Star Trek Deep Space Nine Season 1 Mafia(game over!)

[Titus]

If this is what all theme games run like I wont be playing them.

Senator, most larges are not like this. Generally, players actually try to be town.

[davesaz]

A refunded shot? That's interesting. IIRC there are normal n-shot mechanics which don't use up a shot when it fails but I can't remember what, so research awaits my return from dinner.

[Thor665]

@Thor, or maybe you can just realize that Senator is STILL likely just playing to the flip. He's probably scum. If not, no regrets because CDB is likely town.

Salmance is the only player that really gives me the jeebies on that wagon. If I had to pick a second scum on there, I'd go Nero/Narnian but those would be stretches that make Strech Armstrong look like a seasoned tunneller.

I would pick CDB and probably you.

[Thor665]

It also occurs to me Titus that you called me out on dinging you for making stuff up - but when I explicitly state what you're making up you go dead quiet on the subject.
I'm going to clarify now that I'm straight up scumreading you.

[RIP]

This blows

[Titus]

It also occurs to me Titus that you called me out on dinging you for making stuff up - but when I explicitly state what you're making up you go dead quiet on the subject.
I'm going to clarify now that I'm straight up scumreading you.

Highlight what I missed please. I have been a bit distracted due to IRL stuff. You ought to know me by now when I miss something, it's not alignment indicative. The fact you try to spin it otherwise is telling.

[RIP]

Well based on my role it seems the dr balaik is town and the fact my role speaks of him must mean he is in the game
. So cbd claim seems to be correct.

I agree he was scummy and that's reason I was voting him.
And of course I was right about now senator. Pretty fuckin poor decision
And senator u should have claimed earlier,

[Titus]

Senator's use would be a X-use if accurate. That's generally the mechanic for refundable shots.

I do have a major concern with Senator's claim. If he's claiming vig that shot Saint night 1, then why was he so focused on the hider claim? After his "vig" kill, there's only one kill left. Why wouldn't he think it's likely that scum just shot the hider directly? Why would he argue that the hider crumb implicated CDB?

[MonkeyMan576]

I am ending twilight a little early because I am going out for the evening.

It is now night.

Senator was Major Kira,

Town Two Shot Vigilante.

[MonkeyMan576]

There is 1 day five hours left in night. Little Gumball is re-replacing The Fox.

[MonkeyMan576]

Salamence20, who was Keiko O'Brien,

Vanilla Townie

, was killed night 3.

[MonkeyMan576]

It is now Day 4. Day 4 ends on July 8th, at 11 PM USA Mountain Time or when a lynch occurs.

[MonkeyMan576]

unlocked.

[MonkeyMan576]

Vote Count 4.00- Up to post 2537

Not Voting(15): KlingonCelt, Channel Delibird, davesaz, Narninian, ArcAngel9, displaced, Riabi, Titus, Sinsun1, RIP, Thor665, PeregrineV, Nero Cain, Suzune, LittleGumball

Mod Notes: LittleGumball is re-replacing The Fox.

With 15 alive, it takes 8 to lynch

Day ends Wednseday, July 8th, 11 PM USA Mountain Time or when a lynch occurs

[/area]

[davesaz]

Final VC just had the ones voting for Senator. Here's the full VC.

Senator(9) - Riabi, KlingonCelt, Titus, Sinsun1,

Salamence20

, Nero Cain, ChannelDelibird, Narninian,

Senator

[Lynch]

Narninian(3) - Suzune, RIP, davesez
ChannelDelibird(3) - displaced, PerigrineV, Thor665


Not Voting(2) - ArcAngel9, The Fox

Really disappointed in this lynch. I thought the claim was believable both from a mechanic and content point of view.

One thing I'd also like to point out, unless I've missed something when reading about the role, a hider who is using their ability can't be targeted directly by a kill. If Senator did indeed use his shots like he said, then there are only two likely ways to read the N1 results. Either Maxwell's death was by hiding behind Saint, or Maxwell's death was from hiding behind scum. In both cases, it appears that scum also failed to kill unless Maxwell didn't hide at all (I'd call that extremely unlikely). I don't think we need to go into the other things this implies, just yet.

@Mod:

so that means LG is replacing back into the same slot?

[MonkeyMan576]

@Mod:

so that means LG is replacing back into the same slot?[/quote]

Correct.

[displaced]

Senator's use would be a X-use if accurate. That's generally the mechanic for refundable shots.

I do have a major concern with Senator's claim. If he's claiming vig that shot Saint night 1, then why was he so focused on the hider claim? After his "vig" kill, there's only one kill left. Why wouldn't he think it's likely that scum just shot the hider directly? Why would he argue that the hider crumb implicated CDB?

o_O

[Suzune]

I believe looking at the situation the sala kill was the only one that the scum could have made given the situation from yesterday, so sadly I am not surprised. They could not risk killing someone on another train because that would be like confirming the other train was wise. So in order to keep in fighting high they limited the control of the town. I suppose from that perspective it was a smart move. It would then be wise to look at those not on the train though as I imagine it may lead to more evidence. Sorry the tired thoughts of my insomnia. I will check with he final decisions that led to that vote train later in the day.

[LittleGumball]

Hi friends. Sorry about the absence, that normally doesn't happen. I'll be as active as I can.

So a while ago I kind of skimmed the majority of the previous day, and Salamence was really the only person I trusted. I began to see Senator as a Lickety 2.0 of sorts where I just wanted him out of the game.

It is obvious to me that scum is controlling this game. I'm going to look through the game if I can (will likely be tomorrow bc it's 1am and i'm tired af) and I'm going to pick out some reads. My prediction is that, assuming there are 4 mafia members in the game, at least one of them is an inactive, if not two. The remaining members are actively participating in discussion and have high influence on who is getting lynched (because let's be honest, Lick and Senator were easy lynches simply because of their behavior). Mafia is smart this round and town cannot afford to make stupid/obvious mistakes.

Can someone summarize the whole Hider discussion? I'm not overly familiar with playing with Hiders but I have a general idea of how they work.


this post is awful, sozzles friends but it's 1am and i can't function properly

[LittleGumball]

i lied i'm in the middle of reading a couple things instead of doing the smart thing and just going to bed already but I want to point out that i'm p sure that senator (aka confirmed town) thought that kling was scum so maybe that's a thing to do some research on (sorry if there's a claim or something obvious i missed)

k no more posting for me tonight

[Klingoncelt]

i lied i'm in the middle of reading a couple things instead of doing the smart thing and just going to bed already but I want to point out that i'm p sure that senator (aka confirmed town) thought that kling was scum so maybe that's a thing to do some research on (sorry if there's a claim or something obvious i missed)

k no more posting for me tonight

Me mostly, but he suspected everyone, and I do mean

everyone

else as well. He didn't have a case on anybody.

He was being ridiculous.

[RIP]

Ok guys. Weird kill.
I didn't trust sala and neither did senator.
Fucking pissed you guys didn't listen to me, who really knows what's going on this game? Yea RIP.

I will decide the lynch today, if you think I'm scum let me know so I ISO your silly game.
I'm not dying by lynch today so forgetboutit.

Suzanne looks like TMI.

[RIP]

VOTE: narminian placeholder

[RIP]

I'm down to kill gumball too.

[Thor665]

Vote: CDB

The Narn vote looks silly to me, but I like that RIP at least comes out of the gate swinging.
That said - we had like 3 counterwagons to this guy yesterday.
Hint.