I answered your question at the bottom in one of my last two posts. I voted him for that reason, go look it up.
As for Wisdom. From my memory of our games and his flips, it's probably true. He was different this game to me, and I just didn't realize before he mentioned it that it should have lead me to assuming he was town because of that.
I probably was unable to figure it out because, as he mentioned, I've never played with him as town. So I never had a game with him as town to compare how he was acting.
In post 255, sthar8 wrote:The jump on Sonic was a huge stretch. Kinda seemed like you might be looking for evidence to scumread him, rather than scumreading him based on the evidence.
how much do you know about how ms plays/thinks as scum vs. town? i think your assessment of his play is severely incorrect if you don't think he enjoys spam posting or that making a bunch of spam posts is something he often does as scum - this is even more so the case when he literally just got out of a game where he and titus (in-hydra) rolled scum and did that exact thing.
there is also that i partially just wanted to warn everyone in advance that if he started posting a bunch of nonsense posts he was likely scum because i don't feel like dealing with that shit
that said, i no longer think it's a thing now that he clarified he had asked her pregame. what do you make of him claiming it made him "obvtown" when he'd probably be honest about it even if he was scum here?
I just completed a game with town-firebringer. the micro with 5 billion neighborhoods. he's posting a lot more in this game, and he's posting trollish looking stuff especially the last page or so.
My impression from that game is that his mafia experience (which is not all on ms) has been in an environment with a very different sort of site meta from MS.
Amid the pressure of great events, a general principle gives no help.
In post 280, fferyllt wrote:I just completed a game with town-firebringer. the micro with 5 billion neighborhoods. he's posting a lot more in this game, and he's posting trollish looking stuff especially the last page or so.
My impression from that game is that his mafia experience (which is not all on ms) has been in an environment with a very different sort of site meta from MS.
i think firebringer suggesting a no lynch is incredibly dumb, but he's probably town. it reads like he thought something along the lines of "no lynch is the theoretically correct play today" (even though it's not, in part for reasons pointed out already) and thinks anyone who disagrees with it has to be bad at the game for not agreeing with it. i really do not think he would have thought to fake it or approach it in this way as scum, and if he did, i think it would have came off more awkward than it did here.
What person lynched rightn. Ow would give us the most info?
And why?
I still don't want a lynch today but I would like to hear peoples thoughts
We treat this day like any other. We poke, we squint, we ask questions, we throw out theories, we vote and we watch votes. We do the stuff that generates reads.
Asking who people want to lynch right this minute gives information, but not information about who will/may be the eventual lynch.
To me, lynch-based info is a distant second. My goal is always to lynch scum.
In post 277, sekai no ki wrote:how much do you know about how ms plays/thinks as scum vs. town? i think your assessment of his play is severely incorrect if you don't think he enjoys spam posting or that making a bunch of spam posts is something he often does as scum - this is even more so the case when he literally just got out of a game where he and titus (in-hydra) rolled scum and did that exact thing.
there is also that i partially just wanted to warn everyone in advance that if he started posting a bunch of nonsense posts he was likely scum because i don't feel like dealing with that shit
that said, i no longer think it's a thing now that he clarified he had asked her pregame. what do you make of him claiming it made him "obvtown" when he'd probably be honest about it even if he was scum here?
I am aware of his spammy tendencies. As scum he's doing it for carnival, as town he gets distracted by irrelevant things like dick-measuring.
Specifically I take issue with the "I want to play with a friend" bit being scummy. Even if he hadn't asked her until after he saw his PM, I don't think it would have been alignment indicative. Sonic has plenty of ego and confidence; there's no way he thinks he needs titus' help. It's much more likely that he wants titus in the game because he enjoys playing with her as either alignment.
In post 282, sekai no ki wrote:i think firebringer suggesting a no lynch is incredibly dumb, but he's probably town. it reads like he thought something along the lines of "no lynch is the theoretically correct play today" (even though it's not, in part for reasons pointed out already) and thinks anyone who disagrees with it has to be bad at the game for not agreeing with it. i really do not think he would have thought to fake it or approach it in this way as scum, and if he did, i think it would have came off more awkward than it did here.
In post 277, sekai no ki wrote:there is also that i partially just wanted to warn everyone in advance that if he started posting a bunch of nonsense posts he was likely scum because i don't feel like dealing with that shit
thats why i particularly posted a bunch of nonsense posts as mason in your game lolol
In post 290, Metal Sonic wrote:i am a cop. in order to remove all wifom from etl i am going to cop her tonight because otherwise she might have to be policy lynched.
I have policy called:
Lynch all liars.
I will give you one chance, is this a real claim? Because if it is and you switch it later I am going to get you lynched .
Hmm, I tend to belive Sonic's claim. But I don't think it should have been claimed+ the target is bad IMO. Why didn't you just shut up, investigated somebody(preferably somebody else like us who you found suspect. Or the other hydra.) and them came with the claim tomorrow with an actual result?
