - [Game Over]

[Natirasha]

Who should I vote?

I need to learn to play mafia again.

[borkjerfkin]

I'm not feeling super good about Nacho from this page

1) this is super guttish, but I expected at least a passing shout-out/welcome/acknowledgement to me at game start since we just met up a few weeks ago I RVSed him and I've had substantial game presence and I'm excited to be playing with him and I feel he should reciprocate that.

2) I feel like, even with my limited knowledge of Katsuki, I could find examples of him just going totally off the reservation as town on D1. I'm not saying that makes him town, but I feel like that's pretty null and especially null for him. My first reaction if I wanted to probe Katsuki would be more of a "the hell you on about with SCUMBIRDS?" (in fact, Katsuki, consider that question asked) rather than to say his push (if you can even really call it that) is scummy

[notscience]

I agree, nacho's posts on this page are scummy as fuck

[notscience]

ill be here and serious tomorrow

[borkjerfkin]

I agree, nacho's posts on this page are scummy as fuck

I'm going to assume this is a jibe at the page turning over rather than an actual agreement and ask why you're not even remotely engaging?

Pedit ok

[borkjerfkin]

Who should I vote?

I need to learn to play mafia again.

Can you read the thread? Fresh perspective right now would be pretty rad.

[Nachomamma8]

Eh, i just thought your reactions were similar to those in Pick your poison, i said as much in the neighborhood which is why Mika switched gears, but anyway enough about that game.
Why do you townread Kagami?

I like that Kagami's approach to the game is very similar to mine thus far and I think the way she's approached the game thus far does feel like she's trying to solve the game. I don't think she's done anything unfakeable or anything that's ridiculously unlikely to be coming from scum, so she's not a level of townread that Cho or Brian would be.

this is super guttish, but I expected at least a passing shout-out/welcome/acknowledgement to me at game start since we just met up a few weeks ago I RVSed him and I've had substantial game presence and I'm excited to be playing with him and I feel he should reciprocate that.

I have a stronger tendency to reach out/be social when I have time to be properly integrated in the game. I don't think I'm any more/less likely to be friendly when scum, but that might be incorrect?

I feel like, even with my limited knowledge of Katsuki, I could find examples of him just going totally off the reservation as town on D1. I'm not saying that makes him town, but I feel like that's pretty null and especially null for him. My first reaction if I wanted to probe Katsuki would be more of a "the hell you on about with SCUMBIRDS?" (in fact, Katsuki, consider that question asked) rather than to say his push (if you can even really call it that) is scummy

The main reason I'm pushing him is because of how I expect his role would fit in on a scumteam and that role's interaction with Cho's (who I very strongly believe is telling the truth and is town). I agree that Katsuki sometimes says crazy shit as town, and, as a result, gets away with making pushes as scum that are very obviously scum-motivated. I see scum-motivation behind his push. I see why he would have the role he does as scum. He is my strongest scumread as a result.

[Nachomamma8]

also i don't really think "why scumbirds?" is a productive line of questioning
i agree with the sentiment behind the whole "d5 quintuple voter and d5 double voter are kind of weird as town together" line of reasoning, i just trust in cho-town more quickly than katsuki-town

[Nachomamma8]

Who should I vote?

I need to learn to play mafia again.

sheep captain america
you have a good hydra dynamic with him, i'm sure using him as your sounding board can only result in good things

[GuyInFreezer]

I was like "how the flying hell do y'all know so much about setup"
and then I read the op.

[Katsuki]

LOL IM SO SORRY THAT YOU DREW SCUM NACHO

Cho is probably some strong power role, Nacho is his buddy. Muffin you wanna get this nacho wagon going again, except this time forreals?

@GIF: Go read the flavor FG posted in the signup thread, that flavor directly correlates with SCUMBIRDS

[Katsuki]

^@Bork not fig

[borkjerfkin]

The main reason I'm pushing him is because of how I expect his role would fit in on a scumteam and that role's interaction with Cho's (who I very strongly believe is telling the truth and is town). I agree that Katsuki sometimes says crazy shit as town, and, as a result, gets away with making pushes as scum that are very obviously scum-motivated. I see scum-motivation behind his push. I see why he would have the role he does as scum. He is my strongest scumread as a result.

Not digging it

VOTE: Nacho

You're basically saying that you're willing to make the most broad of assumptions to fit this read:

1) Cho being totally on the level with a day 1 unsolicited claim (motivation to claim here is ???)
2) Same for Katsuki for the counterclaim
3) Katsuki having/being considerably more likely to be scum if Cho is town with aforementioned role
4) Knowing nothing/very little about what roles are in the game that could temper things in one direction or another
5) Somewhat related -- there are a lot of other doublevoter claims going around. I count 4. That's probably pretty damn important and should make you think twice about whether or not what has been presented is what is indeed going on here.

Also you think Katsuki's plan as scum when he finds an imminent threat in a town PR is to loltunnel him with essentially all bark and no bite and hope town just piles on?
I don't.

p-edit: k

[borkjerfkin]

doduo or whatever?

[Cho]

bork, I want to know what you think of me.

Hot or not?

[borkjerfkin]

I think you're moderately town; my opinion's not really changed since 193

[Cho]

What do you think of my claim?

I'm really only interested in this.

[borkjerfkin]

Although I'd like to know: how do

you

feel about Katsuki's claim?

p-edit: I have reason to believe there is a shred of truth to it, but possibly only a shred?
I'm not meaning to be cryptic, but I think I know why you're asking me specifically.

[Cho]

If they ever cast for a remake of Men in Black, I know who I'd want my co-star to be.

[Nachomamma8]

The main reason I'm pushing him is because of how I expect his role would fit in on a scumteam and that role's interaction with Cho's (who I very strongly believe is telling the truth and is town). I agree that Katsuki sometimes says crazy shit as town, and, as a result, gets away with making pushes as scum that are very obviously scum-motivated. I see scum-motivation behind his push. I see why he would have the role he does as scum. He is my strongest scumread as a result.

Not digging it

VOTE: Nacho

You're basically saying that you're willing to make the most broad of assumptions to fit this read:

1) Cho being totally on the level with a day 1 unsolicited claim (motivation to claim here is ???)
2) Same for Katsuki for the counterclaim
3) Katsuki having/being considerably more likely to be scum if Cho is town with aforementioned role
4) Knowing nothing/very little about what roles are in the game that could temper things in one direction or another
5) Somewhat related -- there are a lot of other doublevoter claims going around. I count 4. That's probably pretty damn important and should make you think twice about whether or not what has been presented is what is indeed going on here.

Also you think Katsuki's plan as scum when he finds an imminent threat in a town PR is to loltunnel him with essentially all bark and no bite and hope town just piles on?
I don't.

p-edit: k

no.

[Nachomamma8]

The assumptions I'm making is that Cho is telling the truth and Katsuki's role as scum makes sense while both roles existing as town does not. If Katsuki is not telling the truth about his role, he's probably scum so I'm not really making assumptions there. I don't care about other doublevoters (why should I?). Yes, katsuki as scum would take this path as scum because he has before.

[Nachomamma8]

And yeah there's a lot of unknowns in the push in katsuki. It's a theory. I expect to solidify the read further when I push him.

[Nachomamma8]

Mostly I'm frustrated because instead of critically thinking about how I've been approaching the game so far you're pushing me for an imperfect push in a stage of the game where no one has actually formed anything even remotely solid

and you're pushing me despite the signals that say DO NOT PUSH which already are much much louder than they should be

[Nachomamma8]

LOL IM SO SORRY THAT YOU DREW SCUM NACHO

Cho is probably some strong power role, Nacho is his buddy. Muffin you wanna get this nacho wagon going again, except this time forreals?

@GIF: Go read the flavor FG posted in the signup thread, that flavor directly correlates with SCUMBIRDS

Why do you think Cho and you can't both be town? Why do you think Cho would lie about quintuple voter when it's confirmable on Day 5?

[Sakura Hana]

I'm just gonna continue sheeping GIF, because atm im not feeling well enough to care.