Open 606: Near-Vanilla 40k TOWN WINS

[ika]

Page 7 and I already am no longer reading

Yes my Internet is Stil shot and I'm borrowing iPad so points to anyone who figures why I stopped

[St Constantine the Hermit]

We're at Day 1 right now, while I have seen a town bloc form early of town players before how do you know all 3 of you are town at this point in the game? How much history do all 3 of you have together?

There are players that are generally easy to read. Vedith is not one of them.

If you look at the game state though, everyone was sucking up to me for awhile, and Titus was the first to apply any pressure to 4xty.

[St Constantine the Hermit]

I don't think I agree with most what Hermit says, but I feel confident he is town.

Titus's slot has ignored all critical anaylisis on the major wagons, and instead is trying to extremely light tunnel the players that honestly have no chance of being lynched today, IE, me and 4xty. Sheeping Yimmy was like what? Then claiming to have liked her case was even worst, because post #259 only contained

ONE

question asking me why I stated I would be okay policy lynching a town read.

There was also some serious scumminess in regards to how she joined the game and began to vote Verity, but switched ships when Verity started to receive more attention than ASP. To top things off, Titus's meta is hard tunneling players that are usually scum, and since her play this game is light tunneling obvious town, I am under the impression that we are not dealing with town Titus

@Firebringer

What about Titus makes sense to you? I am pretty sure you are town reading me, 4xty, and Vedith, and it isn't like Titus has been making actual cases (instead resorting to common survivalist tactics)

[Firebringer]

That sheep on Yimmy was kind of odd, when I looked at it.

I don't know about lynching Titus today though. The meta reasons actually paint her as more town to me than anything else. I would like to hear more from duppin.

How you reading him?

[ika]

hi ppl still board and we get an l-1?

[Vedith]

I think that anyone with votes on me should take them off!

VOTE: TheWorst

I don't think that I'm wrong.

[ForWhomTheJellyRolls]

Why are you voting TheWorst?

[ForWhomTheJellyRolls]

We have less than 4 days until deadling and as far as I can see yours is the only vote on TheWorst. What are you hoping to acomplish with your vote?

[St Constantine the Hermit]

He is hoping to accomplish anything. He wants to start a hopeless wagon instead of taking the risk at being associated with a town flip. Despicable!

[Vedith]

I've already said my opinion on The Worst.
I don't want to vote Titus and I'm obviously not going to vote myself.
If I'm put into a situation where voting for ASP just before deadline will cause a lynch over a no lynch I will easy vote them.

A part from that the thread isn't moving in a good direction.

[St Constantine the Hermit]

This I am actually pretty passionate about.

For whatever reason, players on MS do not find it scummy or anti-town when someone purposefully signs up to a wagon that is unreachable. Scum do this a lot to avoid being associated with being on a wagon that flips town, but it is also anti-town, because one of the few powers you have in this game is your vote, and it is wasted when you put it on an unreachable wagon!

[Vedith]

Like your vote on Titus?

[Firebringer]

This I am actually pretty passionate about.

For whatever reason, players on MS do not find it scummy or anti-town when someone purposefully signs up to a wagon that is unreachable. Scum do this a lot to avoid being associated with being on a wagon that flips town, but it is also anti-town, because one of the few powers you have in this game is your vote, and it is wasted when you put it on an unreachable wagon!

So joining a wagon for a player you think is town, is somehow a town move? What?
What kind of logic is this?

Like I understand regretfully joining up with trains because you read a player Null, or partly think lean town on them a little, but if you think a player is full on town and their is no doubt about it in your mind. That is EXTREMELY ANTI TOWN to join the wagon just for a lynch to take place.

[TheWorst]

Ok been readin'. Vampirate is a null for me for now, didn't like his first few posts at first (that meta seemed pointless to me), but since then he's shown the intent to expand his reads and knowledge, which is good. Have some doubts about him though. I like Titus's logic (e.g. her response to me), and it's interesting that she would go after three of the more prominent players, though I don't think Hermit would be a good lynch at all, that's where I disagree.

@ASP

If you find that Titus is the only one making sense, how do you feel about her idea that Vedith, Hermit, and Anxiety are scum?

@Yimmy

If you're up for a Hermit lynch, why would you find it ridiculous that Titus sheeped you? What's your read on Hermit then?

@Vedith

Oh woah! You should look at post 260 for my opinion on you now! Anyway, I find it curious that you didn't acknowledge or respond to my last post, instead focused on Titus claiming you post no substance, and Hermit + Vampirate. And your reasoning still seems based on my posting style than my content.
You did spark some sort of discussion, so hats off to you on that one.

@Jelly

What the hell, there's 4 days left already? And STILL no replacement for The Enigma? That slot really is gonna remain mysterious. I'd suggest that the

Mod

should bump the replacement post or something.
Anyway Jelly, this is the first time you've talked in a while, got anything else?

Also, it's a shame that Randomidget might not make it back in time.

[duppin]

@duppin: Your take in all this my and enigma's slot aside?

To be completely honest, I find this question very wierd. I am very curious as to why you'd call me out on this?

I don't care about Titus vs Constantine, it does not change anything for me at the moment. Already gave my opinion on Constantine, and I don't find Titus scummy.

I still think you and Enigma's slot are the most interesting targets today.

[Firebringer]

Why doesn't the worst ever ask me anything ;(

[TheWorst]

I thought you hated questions! I fear for another question rant if I ask you something.

[Vampirate]

@duppin: Your take in all this my and enigma's slot aside?

To be completely honest, I find this question very wierd. I am very curious as to why you'd call me out on this?

I don't care about Titus vs Constantine, it does not change anything for me at the moment. Already gave my opinion on Constantine, and I don't find Titus scummy.

I still think you and Enigma's slot are the most interesting targets today.

Quite simply you're giving me the in the background vibe so I decided to bring you out in the light.

[4nxi3ty]

mah ASP lightbulb still hasn't clicked on huh

yawn

enigma is probly town

I'm not sure I like the Enigma lynch right now, though.

In particular regarding Enigma, the questioning from 36 and the edit in 37 are sound and come from a similar strand of curiosity regarding Fire's comment.

having trouble seeing who the 3rd scum could be

[Firebringer]

I thought you hated questions! I fear for another question rant if I ask you something.

I hate stupid questions, fluff questions, and questions that are loaded.

So maybe it is best you don't ask me any.

[duppin]

@duppin: Your take in all this my and enigma's slot aside?

To be completely honest, I find this question very wierd. I am very curious as to why you'd call me out on this?

I don't care about Titus vs Constantine, it does not change anything for me at the moment. Already gave my opinion on Constantine, and I don't find Titus scummy.

I still think you and Enigma's slot are the most interesting targets today.

Quite simply you're giving me the in the background vibe so I decided to bring you out in the light.

It was a silly question. I can't tell whether you are trying to pretend you are scum hunting or you just sincerely believe it was a good way to "bring me out in the light".

[Yimmy]

@Yimmy

If you're up for a Hermit lynch, why would you find it ridiculous that Titus sheeped you? What's your read on Hermit then?

After my first game (offsite) where scum essentially won the game by using my constant radom sheeping with no new reasoning to add, I don't really like sheeping with no real reasoning to add.

[Titus]

@Yimmy

If you're up for a Hermit lynch, why would you find it ridiculous that Titus sheeped you? What's your read on Hermit then?

After my first game (offsite) where scum essentially won the game by using my constant radom sheeping with no new reasoning to add, I don't really like sheeping with no real reasoning to add.

Link to this game please?

Also, are you saying that you as scum randomly sheeped everything or that scum randomly sheeped you? or that scum "scumread" you for randomly sheeping?

[Yimmy]

http://www.interguild.org/members/forum ... hp?id=7456 Day 1
http://www.interguild.org/members/forum ... hp?id=7479 Day 2
I as town randomly sheeped everyone

[Titus]

So your concern is scum might use that against me? I guess?

I don't sheep lightly. I'm one of the most stubborn players on this site. I am known that way because I require a great deal of proof. People sheep all the time, sometimes with naked votes (not even declaring sheepage). You'll have to get used to that. We all can't be first on a wagon.