Mini 1700: Space Mafia (Game Over)

[Scorpious]

@Gray, first. Welcome

second,can you elaborate just a little more on that vote? I'm also leaning scum on Garmr,I'm curious if we are on the same page here.

[yoloswag123]

Urghh thinking about that deas that is a pretty good point.

Grayfoxx can you point out some examples of garmr misrepping posts?

[Garmr]

I honestly don't feel I misrepped anyone

[DeasVail]

Frag, so do you think Blocky is scum or are you just wanting to see him slip as scum? It's been a bit unclear to me. No need to mention ongoing games and I probably won't be looking at your game history honestly since I find it confuses me rather than helps (others can get a lot from it though!) but feel free to mention anything you think is particularly relevant.

A little of both. He's a scum lean right now for me, as well as I'm going to put some pressure on him. I don't think for the most part his playstyle has been pro-town at all. Even now providing reads they don't have much content behind them at all. He says someone Is making pro-town posts but doesn't explain in further details what those posts are. I feel like I have a decent read on Blocky.

Ok, my opinion is that scum put a greater amount of effort into looking pro-town because it helps them look better and thus serves their win condition. However, I have been caught out in thinking this before and sometimes scum just don't care, so what I think is definitely not foolproof nor should it be blindly followed. I think Blocky is town though!

[Scorpious]

Deas seams pretty town. I like Sland too, just not as much.

Instead of a big catchup post ask me anything and I will reply. I promise.

How do you feel about being a replacement player? Have you ever done it before?How did that\those game(s) turn out? If any..

and happy late scumday

[Firebringer]

I am here to say hi.

Such a bad active lurkerer

I honestly don't have much to say so far. Blocky still seems most like scum.

[Fraggernaut]

@Gray Do you have any extended reads on anyone? From what I've seen through numerous games so far is that a replacement player has a high chance to flip scum. The person you replaced (Axwell) didn't give that slot any help & seemed kind of scummy. Just trying to get a read on your slot.

[DeasVail]

I am here to say hi.

Such a bad active lurkerer

I honestly don't have much to say so far. Blocky still seems most like scum.

What is your opinion on the contrary arguments that have been raised

[GrayFoxxxx]

@Scorp,yolo,frag.

I will quote my top town and scum reads with analysis tonight.

[Firebringer]

I am here to say hi.

Such a bad active lurkerer

I honestly don't have much to say so far. Blocky still seems most like scum.

What is your opinion on the contrary arguments that have been raised

They are well written arguments.

No. Honestly Day 1 is a big hassle for me. Its just mass guess work and theory crafting. Day 2 is when you actually figure stuff out. I would rather us lynch Blocky right now then if Blocky is scum that gives us options and have us look at who defended them tomorrow.

Or reverse if town.

I prefer looking at voting patterns than actual post analysis, actions speak louder than words.

[Firebringer]

Don't forget to vote BlockyMan for president! That is what we are voting for right? Leader?

[DeasVail]

I am here to say hi.

Such a bad active lurkerer

I honestly don't have much to say so far. Blocky still seems most like scum.

What is your opinion on the contrary arguments that have been raised

They are well written arguments.

No. Honestly Day 1 is a big hassle for me. Its just mass guess work and theory crafting. Day 2 is when you actually figure stuff out. I would rather us lynch Blocky right now then if Blocky is scum that gives us options and have us look at who defended them tomorrow.

Or reverse if town.

I prefer looking at voting patterns than actual post analysis, actions speak louder than words.

Well I don't know. If you want me to be interested in lynching blocky you'll need to have more than arguing how it's good 'if he's scum' because I don't think so. :/

If you don't want me to vote for him though, then keep going as you are!

[Firebringer]

Okay going to continue as I am.

Read his posts if you see him as town, good for you. I don't.

[redFF]

im gonna reread this game over the weekend

self reminder to take a look at garmr

[redFF]

Same question to RedFF. I was suspicious of Blocky before, but now, especially with the very obvious opposition there is to anyone suspecting SwordMaster, it just seems really unlikely. Like, what is his plan here if scum? He could have grand ambitions of getting SwordMaster lynched, but he is not trying nearly hard enough for that, even if we ignore that glaring lack of likelihood of that happening anyway. If he doesn't want to get SwordMaster lynched and is 'suspecting' him for show, then what does he hope to achieve from that. I think it would be a fairly expected thing that people would find him scummy for it! The only thing that would make sense of his actions for me is if he's scum with SwordMaster, which is where what I will say will stop and I very much doubt that it's what anyone is considering.

this is a very good point and you'll notice i didn't put him at L-1, im going to reread some stuff.

i think firebringer is a better lynch than blocky at this stage, for instance

[redFF]

I prefer looking at voting patterns than actual post analysis, actions speak louder than words.

would love it if you gave us some of the analysis from your voting patterns

really love it

[Firebringer]

Saying I am best lynching option then asking me to explain my actions.

It's like " yeah I think you are guilty so why don't you give me more information so I can interpret that to be proof of your guilt"

Yeah, no thank you.

[Firebringer]

I feel pretty sure you couldn't get the votes on me for Day 1 lynch on me.

Call it w/e I've seen players try it in other games. I have never been lynched day 1 in any mafia game from any source I have ever played.

Wanna try break my streak?

[redFF]

damn u sound pretty confident tbh

i will stop attacking u cause ur a boss and u never get lynched cause ur just that good at mafia

[Firebringer]

damn u sound pretty confident tbh

i will stop attacking u cause ur a boss and u never get lynched cause ur just that good at mafia

Yep.

Though being good at mafia and not getting lynched isn't really related unless you are mafia.


Also I sensed sarcasm in your tone but I will take the compliment anyway, I welcome your attacks knowing they will get you nowhere.

[redFF]

i have been owned

[Firebringer]

i have been owned

I find you mildly entertaining it would be unfortunate if you are mafia. I enjoy your snarky attitude.

[VictorDeAngelo]

I am here to say hi.

Such a bad active lurkerer

I honestly don't have much to say so far. Blocky still seems most like scum.

What is your opinion on the contrary arguments that have been raised

They are well written arguments.

1

No. Honestly Day 1 is a big hassle for me. Its just mass guess work and theory crafting. Day 2 is when you actually figure stuff out. I would rather us lynch Blocky right now then if Blocky is scum that gives us options and have us look at who defended them tomorrow.

Or reverse if town.

I prefer looking at voting patterns than actual post analysis, actions speak louder than words.

1

This is a cop out answer if ever I read one. Can you elaborate on whether the content of the arguments please.

2

My last major action this game was to vote you. What do you think about that?

[VictorDeAngelo]

I feel pretty sure you couldn't get the votes on me for Day 1 lynch on me.

Call it w/e I've seen players try it in other games. I have never been lynched day 1 in any mafia game from any source I have ever played.

Wanna try break my streak?

@All

Come guys, if we work together we can break the streak!!!

[Firebringer]

Breaking someone's streak is as good of reason as any reason to day 1 lynch anyone.

Proves my point about day 1 lynches being arbitrary and random.