Battlestar Galactica Mafia - Game over!

[Nikanor]

Second, I think it's more likely for there to be a scum bullet-proof in a game with a 1-shot vig. I've killed Sangres by the way, so voting him is pointless... He dies when the sun goes down.

Why do I not believe you?

[NotAnAxehole]

^ I realize this role reveal is horrible play, but I just want to move along more. I'm a 1-shot Vig, my flavor is human mutineer Tom Zarek. CuriousKarmaDog is my partner in crime, he basically kills who I tell him to kill. You can even test this (though I suggest not), from here on out, I lynch at L-1. So, it's a little easier for me to die during the day, but I don't think that should be a problem.

[NotAnAxehole]

Second, I think it's more likely for there to be a scum bullet-proof in a game with a 1-shot vig. I've killed Sangres by the way, so voting him is pointless... He dies when the sun goes down.

Why do I not believe you?

CKD can confirm.

[Nikanor]

okeedokee.

Vote: SnowStorm.

Screen: Porochaz.

[curiouskarmadog]

I'm going to make this real simple. Screen Elusive or I'm killing her.

well technically I would be killing her.

^ I realize this role reveal is horrible play, but I just want to move along more. I'm a 1-shot Vig, my flavor is human mutineer Tom Zarek. CuriousKarmaDog is my partner in crime, he basically kills who I tell him to kill. You can even test this (though I suggest not), from here on out, I lynch at L-1. So, it's a little easier for me to die during the day, but I don't think that should be a problem.

oookkkkayyy.....and I am the one who got shit for revealing stuff.

[NotAnAxehole]

Screen:Snowstorm

[curiouskarmadog]

I confirm, Sangres is dead..or will be.

[curiouskarmadog]

also if elusive is scum, her fucking entrance into the game was hilarious. you got mad for me calling you out on your horrible scum play did you?

screen snowstorm.

[curiouskarmadog]

I lynch at L-1. So, it's a little easier for me to die during the day, but I don't think that should be a problem.

for what it is worth, I can not confirm this part.

[curiouskarmadog]

Oh and to be clear, I don't mind being screened at all but it's a waste.

well I think you might get your wish...

[Porochaz]

I am quite happy to be screened and would prefer it to be me over Snowstorm.

screen snowstorm

[curiouskarmadog]

I am quite happy to be screened and would prefer it to be me over Snowstorm.

screen snowstorm

Lynch all Liars?

[curiouskarmadog]

unscreen, screen Porochaz

[Porochaz]

wait thats silly sorry

screen porochaz

[Nero Cain]

Just pick someone from this list and we'll screen.

2. Porochaz -

An okay screen

5. elusive -

An okay screen but then you'd have to accept the possibility of Andy distancing from all his scumbuddies on Day 1

6. ValiliaRei -

Could still be the scum sleeper, would probably be better off not screening

12. AngryPidgeon -

Meh, probably shares the same alignment as TWL, who you want to lynch anyway

16. SnowStorm -

I think this is an okay screen and Nacho could have been trying to distance from him

19. curiouskarmadog -

An okay screen, but I'd prefer to screen Axe over CKD just based on how their roles seem tied to each other

20. RIP -

An okay screen, but I'm still leaning town on him

I had an issue with Andy at the very beginning of the game, but I mostly think Andy was townie. Elusive is really scummy type play and is a claimed bulletproof (supposedly) and I can see her being talked about alot and thus a distraction (if not scum)

Much like Andy I think Val is p town but that whole "maybe a sleeper" will hang over her.

RIP started strong but has been a non entity lately.

Don't wanna do CKD anymore.

Snow getting distanced by Sangres is a thing but I was never really THAT sold on them being scum.

screen:poro

[Nero Cain]

I've killed Sangres by the way, so voting him is pointless... He dies when the sun goes down.

but why would you do this? I guess it doesn't really matter but I feel like you should have shot twl/lld and we lynched conf scum Sangres but we can just do the reverse and lynch LLD/TWL.

[curiouskarmadog]

oh yeah, so since that is all out in the open. you understand why I had to say something day1? I was not sold that Axehole's alignment HAD to be town. also this is why I thought there was a watcher type TOWN role in the game.

someone makes me kill..

how do I explain that unless I say something EARLY.a town watch role, would fit nicely with that role if you want to build suspicion in a game.


but he used our only kill on Sangres..seem town...or a desperate scum ploy.

thinking town....he could have easily used it on elusivetown and said that he was in such a rage blah blah blah...I would have believed him and backed him up (based on our neighborhood discussions).

[Brian Skies]

you're right... VOTE: Elusive

VOTE: Vote Sangres

I have to think a bit about screens.

There's two types of PRs those that play hard and those that lurk or be lurky and its hard to figure out town PR and scum because of that.

AP provided no reasoning for saving TWL which, considering no one knows 100% was a hasty and abrupt choice.

I'm the Admiral so screening me is pointless. Based on Mantis flip we might even be able to figure out the game with mass claims at some point because of they way the roles\flavor have corresponded to the actual show.

There are a few reasons why I'm scum reading Elusive, this post is one of them...

Second, I think it's more likely for there to be a scum bullet-proof in a game with a 1-shot vig. I've killed Sangres by the way, so voting him is pointless... He dies when the sun goes down.

I'm not really seeing your issue with Elusive's post. What's scummy about it? I'm also not interested in lynching the one role that can still communicate a screen result in the event Toog ever dies.

Why do you think a town bulletproof can't coexist with a limited vigilante role?

[Nero Cain]

he still seems kinda town but the Sangres kill was seriously dumb. Its safe and I don't think that scum with an extra one shot kill that he doesn't even make is impossible. Might want to screen him now, idk.

Do you two have any communication outside thread? What is your role name? Does your pm mention that you will be a puppet for him?

[Brian Skies]

I'm still okay with screening Axe. He's been opposed to it all game, but if he's a hated role it kind of makes sense why he'd think it'd be a waste. I'm just a little paranoid because he targeted me yesterday and he's targeting our admiral today. It just seems like he could be trying to make some kind of dent in our steady supply of screen results.

[curiouskarmadog]

lol

[Nero Cain]

or he could just be a terrible scumhunter like 80% of this site....

[Brian Skies]

Could be. Hence me wanting to screen him and not lynch him.

[curiouskarmadog]

Do you two have any communication outside thread? What is your role name? Does your pm mention that you will be a puppet for him?

NC, I have only mentioned I have talked to him outside this thread...5 times? maybe more?

I am a Human Mutineer

His decision causes me to kill someone....does it uses the term "puppet"? no...am I a puppet? yes.

[curiouskarmadog]

use