In post 65, Shanba wrote:Different to face to face for sure...
also I haven't played a forum mafia game in a long time, so this is taking some getting back used to.
In post 105, Shanba wrote:I'd like to note here that I am actually really paranoid about nexus, so take my reads on him with a grain of salt.
In post 112, Nexus wrote:Didn't realise inspie has only posted 3 times.
Scum shirley can't be two of the lowest posters. SHIRLEY NOT
In post 119, AurorusVox wrote:I've clearly claimed an only town role so you should all sheep me and lynch poro.
In post 274, Tammy wrote:Oh I remember, this is the only post I worried about from Ampersand.
In yoloville, CES made a similar type of "mislynch" slip and I should have paid more attention to it when Vi pointed it out.
![:]](./images/smilies/icon_smiling.png "Cheerful Smile"){kind=icon}
In post 269, Tammy wrote:One thing that did keep repeating to me in the dream though was Nexus' assertions that he got his favorite role. I don't remember seeing anyone react to that at all and it kinda surprised me that he's on people's suspect list while doing something that I thought would be familiar or that would spark a response. I'm not sure what to make of that. Maybe I'm misremembering how many times he said it.
In post 278, Tammy wrote:
In post 105, Shanba wrote:I'd like to note here that I am actually really paranoid about nexus, so take my reads on him with a grain of salt.
I'm not sure what to make of this. On the one hand I hate that he? has nexus as a town read in one post and not even a minute later expresses paranoia on nexus with absolutely no indication why. On the other hand, I know how contradictory I can be when my head and gut are fighting, but I'm not seeing an indication of this fight here, so I don't know why there's a turn around in less than a minute.
If you like CDB, do you not trust his read on nexus?
In post 282, Tammy wrote:But I will say that the reason why I asked what CES thought about the no track on CDB was because in NY 146 when he replaced in he gave a statistical reason why he was likely not scum because of a no track on him/or vanilla result, damn now I'm second guessing that and will have to look back. If it was a track, I might have another question. So, tomorrow.
Why, what happened previously?In post 264, Nexus wrote:I'm always uncomfortable when CDB says he town reads me as heavily as he has today.
If they are partnered, I figure it's basically either bus Nexus hard early, or super town read him early to keep him alive, it's really awkward no matter what. My impression is that CDB doesn't strongly bus that often. And seems like it kinda has been working? But this still feels like I'm being dumb. Basically I need someone to tell me why my theory is stupid so I can stop considering it.In post 274, Tammy wrote:I don't think the two of them can be partnered though, or are very likely. If cdb does feel, and it's substantiated by other games, that he can read Nexus, I doubt if they were partnered he'd be likely to read him as strongly town because I don't think* Nexus has a very strong scum game and would likely be caught which would put cdb in a bad position. And with you guys all knowing each other so well and being friends I think he'd be less likely to get away with town reading his scum partner Nexus, who would likely be caught as scum, and then there he'd be looking too obvious.
I was more interested in the fact he seemed to "understand" the votes on him, which seems less likely to come from town. I think I skimmed back to see what he said about the votes on him, interpreted the first quote as saying he looked town and thought it worth asking about.In post 268, Tammy wrote:This felt stretchy. I didn't think this felt contradictory.
In post 139, Nexus wrote:because av pinged my scumdar as well but I was also unsure on INSPIE and it's TOO MANY SCUM READS FUCK MY LIFE.
I'll vote Prozac > AV > Inspie i think
In post 149, ChannelDelibird wrote:In post 138, Ampersand wrote:CDB: you have inspi as most scummy, neutral on AVox, and Poro as not voteworthy. What are your reasons for these reads, please?
Inspie isn't anything that I haven't said in thread but I feel like his entrance was empty and unhelpful, and his subsequent justification of it seemed like he was making it up a bit after the fact. I liked your #77 in that regard.
AVox is probably up from neutral to scummy now. I thought his first couple of posts were pretty nondescriptly Avoxy and was waiting to get a bit more input but his interactions with you on Wednesday don't look great. The fact that his last posts are asking a couple of clarificationy questions on which he never followed up doesn't sit well to me - looks more like scum posting to be seen posting rather than town actually trying to get answers to figure out anything.
Prozac just seems pretty town. He's here, and he's making some kind of effort even if he's admittedly struggling to get into things at times. His reads are maybe not meshing with others' perfectly and he's had some heat with which to deal but he doesn't strike me as particularly rattled by it.
In post 286, Elmo wrote:Hmm, I should vote but it's, uh, late. Tammy has posted a bunch of stuff which I haven't read properly but seems reasonably townish so far, which is mildly annoying since that leaves me with Nexus and CDB, and, well, is it that easy? It just feels off because I'd expect CDB to get nervous around Nexus, but he just seems very nonchalant about the whole thing. I dunno. Consider this a nominal vote for CDB.
In post 286, Elmo wrote:My impression is that CDB doesn't strongly bus that often. And seems like it kinda has been working? But this still feels like I'm being dumb. Basically I need someone to tell me why my theory is stupid so I can stop considering it.
In post 289, Tammy wrote:In post 149, ChannelDelibird wrote:<snip>
The reasonings for these feel like they should be closer in your reads than farther apart.
In post 261, Elmo wrote:CDB having that many town reads seems off at this point.
Hey, CDB, what's your read on Primate/Tammy now, and why?