Star Trek Deep Space Nine Season 1 Mafia(game over!)

[Titus]

I am not sure, but I am leaning towards it. The odds of two doc saves a minimal at best but I just don't like the thought of handing scum free reign on who they kill. Yet with this many people getting two doc saves is difficult.

[Klingoncelt]

(Psst, Titus, it's rein, not reign. Free rein means letting a horse move at the speed and in the direction that the horse desires.)

[MonkeyMan576]

Vote Count 7.02 - Up to post 4451

Titus[2]: Sinsun1, LittleGumball
PeregrineV[1]: Nero Cain
Not Voting[6]: Titus, Thor665, PeregrineV, Riabi, davesaz, Suzune

KlingonCelt is TreeStumped.

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.
Day ends on August 20th at 3:40 PM USA Mountain Time or when a lynch occurs.

[Thor665]

I am not sure, but I am leaning towards it. The odds of two doc saves a minimal at best but I just don't like the thought of handing scum free reign on who they kill. Yet with this many people getting two doc saves is difficult.

We would hand them the Doc, who *already* isn't amongst a reasonable town bloc that exists - even by your own admission.
In exchange we would get an assured scum lynch in 1 (if PV is scum, as you claim) or 2 - after already losing a scum.

Why wouldn't you be behind this? Seems like a good plan to me.
I already netted you one scum using my method - why are you against it this time?

[Thor665]

Pv needs to reveal the town role.

Meh, I am fine with the situation as stands - what are your thoughts on obligatory Doc claim?

[MonkeyMan576]

Riabi has been prodded.

[Titus]

@Thor, I'm not even sure what your method is.

A doctor is the most powerful town role and someone who I usually feel should be protected at all costs. Selling a doctor up the river in exchange for one scum isn't exactly something I want to do lightly. I'm starting to think no one is going to claim doctor though anyway so :S

[Thor665]

@Thor, I'm not even sure what your method is.

Getting scum dead.
Note the last two scum deaths.
Thank you.

A doctor is the most powerful town role and someone who I usually feel should be protected at all costs.

You are wrong.
Doc is a chump role.

Selling a doctor up the river in exchange for one scum isn't exactly something I want to do lightly. I'm starting to think no one is going to claim doctor though anyway so :S

I would trade 1 town PR for 1 scum all day, everyday, in all my town games and would count myself a good player.

If no one would claim Doctor, then that confirms Pere as town, yeah? Or scum bussing...3 scum?

[Klingoncelt]

Vote Count 7.02 - Up to post 4451

Titus[1]: Sinsun1, LittleGumball
PeregrineV[1]: Nero Cain
Not Voting[6]: Titus, Thor665, PeregrineV, Riabi, davesaz, Suzune

KlingonCelt is TreeStumped.

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.
Day ends on August 20th at 3:40 PM USA Mountain Time or when a lynch occurs.

Ooooh, I get my own little headline!

[Titus]

@Thor,

We only lynched ika due to my push (I know you disagree) and Constantine because he had an undeniable slip IMO.

We disagree on theory, and you're pretty much the only player I listen to on disagreements.

If no one claims doctor, a doctor might just not exist, thus making PereV scum.

But fine, let's do it. Doc claim. It's not me.

[Titus]

Grandma, you should totally try to persuade me of things. That's part of the fun as outed scum. Having everyone know you're scum and still fucking with minds.

[Klingoncelt]

You guys are doing a great job with wifom, in fact I was just going to make a batch of extra-buttery popcorn, lol.

[Sinsun1]

If no one would claim Doctor, then that confirms Pere as town, yeah? Or scum bussing...3 scum?

In your own words. Come on Thor, just sheep me and we'll get PereV tomorrow if Titus really is town (which I doubt fully and throughly as you keep trying to reason with her and she doesn't see it, where if she is a good town player like people claim, she would).

[Titus]

Read 4459 again. I literally just claimed not doctor.

[Sinsun1]

We only lynched ika due to my push (I know you disagree) and Constantine because he had an undeniable slip IMO.

Let's forget about the fact you refused to vote off Kling who's alignment was revealed upon being treestumped and better yet giving us an extra mislynch in which you had no part of helping with.

No matter whether I was the first or last one on all 3 scum wagons, I've played my part in helping net all 3 current scum flips. Can you say the same? Oh wait, you can't. Because you wanted to lynch PereV who netted us Kling because of your paranoia.

Not sure if the reason I can see you so clear as day is because I'm not bias about your alignment because of no past experience to base your play on, or if others really just can't see the obviousness here.

Also, seriously, with TWO scum left, you wouldn't trade a doctor who didn't save our tracker for confirmed scum making us go into a day where we we have 2 mislynches left to hunt a SINGLE scum. Of course you wouldn't though, because outting doc now meant flipping doc-scum.

P.S, you still can't take credit for the Ika flip. You did basically diddly squat before town had already started looking at that slot.

[Sinsun1]

Read 4459 again. I literally just claimed not doctor.

I've known that for a while darling. It's down to Riabi or Nero to claim it. Nero did not claim it yet but did vote PereV. That being said, to convince everyone else, he seems like the type that would. So unless Riabi comes back and claims town doctor, it will be safe to assume there isn't a TOWN doctor.

[MonkeyMan576]

Vote Count 7.02 - Up to post 4451

Titus[1]: Sinsun1, LittleGumball
PeregrineV[1]: Nero Cain
Not Voting[6]: Titus, Thor665, PeregrineV, Riabi, davesaz, Suzune

KlingonCelt is TreeStumped.

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.
Day ends on August 20th at 3:40 PM USA Mountain Time or when a lynch occurs.

Ooooh, I get my own little headline!

******

I can put a pretty picture too if you like.

[MonkeyMan576]

Riabi has been prodded.

[Klingoncelt]

Vote Count 7.02 - Up to post 4451

Titus[1]: Sinsun1, LittleGumball
PeregrineV[1]: Nero Cain
Not Voting[6]: Titus, Thor665, PeregrineV, Riabi, davesaz, Suzune

KlingonCelt is TreeStumped.

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.
Day ends on August 20th at 3:40 PM USA Mountain Time or when a lynch occurs.

Ooooh, I get my own little headline!

******

I can put a pretty picture too if you like.

<3<3<3

Thank you! It looks just like me - you even got my good side!

[LittleGumball]

If no one claims doctor, a doctor might just not exist, thus making PereV scum.

This statement is just wrong. A town doctor not existing does not mean that Pere must be scum. A town doctor that DOES exist would make him scum.

[Titus]

If no one claims doctor, a doctor might just not exist, thus making PereV scum.

This statement is just wrong. A town doctor not existing does not mean that Pere must be scum. A town doctor that DOES exist would make him scum.

I was saying no doctor existing makes PerV scum because his theory requires a scum doctor.

[davesaz]

No doctor would only be possible if the lightning rod is bulletproof, or no kills were submitted.

[LittleGumball]

If no one claims doctor, a doctor might just not exist, thus making PereV scum.

This statement is just wrong. A town doctor not existing does not mean that Pere must be scum. A town doctor that DOES exist would make him scum.

I was saying no doctor existing makes PerV scum because his theory requires a scum doctor.

No one's going to claim scum doctor...

Dave does have a point, Suzune said she's not bulletproof so there must be a doctor because she didn't die. And scum doctor can't claim town doctor because when they're not killed in the night it'll be obvious they were lying.

[Sinsun1]

No doctor would only be possible if the lightning rod is bulletproof, or no kills were submitted.

So yeah, vote Titus in your next post unless you can come up with a reason why not to. Her logic is faulty and laced with scum agenda.

[PeregrineV]

Good Monday morning! Will do some reading today.