Star Trek Deep Space Nine Season 1 Mafia(game over!)

[Senator]

Why are you interested in focusing on what could, when properly distorted, be taken as decietful?

[Suzune]

Why are you interested in focusing on what could, when properly distorted, be taken as decietful?

I am merely suggesting that telling some to base their read on you on past gameplay is kid of a decietful tactic because assuming you have changed since then, you could merely be using an old tactic to hide you alignment.

[Senator]

I'm reminding people that I am the same player who did NY 180; and the same player who was in Newbie 1471, although that last one is well beyond what I'd consider current.

[Senator]

To hold me to some fanciful standard is to ask for a mislynch, which I am equipped and bound to fight.

[Senator]

Can we get votes placed? Id like not to have to do the deadline shuffle.

[Suzune]

Can we get votes placed? Id like not to have to do the deadline shuffle.

while we are not often in agreement I agree I would not like to have a last minute lynch.

[MonkeyMan576]

Vote count upcoming...

[MonkeyMan576]

Vote Count 3.11 - Up to post 2381

Senator(4) - Riabi, KlingonCelt, Titus, Sinsun1
Narninian(4) - Suzune, Senator, ChannelDelibird, RIP
ChannelDelibird(3) - displaced, PerigrineV, Thor665
RIP(3) - Salamence20, Nero Cain, Narninian

Not Voting(3) - ArcAngel9, davesaz, The Fox

Mod Notes: Salamence20 has replaced PeaceBringer, Suzune has replaced Jemerius, The Fox has replaced Little Gumball. The Fox has requested replacement.

With 17 alive, it takes 9 to lynch

Day ends Sunday, June 21st(extended), 8:45 PM USA Mountain Time or when a lynch occurs

[/area]

[PeregrineV]

I don't know RIP from Adam, but just finished a game in which he was scum. If someone familiar with him/his style wants to present similarities, I will consider him for tomorrow.

McNinja Mafia
http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=23&t=61633

[davesaz]

Pedit: my VC is no longer needed. And I see there is a RIP link posted, will take a look.

@Senator, The one liners are not foreign to me but I would say that you have tended to actually make cases where I have seen you before.

CDB: I have read his posting as fairly town. I don't really understand what Thor's case on him is -- I read the exact same posts and think town. If we lynch him we find out if the hider crumb was real or not. And there is quite a lot of activity related to him that might provide info either way. I would not be happy about this lynch but would still prefer it to no-lynch.

RIP: The claim was derp but might make sense. Though a role modifier which says night 4+ seems pretty weak. I have seen things which imply perhaps that's just the "next" use for the role. His play isn't especially effective, but it isn't really scummy either.

Senator: Series of 1-liners are one of his play styles. Again, it's bad and IMO a little scummy, but doesn't rise to the level of very scummy. The discussion about it is a discussion. If he flipped town I don't know if the people scum reading him and voting him would yield good information. If he flipped scum he's doing a really good job of making his actual thoughts on the game unclear.

Narninian: Frankly, I hadn't paid him enough attention to have a running read on him. I'll need to re-re-read and see what that yields.

[Klingoncelt]

I don't know RIP from Adam, but just finished a game in which he was scum. If someone familiar with him/his style wants to present similarities, I will consider him for tomorrow.

McNinja Mafia
http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=23&t=61633

ISO me.

[Thor665]

The Fox has replaced Little Gumball. The Fox has requested replacement.

Uff da.

[Titus]

Trying to hang in here. We should lynch Senator. Will try case this weekend.

[Nero Cain]

Just got back from doc appointments so am tired. Full catchup later tonight/tomorrow morning but RIP still needs death. CDB vote was shit, claim is bunk and "u don't have a case on me" is one of my fave scumtells. Sen/RIP team?

[Senator]

join us on Narn. We can settle me off tomorrow.

[Titus]

Nero, join me on Senator. It is the bigger wagon.

P.S. I use no case all the time as either alignment, more so as town.

[davesaz]

Can I get a summary on Narn?

[Senator]

titus has no case.

[Suzune]

Can I get a summary on Narn?

junp back a couple of pages, while not the best summary there is the reason I am voting him.

[Narninian]

The summary on me is I haven't posted much and I joined other wagons.
I stand by that. The posting not much is certainly not helpful to town, but this is not a tactic and certainly not alignment indicative.
The truth is I can't post from work anymore, it was my birthday this week and I have been fairly busy.
Regaring my votes, I think you'll find push wagons on people that are potential scum in your eyes is the correct move, so as I said I'll stand by that.

CDB I voted for because. almost exclusively because of the hider crumb. I didn't find his actions yesterday or today particularly scummy, but I felt we should take advantage of some what felt like 'hard' information. The Bashir claim was more than enough for me to back off simply because I didn't find the 'behavior' so far scummy.

Titus is also one I am town reading so I've followed her lead with my limited access this week. Now it looks like the leading wagon next to mine is somebody I've haven't felt has been doing townie things, so I'm very likely to vote there next, but I want to make sure I'm fully caught up in the thread before committing my vote.

unvote

[Salamence20]

titus has no case.

Now we are gonna get 3 pages from titus explaining your alignment. Thanks.

Still working on it. Ppl dont have as much free time as suzanne

[Senator]

Nah, titus doesnt do cases on me

[Riabi]

I will note that Titus is also making stuff up and has *not* claimed it was a mistake. Why aren't you having issues with her?

As to the vanity wagon - hell, I also think you are sidelining. I said as much to you outright when you started pushing it. Is having that belief really evidence of scum? I don't think so.

I am unsure how Klingon got into this conversation, maybe you didn't quote part of my reply?

Maybe you can walk me through where you claim Titus made stuff up?

And as for the Klingon/Titus thing. I apologize, I've never played in a large game before, and tbh, I'm a tad overwhelmed and sometimes having a hard time keeping people straight in my head. I know it's not an excuse, and I'm going to tough it out and not sub out. But I can't promise I won't make that kind of mistake again, only that I'll do my best not to.

[Titus]

I don't know RIP from Adam, but just finished a game in which he was scum. If someone familiar with him/his style wants to present similarities, I will consider him for tomorrow.

McNinja Mafia
http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=23&t=61633

Ewwww, please make a case I can jump on.

Thor, I have not made shit up.

Klingon wanted to wait for a claim. She intends to hammer before claim is analyzed. Yes, that's scummy to me.

[davesaz]

If someone says they'll hammer after a claim, why do you feel the need to interpret that as

immediately

after a claim.
AFAIK this is the primary reason you're accused of making stuff up. If you can point to actual posted words that clearly mean immediately, please do so.