Micro 509 - Guyett's Greater Idea Mafia

[Guyett]

Everydaymuffin (1): Kaboose
KaiserB(1): Edosurist,


Not voting (7): Xayzeck, Draynth, TheIrishPope, A Simple Plan, KaiserB, ConManMick, Everydaymuffin

With 9 alive it takes 5 to lynch

Deadline is (expired on 2015-08-16 00:30:00)

[KaiserB]

But I'm not quite sure how worth it that is

[Kaboose]

If TIP is a vig too we have a real problem between him and Mick... Almost the same as me.

This game is starting to annoy me.

[Kaboose]

Well I'm happy with Tip and Mick being town.

I really think Muffin needs to be lynched today.

[Edosurist]

If someone shoots Kaboose and he doesn't die (talking about a third time here), I'll be inclined to believe that he's town.

If we lynch one of Mick or TIP and they flip scum, the other is conftown.

Odds say one of them is scum.

[KaiserB]

But if we really want to use some more maths, we know that there is a 67% chance of any given dayvig being town. Unless two people can't get the exact same role as each other, which means... I guess that one of the dayvigs has only 50% chance of being town.

[Edosurist]

ConManMick -

Cop

TheIrishPope -

Vanilla Townie

I prefer Mick's draw.

@Kaboose why do you think both are town? Assuming you're town, I'd hate to see us lose two 67% chance rolls.

[ConManMick]

How many town day vigs can there be in a game? where's that shagging wiki list gone to...

PEDIT: I'm worried about willingness to play odds, but sure. If you want to 1v1 us, feel free. However, be aware that Pope could be vigilante, 1 shot vig, or another 1 shot day vig, and all you achieve is more townies in the grave.

[ConManMick]

2 possible 1 shot dayvig.

[KaiserB]

http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?tit ... Idea_Mafia
Here's the list for anyone that wants to see it

[KaiserB]

Well guys, if we have another dayvig lying around, feel free to shoot either ConMan or TheIrishPope
If they flip town, then one of the other two is confirmed scum.
But I'm going to go ahead and guess that we don't have 3 dayvigs in one game

[ConManMick]

Do that actually, then lynch kaiser

[KaiserB]

Do that actually, then lynch kaiser

Wow, I may not have fancy mathematics making me probably town, and my logic may be dodgy and wrong, but that doesn't mean you guys can just lynch me. I'm a human being too

[Edosurist]

If there's a town dayvig left, shoot TIP.

@Mick
Pope couldn't be a vigilante. Only dayvigs can take shots during the day.

@All
Why is nobody voting anyone?

[KaiserB]

Maybe we should play this game like people normally play Mafia.
VOTE: Edosurist
I feel you wanting to end the day this early is suspect, trying to cut discussion short for town. You pushed for kaboose's lynch pretty hard, then said we could read people based on who wanted to lynch him and who didn't, without considering the fact that he may be an independent anti-town.

[ConManMick]

If there's a town dayvig left, shoot TIP.

Why not me first? Because I shot first?

@Mick
Pope couldn't be a vigilante. Only dayvigs can take shots during the day.

Ah ok, I thought Day vig was a restricted version.

@All
Why is nobody voting anyone?

you're absolutely right. Let's get moving. VOTE: KaiserB
There's probably 1-2 others I could get behind either, but for now let's go with this.

[KaiserB]

If there's a town dayvig left, shoot TIP.

Why not me first? Because I shot first?

@Mick
Pope couldn't be a vigilante. Only dayvigs can take shots during the day.

Ah ok, I thought Day vig was a restricted version.

@All
Why is nobody voting anyone?

you're absolutely right. Let's get moving. VOTE: KaiserB
There's probably 1-2 others I could get behind either, but for now let's go with this.

Can I ask why?

[EverydayMuffin]

Everydaymuffin (1): Kaboose
KaiserB(1): Edosurist,


Not voting (7): Xayzeck, Draynth, TheIrishPope, A Simple Plan, KaiserB, ConManMick, Everydaymuffin

With 9 alive it takes 5 to lynch

Deadline is (expired on 2015-08-16 00:30:00)

Guyett, did I not unvote?

[KaiserB]

Everydaymuffin (1): Kaboose
KaiserB(1): Edosurist,


Not voting (7): Xayzeck, Draynth, TheIrishPope, A Simple Plan, KaiserB, ConManMick, Everydaymuffin

With 9 alive it takes 5 to lynch

Deadline is (expired on 2015-08-16 00:30:00)

Guyett, did I not unvote?

it says there that you're not voting

[ConManMick]

That means Kaboose is voting you.

[Draynth]

Shoot: Kaboose

Ugh, I wish you hadn't done this.
We could've just lynched Kaboose, we can afford mislynches, and then used this to solve actual problems later on down the line. This was unnecesary IMO especially since we got hardly any information from it.

[ConManMick]

Shoot: Kaboose

Ugh, I wish you hadn't done this.
We could've just lynched Kaboose, we can afford mislynches, and then used this to solve actual problems later on down the line. This was unnecesary IMO especially since we got hardly any information from it.

Should've shot you, dorito head

[Edosurist]

Maybe we should play this game like people normally play Mafia.
VOTE: Edosurist
I feel you wanting to end the day this early is suspect, trying to cut discussion short for town. You pushed for kaboose's lynch pretty hard, then said we could read people based on who wanted to lynch him and who didn't, without considering the fact that he may be an independent anti-town.

I was going to ask where was I cutting discussion short, but I gotcha.

I actually like this post from Kaiser. He seems understandably frustrated under the circumstances.

VOTE: TheIrishPope

People I'm also willing to vote: Draynth and Kaboose.

[Draynth]

If someone shoots Kaboose and he doesn't die (talking about a third time here), I'll be inclined to believe that he's town.

Doesn't he have to be town if he survives again?

[ConManMick]

What about Pope makes him a lynch candidate to you?
PEDIT: That's what Edo is getting at