Star Trek Deep Space Nine Season 1 Mafia(game over!)

[PeregrineV]

Sorry, fixed.

Riabi replacement?

[Titus]

We have three days.

Should I just not bother the mod with finding a replacement who will likely be lynched and hammer?

[Klingoncelt]

Maybe Boonskiies can replace in and hammer himself, lol.

[MonkeyMan576]

We have three days.

Should I just not bother the mod with finding a replacement who will likely be lynched and hammer?

I'm looking for a replacement now.

[Thor665]

We have three days.

Should I just not bother the mod with finding a replacement who will likely be lynched and hammer?

Dunno, do you think the slot is scum or no?

[Titus]

Possible but it's also clear to me we aren't lynching my main scumreads. Supposing I'm wrong, he'd be my scumread along with Nero.

[Nero Cain]

@Nero - how does Suzune's claim, backed by Pere and with a cop in play not confirm her? You would need both Suzune and Pere to be scum in that instance and also have a way to gawk with cop results...on a lightning rod. So...pretty much she would need to be a GF and scum would have to have someone who can assign as a lightning rod, and they would have had to role block the Tracker.

In my defense I had forgotten about the cop inno on her but that aside, she was a claimed lightning rod that had used her power so PV (as scum) would have to be pretty horrible to not know this. Why do you think PV, as scum, would not be able to know she was a rod?

but I guess part of it is just being paranoid that all of Suzune, Sin, Titus, and Gumball are keeping me at arms length and keeping me around as a potential mislynch.

So no, it makes sense to have a FEW good PRs when the bad ones outnumber the good.

town has two full investigative roles, a vig and a gladiator, 2 limited investigation roles, an op roleblocker (light rod) and 4 WIFOMish town roles.

vs.

a useless treestump, a roleblocker, and a motivator and (according to PV) a tracker and a doctor.

Do you think this is balanced? *shrugz* IDK, just looks like alot of town power to me.

[Sinsun1]

I am not sure how useful a gladiator is due to never encountering them in games before. However, let's look at those roles again.

A TWO-SHOT vig (not unlimited) who admitted to killing the town miller which possibly got the town hider killed.

Tracker and hider were limited roles. We'd need to know who the hider hid behind for it to count as investigative.

Lightning rod was ONE SHOT.

I'm interested to know your full list of investigative roles. I only have Cop and Tracker really pegged for it and Tracker was VERY limited and likely to die as well in most scenarios.

But now we have an Oracle who managed to ask the right questions and everyone gets paranoid.

The motivator basically meant the mafia got 2 roleblocks while he was alive. Really think about that. The tracker they could use to find out who had powers to block.

Besides all that, this game has yet to make sense. Also where is your explanation at the lack of Doctor claim to out PereV as mafia if he were lying to us?

[davesaz]

I'm back and willing to hammer. Did we have a claim from Riabi? Also willing to wait to get one from the slot, since it could be vital info.

[Klingoncelt]

A TWO-SHOT vig (not unlimited) who admitted to killing the town miller which possibly got the town hider killed.

Tracker and hider were limited roles. We'd need to know who the hider hid behind for it to count as investigative.

Maxwell didn't hide behind anyone. I killed him.

lol

[Suzune]

I feel like pointing out that in the long run Kling will be bad for us because he will warp our opinions on the game so far because that is the advantage to being a claimed mafia. It might be better to just lynch him...

[Klingoncelt]

Happy Birthday, Suzune!


No warping, I really did kill Maxwell.

[LittleGumball]

Happy birthday Suzune. We can't lynch Kling, the best option is to ignore or (to be extreme) not even read her posts.

@Dave, Riabi has said literally nothing today. I don't think we'll get anything out of him anytime soon.

[Klingoncelt]

... Riabi has said literally nothing today. I don't think we'll get anything out of him anytime soon.

Yep, lynch that lurker!

[Sinsun1]

... Riabi has said literally nothing today. I don't think we'll get anything out of him anytime soon.

Yep, lynch that lurker!

Don't worry, we will. Regardless of the WIFOM you're presenting by speaking, the fact Titus wants you to talk so much tells me Titus is scum. Among other things I've stated. Riabi might be scum he might not be, all I know is he is in the scummy pool and I'm doing this so Thor will hopefully help me with who I believe without a doubt to be scum lynched.

[Klingoncelt]

What wifom?

It used to be a thing to lynch lurkers, then it wasn't, we were supposed to give the replace-ins a chance to redeem their slot, and now lynching lurkers - and siteflakes - is a thing again.

I wish that I could still vote.

[Sinsun1]

I wish that I could still vote.

You can still vote, it just wont count.

[Klingoncelt]

True dat.

[LittleGumball]

Thing is, Riabi was scum before he ever lurked/siteflaked c:

[MonkeyMan576]

Day ends in less than 24 hours.

[Sinsun1]

Someone just hammer this.

[Thor665]

@Nero - how does Suzune's claim, backed by Pere and with a cop in play not confirm her? You would need both Suzune and Pere to be scum in that instance and also have a way to gawk with cop results...on a lightning rod. So...pretty much she would need to be a GF and scum would have to have someone who can assign as a lightning rod, and they would have had to role block the Tracker.

In my defense I had forgotten about the cop inno on her but that aside, she was a claimed lightning rod that had used her power so PV (as scum) would have to be pretty horrible to not know this. Why do you think PV, as scum, would not be able to know she was a rod?

but I guess part of it is just being paranoid that all of Suzune, Sin, Titus, and Gumball are keeping me at arms length and keeping me around as a potential mislynch.

So no, it makes sense to have a FEW good PRs when the bad ones outnumber the good.

town has two full investigative roles, a vig and a gladiator, 2 limited investigation roles, an op roleblocker (light rod) and 4 WIFOMish town roles.

vs.

a useless treestump, a roleblocker, and a motivator and (according to PV) a tracker and a doctor.

Do you think this is balanced? *shrugz* IDK, just looks like alot of town power to me.

I fail to follow your Suzune discussion...you are agreeing with me that she is both a lightning rod and that if she is scum then scum would need a tool to mess with the cop that doesn't involve targeting? That doesn't work though. So she herself has to be a GF and they have to have a create-a-rod power for her to. Be scum, yeah? Could you tell me your current theory on her alignment?

Gladiator is a pure anti-town role.

[Thor665]

Someone just hammer this.

+1

[Titus]

No Gladiator isn't.

VOTE: Riabli

[MonkeyMan576]

Vote Count 7.05 - Up to post 4673

Riabi[5]: Thor665, LittleGumball, Sinsun1, Suzune, Titus[Lynch!]
PeregrineV[1]: Nero Cain

Not Voting[3]: PeregrineV, Riabi, davesaz

KlingonCelt is TreeStumped.

ModNote: Thor665 and Davesaz are VLA. That's a lynch! 6 hours of twilight.

A Lynch has occured.