Mini 1717 Alfred Hitchcock UPick [GAME OVER]

[Thor665]

we also reread your iso a few times

What insights were gained?

I am still waiting for an actual reply to this question.
Is there ever going to be one - or should I stop asking?

I missed it, but was that directed to both of us or were you interested in MS's thoughts specifically?

The only thing I personally gained from rereading was that I'm going back and forth on you. I currently have you in "prob town" category. I think your probing is good, and you have appropriate follow-up questions. You've littered a few conclusions here and there as well, which is satisfactory for the time being. There are little things that bother me, some things paranoia-based, and just a general lack of confidence in my ability to read you correctly. The other thing is also more peripheral than something you've done yourself, which is the fact that I feel like I had too many townreads in the beginning, which leads me to think that at least one or maybe two of the scum team members are quite skilled at looking town. So, combined you land in the "likely town but I don't feel good enough about it to put him to the side just yet" area.

That's very sexy and flattering and all.

But Vedith was the one you guys had said you re-read.
Wasn't even aware that you were re-reading me.

[Hecatia Lapislazuli]

GETTEM

BAHAHAHAHAHA

[Concrete Angels]

lol 2 scum on the wagon

Who are they?

Besides us, because we're not.

^ please respond, ns.

[Concrete Angels]

we also reread your iso a few times

What insights were gained?

I am still waiting for an actual reply to this question.
Is there ever going to be one - or should I stop asking?

I missed it, but was that directed to both of us or were you interested in MS's thoughts specifically?

The only thing I personally gained from rereading was that I'm going back and forth on you. I currently have you in "prob town" category. I think your probing is good, and you have appropriate follow-up questions. You've littered a few conclusions here and there as well, which is satisfactory for the time being. There are little things that bother me, some things paranoia-based, and just a general lack of confidence in my ability to read you correctly. The other thing is also more peripheral than something you've done yourself, which is the fact that I feel like I had too many townreads in the beginning, which leads me to think that at least one or maybe two of the scum team members are quite skilled at looking town. So, combined you land in the "likely town but I don't feel good enough about it to put him to the side just yet" area.

That's very sexy and flattering and all.

But Vedith was the one you guys had said you re-read.
Wasn't even aware that you were re-reading me.

We re-read everyone's ISO. For Vedith, I felt a bit better about him based on some of the things he said when he finally got involved, but I didn't think it was enough to clear him. MS came to the conclusion that he was lynchbait.

[Hecatia Lapislazuli]

please actually read my posts!

i am townreading fars pistachios and dav

that is 3/5 voting us

so who could the scum be?

[Concrete Angels]

I'm more and more convinced we are correct on Hecatia the more ns posts.

p-edit: Like I said, if you are town, then consider we are town and work from there. What is your conclusion at that point?

[Concrete Angels]

Also, why on earth are you townreading pistachi0n?

[Hecatia Lapislazuli]

excpt you aren't town so im not going to consider that?

pedit-

"Who can explain it, who can tell you whyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy?"

the scumread on us for squawking looks like overeager newbtown who has like this simplistic one-dimensional view of the game based of froggie mafia we just finished id say that fits town pistachios p well.

[Concrete Angels]

excpt you aren't town so im not going to consider that?

Because that's what you do when you try to figure things out. You can keep your scumread. But answer the question based on the hypothetical situation I've posed to you.

pedit-

"Who can explain it, who can tell you whyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy?"

the scumread on us for squawking looks like overeager newbtown who has like this simplistic one-dimensional view of the game based of froggie mafia we just finished id say that fits town pistachios p well.

It doesn't fit my experience with him, where he showed a genuine curiosity about people's ideas and tried to understand them. I don't see that here.

[Concrete Angels]

I'm giving you the benefit of the doubt here, ns, and attempting to work with you for a moment to see if we are wrong. You are not giving me much confidence in that idea.

[Hecatia Lapislazuli]

if that hypothetical is true then there is only 1 scum on me.

the only one i have the slightest doubts about is davy but nah.

also pistachios is a she!

[Concrete Angels]

if that hypothetical is true then there is only 1 scum on me.

which would be massive. are you actively scumreading massive or is it just based on the wagon?

the only one i have the slightest doubts about is davy but nah.

also pistachios is a she!

My bad.

[Thor665]

MS came to the conclusion that he was lynchbait.

I presume by this answer that he didn't deign to explain why he thought this?

[Hecatia Lapislazuli]

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 3#p7214663

this is what i mean by overeager newbtown

i do not like massive's push on us! its also why i am posting like this because i expect it will drive him nuts :>

that and townreading everyone the rest of the wagon, yep!

[Concrete Angels]

MS came to the conclusion that he was lynchbait.

I presume by this answer that he didn't deign to explain why he thought this?

I'll ask him.

[Concrete Angels]

viewtopic.php?p=7214663#p7214663

Thanks for this. That game does look like her other town game. Again, I see off-the-cuff curiosity, questions aimed at understanding. And again, I

don't

see that in this game.

[Concrete Angels]

MS came to the conclusion that he was lynchbait.

I presume by this answer that he didn't deign to explain why he thought this?

I'll ask him.

Just so you are aware, he is on the other side of the planet, and just went to bed. He said he has a math final tomorrow, so I expect to hear from him after that. I sent him a fb message about it.

[Hecatia Lapislazuli]

i can see what you're saying but that read based off the squawk still feels like awkward newbtown to me so ill think over it some

why did you not tear me a new one for being a nonentity early

[Concrete Angels]

i can see what you're saying but that read based off the squawk still feels like awkward newbtown to me so ill think over it some

why did you not tear me a new one for being a nonentity early

It was the beginning of the game. I'm more concerned when you fall off the face of the earth in late game or LYLO.

[Hecatia Lapislazuli]

cos thats what was bugging me

i fully expected that type of response especially when i made the squawk and I didnt see any of it and that confused me.

VOTE: massive

[Concrete Angels]

It's a lot different when you are in a hydra. Your partner was active. If you were playing solo, I'd have poked at you more about it, like I did with the others.

[Hecatia Lapislazuli]

Even still, given what you've said to me recently that is what I expected out of you if you were town and not seeing it made me think back to the last anti game where you were yelling at me in the scum pt and I was like

"she isnt yelling at me, she must be yelling at me in the scum pt"

But clearly I'm not as sure as I was.

[Concrete Angels]

Why would my yelling at you, or not yelling at you, be any indication of alignment? I yelled you openly about it in Dark Age AND that Anti game. In fact, it was my sole argument against you in an attempt to deflect making a real read on you in LYLO. Don't you remember that? My irritation at certain playstyles is pervasive across all games, regardless of alignment.

[Hecatia Lapislazuli]

My thought process was you wanted to proceed calm and collected-ish so you could save it for something more important.

I remember vry little about both of those games, the thing I remember from anti-game was your comments in the maf pt that I just mentioned and you were buddying BC the IC late, and dark ages I remember whiteknighting the fuck out of a gunsmith guilty and the dildo discussion.

I will go back and check later, but it's been FOREVER since we played together and I know you were going to be pissed at me if I was a non-entity which is why me being a non-entity and you not being pissed at me was so weird to me.

[massive]

Dig deeper massive, you might hit gold. Or is this as far as your efforts go?

This is far enough for my efforts, since you seem content at mudslinging, I think that fairly answers my question.