Open 609: Pick Your Poison (Game Over)

[Shiro]

VOTE: Shiro

My bah post

[Luna Fox]

So i'm here now. This will take a while, while i'd prefer to have another conf town (a.k.a the 3rd PR to claim, or a potential 2 conf towns in the event of a cop with an inno) to make this easier im not going to force them if they don't want to, i'm going to wait a bit because an extra conf town would help greatly on the analisis.

I'm still currently leaning on voting ika today, but mario's "looks like im the scum designated mislynch of today" is weird, since im the only one that changed their stance from before at the start, and opted to vote ika, who im thinking of voting.

Anyway, just food for thought, be back later.

[ika]

sigh....

cus people wont shut up about me ill claim then

im the 3rd pr

[Luna Fox]

That does help a lot actually, if no one CCs you're conf town, that simplifies my pool of possible scum candidates to:
Mario
Panther
Vedith
Diego

2 town / 2 scum.

That's a 50/50 chance to vote scum if i were to vote randomly, those are already great odds.
Anyways analysis coming soonish.

[Luna Fox]

Performer

- 6 -

Alchemist21

, Luna Fox,

Shiro

, MarioManiac4, Vedith,

ika

Diego1487 - 1 -

Performer

Not Voting:

MaxwellPuckett

, Diego1487, PantherPunt

There's 1-2 scum among Vedith, MM4.

If someone CCs ika then there's guaranteed 1 scum among ika and whoever CCs ika.

I'm going to look at Vedith's and MM4's reads and progression as well as MM4's alt/predecessor's reads. Thinking about it, im still iffy about sparrowbird's L-1 vote on bella, specially now that we know she's town...

[Luna Fox]

i just realized that scum probably knows what ika's PR is, so i dont know why ika didnt claim the actual PR. Anyway:

Spoiler: Sparrowbird/Mario

Welcome to Shitfest 2015!

Vote:

Bellaphant

This is so I have enough time to read shit without it growing so fast I never catch up!

Note this was an L-1 vote

Sparrowbird
ika -> Correct
Firebringer -> Correct
Vedith -> ???

PantherPunt -> ???
Luna Fox -> Correct
Flow Alpha -> Correct
TellTaleHeart -> Correct

Alchemist21 -> Wrong
MaxwellPuckett -> Wrong

Lizard_Buttock -> Correct
Shiro -> Wrong

Bellaphant -> Wrong

I would prefer to lynch

Silverjaws

than

TTH

.

Interesting to note, Sparrow/Mario keep avoiding mentioning anything related to why they wouldn't prefer to lynch TTH over Silver, despite being asked multiple times by panther.

There are more scummy players.

Can you help me out and give some semblance of support for any of your reads? I don't understand why you keep refusing to do so, tbh. I mean- unless you are scum and are trying to avoid spewing your team since others have meta on you.

The reason I made a fucking alt is that I'm fucking tired of meta.
And my reads are actually mostly gut.

Silverjaws

has slanged mud at everyone, so I'm scumreading him. You and Luna reads as classic TvT to me.

Ika

is ika and he basically has an activity tell that is basically never broken. I see scum movitation in clogging up the thread, and

Alchemist

is the only one apart from you and Luna, who are townreads, to do that. Plus

Alchemist

's post 435 almost seems like guilt/fustration that he helped make his buddy replace out.
Apart from that, yeah, mostly gut. (And gut adds to the reads I've mentioned anyway.)

I promise if somebody hammers

Silverjaws

I'll read this clusterfuck <3

I'm, like, sort of around?
I didn't mean I won't catch up, I mean I won't read the tvtvs (IMO) that transpired over a few pages and changed pretty much naught.
I'm leaning

Alchemist

for the S, but it may well be you.

I'm leaning Alchemist for the S, but it may well be you.

Oook eh exactly what are you scumreading on Panth cause that is some odd accusations. You are calling scum m top town read here.

I'm saying I see Luna as more town them him and I believe LunavPPv

Alchemist

is TvTvS

Question if you read this, but now that alch is IC what's your opinion on this?

VOTE: silverjaws

VOTE: Performer

It's pretty obvious

Performer

got his pants in a twist at Silver getting run up on d1.

Alchemist

could be third scum but I honestly suspect

ika

at this point.

Eh, i think mario might be town after all, interesting things to note, his reads were more or less correct D1, but not D2, same case as mine so i don't mind it as much.

[Vedith]

Luna, explain to us how you can't be scum again?

[Luna Fox]

I'm not saying i can't be, but my role PM is town obviously im not going to scumhunt myself.

[Vedith]

VOTE: Ika

Like Luna said, why not say what your role is?
I don't buy it.

[Luna Fox]

Nah ika's probably not scum, unless there's a CC, ika just probably didn't realize that scum already know who the last role is. If there's a CC then maybe.

[ika]

VOTE: Ika

Like Luna said, why not say what your role is?
I don't buy it.

you realzie that scum pick the roles right?

they know what i am

[Luna Fox]

you realzie that scum pick the roles right?

they know what i am

That's the point, so why hide it and not let town know what you are?

[Vedith]

So why not let us know?

Pedit - Yeah what Luna said.
You would be helping the scum here.

[ika]

So why not let us know?

Pedit - Yeah what Luna said.
You would be helping the scum here.

*shrugs* i like suspense stuff

im tracker

[Luna Fox]

Do you have anything good that could helps us figure out who's scum? Even someone not being tracked anywhere could be good information.

[ika]

Do you have anything good that could helps us figure out who's scum? Even someone not being tracked anywhere could be good information.

unfortunately no....

bella was my night one and shiro was my night 2

both are kinda obvious at this point on what results are

[Luna Fox]

orz

Oh well

[Vedith]

So who are we looking at today then?
Ika is confirmed town at least.

[Luna Fox]

So who are we looking at today then?
Ika is confirmed town at least.

Still the same pool of 5 (Me, You, Diego, PP, Mario)
I know i'm town im trying to figure out which half is scum.

[Luna Fox]

This is mostly because my whole PoE flipping town means that i misread 2 people as town, so i need to do a global reset and restart.

[Luna Fox]

My current main point of contention is that Panther Punt's entire reads list has been consistently wrong, which usually tends to be more indicative of scum than town, of course this can't be fully verified without me or diego flipping, while im fine flipping myself, that would result in a 1v1 between Panther and Diego tomorrow, which still doesn't help us, im trying to narrow down who the 2nd one is atm.

[Vedith]

Okay, I wasn't going to do this because it means I'm dead tonight. The problem is, if we mis lynch today then tomorrow it's a believe me or not situation to win/lose the game.

I'm the Tracker. Ika is actually scum.
I gain less than Ika for claiming tracker after him. When we lynch Ika you have either a scum on that day or a scum lynch the next day.
Ika was a decent suspect to look at today, outing the tracker can scum a possible mis lynch on him, and if not a kill during the night.

I also think that Alch is his partner, but that's only because he was in his town block early and the rest are dead. I can see him adding 1 name into the town block of scum.

N1 - Forgot to add in a request
N2 - Shiro shot Maxwell. The reason I voted Shiro, I was half asleep and didn't see that Shiro died, thought as 1 death Shiro was scum.

[Vedith]

VOTE: Ika

[Luna Fox]

I also think that Alch is his partner

No

[Vedith]

So who do you think would be then?