In post 91, RadiantCowbells wrote:Oh dear lord
he is scummy because 1) he tried to divert attention from my firebringer wagon in a very sideways way
and 2) the only content post he makes calls someone out without a vote or any sort of follow up
not because he asked people how experienced they are.
comprende?
In post 64, Sword Master wrote:I've finally found the thread. Lol.
In post 70, RadiantCowbells wrote:Like, then he comes back and addresses the ongoing game issue but doesn't comment at all on alignment, nor any of the responses.
In post 80, RadiantCowbells wrote:Like, Thesp's deliberate attempt to undo progress made in the game
In post 87, All Alone wrote:This comment from Thesp looks like scumhunting but really isn't. He's not analyzing Pistachi0n's alignment, he's not asking her anything meaningful. It's like information instead of analysis, except it's not even informative.
In post 98, Firebringer wrote:Post 79 Calls Alchemist Scum and says I am not scum, that was fast. Post 88 quickly says that alchemist isn't scum but is a asset to scum and wants to lynch regardless. Anti town heavy here.
You train on both me and Alchemist after we voted you. OMGUS
Your reasoning for me is faulty, your reasoning for Alchemist is non existant and you even now say he is town. Pick one. If you think I am scum vote me, if you think its Alchemist vote him, like honestly you are the worst town if you are one, which I doubt.
I suggest everyone move onto Radiant train, he is likely evil.
I'm liking Alchemist21's points re: RadiantCowbells's potential hypocrisy.
(I sometimes get stick-in-the-mud types who insist on not answering and making a big deal about that, but those types are more likely scum in my recent experience.) I'm not feeling the "Thesp is changing the subject" angle as feeling very genuine.
Wha? Are you seriously characterizing your post #7 as progress in the game, and my inquiries to all players as an attempt to undo that?
Yes, and yes.
Would it make a difference if you were to learn that I always open games by asking questions of everyone? Also, I appreciate the content so far (misguided as I think it may be), but I would also appreciate your responses to my questions earlier, and hope it's not too much of an imposition.
Why are you doubling down on this?
RVS is over.
You trying to drag me back to this strikes me as odd.
Then you should vote RC too.
Why not ask Thesp to vote me too, given he's already expressed a scumread on me for two different reasons?
1) How much Mafia have you played before (in person or online)?
4 years worth.
2) How active are you typically in a Mafia game? That is, is there sort of a posts per day frequency that's approximately typical for you?
About 3.
3) Are you scum?
No.
How were we supposed to know it was non-RVS?
In post 106, RadiantCowbells wrote:Why are you doubling down on this?
RVS is over.
You trying to drag me back to this strikes me as odd.
In post 108, RadiantCowbells wrote:Wait wait wait.
What do you want?
That's an interesting reaction to a single RVS vote.
Firebringer is awfully defensive.
Nothing here indicates a non-RVS vote to you?
In post 111, Netherspite wrote:VOTE: Firebringer
I don't believe you forgot who are you voting.
Your excuses look like scum faked his reads and forgot to vote.
No, I'm curious if your reaction to my opening post is different if I open every game I play in a similar manner. (It appears to be a strong basis for your vote on me, so I feel it's worth exploring. I'm still curious - would it affect your read to know I always open the same way?) Thank you for your responses to my other questions!
Not in a terribly strong or interesting way. I don't seem to be the only person with that sentiment. As an aside from a policy standpoint, I can't imagine it would be beneficial to tunnel on one person before half the player list had posted.
In post 116, TheDominator37 wrote:This is the first game ever that I have had no reads this far
In post 116, TheDominator37 wrote:This is the first game ever that I have had no reads this far
In post 119, RadiantCowbells wrote:I'm feeling really shitty about mafia right now.
I don't feel like doing this.
In post 102, Thesp wrote:In post 87, All Alone wrote:This comment from Thesp looks like scumhunting but really isn't. He's not analyzing Pistachi0n's alignment, he's not asking her anything meaningful. It's like information instead of analysis, except it's not even informative.
This is fair - though I was really hoping to see pistachi0n's next post before I comment further on this.