Star Trek Deep Space Nine Season 1 Mafia(game over!)

[Titus]

Where do you get Narn checked HI? I had Thor as one of his checks. Spoiler quotes please.

[Klingoncelt]

Where do you get Narn checked HI? I had Thor as one of his checks. Spoiler quotes please.

Checking, brb...

[St Constantine the Hermit]

What I do find curious is how Peregrine is making all these assertions that he knows who is town and who isn't, and he still hasn't placed a vote. I often state my feelings and wait awhile to back them up with a vote, which is why I am hesitant of making that anything but null.

Its just intresting that of all the players opening in this round, he is the only one who didn't start the day with feelings on who we should be voting. That could be a personality qwerk, or a differentiation that singles him out as scum. IDK, I'm bad at this, I'll just leave my vote on Titus.

[St Constantine the Hermit]

He's riding that tale too hard. Plus he wants a massclaim.

Yeah, so what? I don't see either as any indication that he is scum.

[Titus]

Daveaz and Titus should be more receptive of launching a massclaim if they were town. The massclaim is the most town thing Peregrine has tried to do so far, and it seems every time he brings it up, Titus jumps on him and adds pressure to his slot. That makes me want to go through with the massclaim even more. It just makes sense at this point, being D6 and all.

We need to hear from these other lurking dipshits about whether they want to massclaim or not.
P.S VOTE: Titus

I'm rarely receptive to massclaim in closed setups. It works better as open setups. Also, we have zero completed games, while I admit my tactic is a little different after the Senator lynch, you arguing that is weird. If I disagree with Peregrine's mass claim, I will highlight that.

You initially said gut, and then you made another post with poor reasons. Not a fan of you either.

I like to get all the information and then determine who to vote for (unless that info is bad to obtain, like mass claim). Voting and then getting info is not usually helpful

[Klingoncelt]

Here ya go, Titus:

[/post #1661 (isolation #60) » Mon Jun 08, 2015 12:17 pm
So with some strong presence of anti-town roles (beloved prince, worse than normal, miller) presumably the books are balanced.
One theory I have is Rumpelstiltskin. His post restriction made him a target to be looked at at least early. the character he was in had a couple other characters that were part of his group: Buck Bokai, an Alternative Jazdia.
They weren't inherently hostile in the episode, but their presence did cause danger. I could seem them being a scumgroup, I also feel he was on the wrong side of the fence regarding LQ's lynch.

and then I read that buck bocki was dead and is town. so back to the drawing board.

[Klingoncelt]

1661

[St Constantine the Hermit]

@Everybody Peregrine wouldn't be pushing the massclaim so hard as scum, seeing how much its already being used actively against him.

[Titus]

He's riding that tale too hard. Plus he wants a massclaim.

Yeah, so what? I don't see either as any indication that he is scum.

You don't see his claim as off?

Also, how hard someone pushes for something is a personality tell in 99 percent of circumstances.

[St Constantine the Hermit]

@Titus - So you don't directly oppose the massclaim, but you are actively using it to justify a scum read on Peregrine. Kudos!

[Titus]

@Klingon, That's possible. The post makes no sense as either alignment. Why talk about how the dead guy was scummy? Yet, who else do we see? Rumple...hey isn't that Thor?

[St Constantine the Hermit]

Titus, I have lots of experience in off claims. I find role speculation to be more of a third tier justification.

[Titus]

@Titus - So you don't directly oppose the massclaim, but you are actively using it to justify a scum read on Peregrine. Kudos!

I am opposing the massclaim, directly.

[Titus]

Titus, I have lots of experience in off claims. I find role speculation to be more of a third tier justification.

? So do I. I generally do setup cracking, which is why I find PV's claim hard to swallow but not impossible for certain.

[St Constantine the Hermit]

I've said my piece. I don't think Peregrine is scum.

There are plenty of others here, and it is pretty obvious he is the one getting lynched today. If under any circumstance his theory is right though, then we can't mislynch tommorow.

Also, if Peregrine was scum at D6 and we've only lynched one other scum, wouldn't there be a lot more people defending him?

[Klingoncelt]

He's riding that tale too hard. Plus he wants a massclaim.

Yeah, so what? I don't see either as any indication that he is scum.

You don't see his claim as off?

Also, how hard someone pushes for something is a personality tell in 99 percent of circumstances.

He claimed something like treestump early on in the game - ISOing now, brb...

[Klingoncelt]

I've said my piece. I don't think Peregrine is scum.

There are plenty of others here, and it is pretty obvious he is the one getting lynched today. If under any circumstance his theory is right though, then we can't mislynch tommorow.

Also, if Peregrine was scum at D6 and we've only lynched one other scum, wouldn't there be a lot more people defending him?

Not until the wagon starts loading up. Then they'd start a counterwagon.

Are you new?

[davesaz]

There is someone defending PV, and it happens to be someone I'd consider lynchable.

Whether a massclaim is good or bad depends entirely on the exact circumstances. In this particular case I'm worried it may benefit scum more than town.

[Titus]

I've said my piece. I don't think Peregrine is scum.

There are plenty of others here, and it is pretty obvious he is the one getting lynched today. If under any circumstance his theory is right though, then we can't mislynch tommorow.

Also, if Peregrine was scum at D6 and we've only lynched one other scum, wouldn't there be a lot more people defending him?

Not until the wagon starts loading up. Then they'd start a counterwagon.

Are you new?

He's completely new or an alt. He's claiming he's scumreading me based on me not doing my typical play. That's awkward as we have ZERO finished games.

[St Constantine the Hermit]

@Klingoncelt No, I'm not anywhere close to being new at mafia. I am new at MS, you guys are whack.

Anyways, with all the people who have been voting and applying pressure on Peregrine, I just feel like scum would be on his defense. No one has came to his defense but me, and I'm not even totally sure the guy isn't scum.

I find the whole situation concerning. I guess we'll find out when he is lynched, I don't see this wagon losing momentum.

[Titus]

I've said my piece. I don't think Peregrine is scum.

There are plenty of others here, and it is pretty obvious he is the one getting lynched today. If under any circumstance his theory is right though, then we can't mislynch tommorow.

Also, if Peregrine was scum at D6 and we've only lynched one other scum, wouldn't there be a lot more people defending him?

This implies we're mislynching today...

[St Constantine the Hermit]

He's claiming he's scumreading me based on me not doing my typical play

??? Where did I justify my vote on you based off of meta?

[Titus]

Fuck it. I should be voting PV with all his garbage, but it's possible he's just dumb. I don't see any town player posting what Hermit has.

VOTE: Hermit

[St Constantine the Hermit]

This implies we're mislynching today...

No shit!

[Titus]

I thought Hermit said I wasn't playing to my usual game. I went back to quote it and couldn't find it. :S