Mini Normal 1711: Flavor not required. D2 deadline: 9/29/15

[Spiffeh]

You probably are town. That is playing against your WC as scum too anyway.

PEdit: I think you are town for your L-1 reaction. That was recent.

[Kyubey The Kid]

That assumes that I'm town.

Why would you care whether or not we're assuming you're town if you just want to get the lynching over with? If you were town and wanted to sabotage our game then you wouldn't care about other's opinion about your alignment.

[RadiantCowbells]

If you were town and wanted to sabotage our game then you wouldn't care about other's opinion about your alignment.

Holy fuck you're a genius your analysis is SO AMAZING.

Can you at least promise me that when it turns out that every single pretentious pile of shit you've piled into this thread is wrong you'll shut the fuck up and let people who know how to play do the talking?

[Kyubey The Kid]

If you were town and wanted to sabotage our game then you wouldn't care about other's opinion about your alignment.

Holy fuck you're a genius your analysis is SO AMAZING.

Can you at least promise me that when it turns out that every single pretentious pile of shit you've piled into this thread is wrong you'll shut the fuck up and let people who know how to play do the talking?

You didn't answer the question that you conveniently cut out of my quote.

[RadiantCowbells]

VOTE: Kyubey The Kid

I'm not even sure he's town anymore.

This is a level of stupid so profound that it might be faked scum logic.

[Kyubey The Kid]

VOTE: Kyubey The Kid

I'm not even sure he's town anymore.

This is a level of stupid so profound that it might be faked scum logic.

Oh, I thought you didn't care about the game anymore. This leads me again to the main question you keep dodging: Why do your actions keep contradicting your words?

[RadiantCowbells]

Which leads me to the main question you keep dodging: Why do you talk so much when you have absolutely nothing to say?

[Kyubey The Kid]

Nothing to say? I've been saying plenty. Mostly that I think you're doing a shitty bluff after you not having a solid argument against my theory. You've just been deflecting while adding nothing of substance to the conversation in hopes that I doubt myself out of some fear of looking stupid enough to back down after my scumread on you. Unfortunately for you, I've looked like an idiot so many times in my life that I've learned that it's better to look stupid and learn why I was wrong than to be silent and uninformed. Someone so unhelpful and antagonizing as you is either an idiot townie or a bad scum. Thankfully you're not an idiot; You're just scum.

[catboi]

VOTE: RC

I'm not playing this. hammer me.

stop doing this. what the hell is wrong with you?

anyone who hammers this while i'm out i'm taking as a scumclaim.

[catboi]

oh somehow i missed that vote change. point still stands given two people could easily vote that

honestly think kyubey's irrationally misguided but probably town given the way he's posted

[Kyubey The Kid]

oh somehow i missed that vote change. point still stands given two people could easily vote that

honestly think kyubey's irrationally misguided but probably town given the way he's posted

I'd actually appreciate it if I was told why I'm so obviously wrong. Seriously. If my claims are as idiotic as both you and RC claim, then it really shouldn't be so hard for you two experts to dismantle my arguments. So far all you've done is say I'm wrong 'cause I'm wrong without providing any alternatives to me. The fact that the two people that are accused by me are so unwilling to help me figure things out doesn't help your case.

[Scorpious]

I have no problems saying goodbye to RC. All I see is an angry person that is always finding reasons to insult others.. Not alignment indicative obviously, but I still have no issues getting rid of that.Especially since we have a lot of new players here.

I'm at work so I should be able to get good input in before 5.

[Kyubey The Kid]

Even if you agree with lynching RC, for the sake of arguing both sides, could you try and give reasons as to why I might be wrong?

[Scorpious]

Even if you agree with lynching RC, for the sake of arguing both sides, could you try and give reasons as to why I might be wrong?

Nope. I agree with you. You might be wrong cause it's D1,and D1's are a crapshoot at best. I am working on my read list though..

[Shinobi]

Literally, Shinobi, you are behind Huntress the worst scum player I have ever seen and I can't even fathom how you manage to get these backwards ass towns every time.

You're going to win this game, and you don't deserve it at all.

Replace out then please.

no.

Maybe you can explain your read and I can tell you why it's wrong?

[Scorpious]

Catboi

- I can't discuss much about my read on him due to site rules but I'm really struggling to get any kind of solid read on him.He's obviously making it a point to be at the forefront of the conversation. Again,I don't want to go into too much here because I don't want to skirt rules. Ask me specifics on this one if you'd like. Total null here

JeanDarc

- I really like the questioning.There is some follow-up to,which I like. This is how I would expect a newb town to be on this site. Town

KTK

-I was wary of this one since the beginning. I still absolutely hate that "covenant" comment. I don't like "inside jokes" in these games. Has been active and inquisitive,but I also don't like them asking if they should post analysis. What possible reason would you have to hold back? Are you worried about something?. Scum Lean

LexTrew

-A useless slot so far,Nothing to read..Needs to pick it up... null

Radiant Cowbells

-Disengaged,abrasive,not doing anything but promote apathy. Nothing about any of these behaviors is pro town. If you are town,and you vote yourself. YOU ARE NOT HELPING TOWN!!! Lynch this today.. SCUM

Scorpious

-Me.. Town

Shinobi

- Very antsy at the beginning of the game. I do like some of his answers,but some of them seem a little twitchy and forced. There is a lot from this slot. I really want to ISO this in greater detail..slight scum lean..slight.

Spiffeh

- Gut town on this one,and that's it.. Nothing else but gut.. Town Lean

vijay2vasandani

-Useless,and what little we have gotten is erratic. This is either piss poor play or scum..

Feel free to pick apart any of these. I love answering questions..

[Kyubey The Kid]

Oh the covenant thing was just a comment about the player you replaced leaving so early. I don't have any inside jokes here since I don't know I anyone on this forum.

In my analysis I said that RC's guilt is strong evidence for Catboi's guilt, but you seem to think otherwise. He's been behaving like RC, except that he actually tries to discuss the game sometimes. He's been defending RC to an extreme that a townie shouldn't be able to do without just being very trusting of him, unlike Spiffeh who pressed RC before deciding he's town. I think it's more likely that Catboi and RC are working together than RC being guilty and Catboi just naively believing in him without question.

[Kyubey The Kid]

Forgot to ask: Why would you not be at least leaning towards Catboi being scum over just a null read?

[Scorpious]

Forgot to ask: Why would you not be at least leaning towards Catboi being scum over just a null read?

That I can't say.. Sorry,not trying to be difficult..

[Scorpious]

I don't feel confident calling him either way right now..

[Kyubey The Kid]

Forgot to ask: Why would you not be at least leaning towards Catboi being scum over just a null read?

That I can't say.. Sorry,not trying to be difficult..

Nah it's cool. I'm just trying to find any oversight on my part by bouncing my reasoning off you. What's the biggest thing holding you back from giving a scum read on Carboi?

[Scorpious]

Forgot to ask: Why would you not be at least leaning towards Catboi being scum over just a null read?

That I can't say.. Sorry,not trying to be difficult..

Nah it's cool. I'm just trying to find any oversight on my part by bouncing my reasoning off you. What's the biggest thing holding you back from giving a scum read on Carboi?

that's kinda the same question no?(heh,carboi). Like I said as of right now,me saying I'm leaning either way on him right now would be a false statement. I really do not know what to make of him right now..

[Kyubey The Kid]

If you had to blindly guess which is more likely, what would you chose between the conflicting theories of them working together and Catboi defending RC because he just KNOWS that RC is town? Really just use your gut to chose even if you think it's most likely wrong. At least a choice between option A and B helps me understand what could be wrong in my approach to this problem.

[Scorpious]

gun to my head. I would lean scum on Cat..

[Kyubey The Kid]

Thanks, so do you believe my reasoning is retarded/irrational or do you can your understand why I would think this way?