In post 197, Spiffeh wrote:Is anyone else not understanding what catboi's issue with me is? If someone else does could they please explain it to me?
And catboi I still want an answer: Who else is scummy other than Shinobi?
In post 202, Kyubey The Kid wrote:Oh and I'm currently writing an analysis of what I believe to be the current gamestate, but it's getting pretty lengthy. Should I keep it to myself or are you guys ok with what is amounting to be my will and testament?
In post 195, Kyubey The Kid wrote:In post 193, catboi wrote:In post 191, Kyubey The Kid wrote:While I can't really townread anyone at the moment, I'd lean more towards Jean being town than not. He hasn't done anything that would stand out as either alignment, but since his approach has been more investigative than accusative, my gut tells me he's town. That said, I wouldn't bet my life on it or anything. I don't agree with him voting for you though.
Why is being "investigative" more likely to make someone town?
Because of what drives both sides. Unlike townies, who are supposed to be motivated to find out who is who, scum's objective in the game is to mislead others into lynching the wrong person. In other words, they're not in it to find out anyone's alignment because they already possess that info. If the majority of posts someone has are at their core just accusations, then it's more likely for that person be scum than not. Of course everyone HAS to accuse at some point, and the frequency of accusations someone does is also very dependent on play style, so this isn't exactly a foolproof method of identifying scum. On average though, I've found it wiser to be more suspicious of those who just accuse and don't make it a priority to explain their reasoning over those who try to understand the other players and explain their thought process to everyone without being forced to. It's not that being investigative proves innocence (since a good scum should already knows this and will therefore try to be as investigative as possible); It's that accusing a lot makes people more suspicious of everyone and therefore makes it harder for the townies to band together, which at the very least is anti-town. This is largely based on my preference in play style and how I think so I'm not really asking people to base their suspicions on what is largely just my gut instinct.
In post 206, RadiantCowbells wrote:The stupidity is unfathomable.
Once you've seen that I'm town, speedlynch Shinobi.
In post 211, catboi wrote:RC you're really not helping things by posting this way
fact is though they're horribly wrong they're trying in earnest and I don't think they deserve this sort of treatment
In post 206, RadiantCowbells wrote:The stupidity is unfathomable.
Once you've seen that I'm town, speedlynch Shinobi.
In post 207, RadiantCowbells wrote:Like literally I've played some terrible games but this one is in a tier of it's own.
Spiffeh and Kyubey so self righteous in their idiocy that it's just sickening.
In post 214, Shinobi wrote:In post 211, catboi wrote:RC you're really not helping things by posting this way
fact is though they're horribly wrong they're trying in earnest and I don't think they deserve this sort of treatment
Basically, though I'm not sure on the wrong/not wrong bit.
You're playing like a shitter and everyone just kind of wants you to explain things so we can move forward.
In post 217, Spiffeh wrote:Not thrilled that Shinobi sees someone at L-1 this early and doesn't unvote.
In post 220, Spiffeh wrote:RC is at L-1 in #205
You post #210
I unvote #212
You saw him at L-1 and left him there.
In post 222, catboi wrote:shinobi btw never posted an actual tangible explanation for voting RC (because he doesn't have one)
In post 223, Spiffeh wrote:Then it's safe to assume you believe his reaction to being at L-1 was scummy? If so why?
