It's amazing how much things can change after you're caught up. My original smorgasbord of quotes are now down to 2.
In post 157, mastin2 wrote:
2. Bulbazak
^Bulbazak is so town that every time someone votes him, borkjerfkin coughs up blood.
Was the Maniacal cough contagious?
In post 252, Seiko x Naomi wrote:ftr, Aeris looks really obviously town here and I think the reasons both Varsoon and Jaqen have for scum reading her (as well as hawk's original push) are pretty awful
I actually agreed with that reasoning.
After all that, strong townreads remain the same. Adding AntiIka, Tip, Saint, and Potty Training Elmo to the list. Singer is really close to that list, but I'm not sure if I have a good baseline there. I also want to say Feysal is town, but I always waffle on that point in my heart of hearts, and I don't know why. Not touching the Nacho/GiF hydra until later in the game. Titus-hydra is still my strongest scum read. I've decided to give Varsoon and Aeris room after everything from page 20 on. There are some indications I may be wrong there. Not sure how to feel about Jaqen's claim. Not worth lynching anytime soon. Flubber, Kaboose, and CB are also scum. Everyone else I'll sort later.
I know there was something prior to page 15 that caught my eye and indicated scum, but I forget what it was, and I can't seem to find it upon a quick skim. Anyway, I'm hoping Aeris actually participates and does some scumhunting now. I still don't like her defense, as I feel it was way over the top for town, especially with the sexist accusations. That screamed of desperation. However, there's a detail in her soft claim that I think points to possible town. As for Titus (yes Titus. You can drink yourself to oblivion for all I care, Sal.), I made a vow after Signs & Voided that if at any point in a game Titus made a move that I couldn't make sense of from a town perspective, I would lynch immediately, regardless of my previous read. She made that move early with her defense of Aeris, which I couldn't see as town, but what really sealed it for me was her defensiveness, which boils down to mudslinging and threats. I can't see this from town Titus, and I'm not going to try to talk myself out of a major ping like I have before.
Vote Focus Beam
Also, if anyone can find who said something about there being 2 kills even with more than 2 scum teams, can you quote it? I have a game starting soon, but I'm pretty sure whoever said that is scum. That's not what I saw before, but it is pretty damning.