Greater Idea Mafia (Endgame)

[Luna Fox]

hmm i wonder who the nymphomaniac targeted, since they have to compulsively target someone N1, an extra death could be due to them dying + whoever targeted suicided

[Shiro]

hmm i wonder who the nymphomaniac targeted, since they have to compulsively target someone N1, an extra death could be due to them dying + whoever targeted suicided

How do you know it not the opposite that happened? The one they targeted died and he suiced for it ?

[Luna Fox]

hmm i wonder who the nymphomaniac targeted, since they have to compulsively target someone N1, an extra death could be due to them dying + whoever targeted suicided

How do you know it not the opposite that happened? The one they targeted died and he suiced for it ?

Because Mr Elvis was supposedly mod slip confirmed town?
I guess it's possible he targeted Davsto so his action would fail.

[Greys Holly]

Patience please.

I have a day of work ahead of me and kittymo is getting over being sick and moving back into her dorm room.

We are going to try and sync up later.

~M

[Natirasha]

Hi everyone im in this game and I'm not reading at all because it's Greater Idea.

As expected, old fools are L I A R S.

[Kthxbye]

Ho.....Ly....Shit. That's a lot death.

Okay, so first of all, eat it Ank and d3x. I knew you'd be trouble. Glad they are dead dead dead.

Secondly, we have 2 scum teams in our midst (obvious I know). Good news is they can cross shoot eachother. Bad news is, they are trying to find scum like the rest of us which makes it harder to get a town block going and with all the town deaths, holy shit do we need one.

D1 VCA:

Luna Fox

:

Firebringer

shaddowez

:

mr elvis

firebringer

: west9

Delenn

: hiplop, T S O, Level 1-1,

purple hero

,

BotLane

, Verdith,

kaboose

Verdith

: Inquisitor, Fro99er,

Delenn

,

davsto

, shiro, luna fox, rabble rabble rabble,

Aristophanes

Mr Elvis

: Natrish

Level 1-1

: rabble rabble rabble

Fro99er

:

Kthxbye

shaddowez

:

mr elvis

Verdith

: Inquisitor, Fro99er

rabble rabble rabble

:

purple hero

, hiplop, greys holly

Aristophanes

: T S O,

Botlane

, Level 1-1, verdith, Shiro,

Kaboose

, west9, rabble rabble rabble, luna fox,

davsto

,

aristophanes

Mr Elvis

: Natrish

There is a better than good chance there is at LEAST one scum on Aristophanes and I'd bet at least one more scum and/or werewolf on Aristo as well. Assuming there are two, three person anti town factions, that'd leave 1 or 2 scum/were OFF the Aristo wagon as well. This breaks down like so:

2-3 scum in - TSO, Level 1-1, verdith, Shiro, west9, RRR, luna fox (7)
1-2 scum in - Inquisitor, Fro99er, hiplop, greys holly, Natrish (5)

Current VCA:

Greys holly:

luna fox

,

shiro

,

rabble rabble rabble

These

were on Verdith wagon (the counter wagon to known scum Delenn) before the Delenn flip AND on the Aristo wagon (known town) at the end of D1.

Now if I were a betting man (I am), I'd say it was a safe bet that hiplop, TSO, Level 1-1 and Verdith aren't Scum, but they could be Weres. Cross reference that with the above and that leaves a good chance for a Were to be found in Shiro, west9, RRR and luna.

TSO is probably town

I agree with this and the reasoning. This being pointed out gives me town vibes on Luna as well. Could be buddying to TSO, but if that was that case, that'd just make TSO all the more town.

@TSO:

Thoughts on who you'd want in a town block if left to lead? Also, thoughts on Luna, specifically p2025?

Finally, this is an update of the list which may help later:

Player Name	Game 1	Game 2	Game 3
Fro99er Greninja	Mafia Gov / Survivor	??? / Mafia Compulsive Hider	Mafia Reflexive Doc / Mafia Compulsive Hider
Luna Fox	Supersaint / Serial Killer (Protection from alien and werewolf kills)	Town Bloodhound / Wild Card	VT / Werewolf Alpha
Greys Holly	One Shot Glad / Doc	??? / Wrong Place at the Wrong Time Townie	Weak JK / Wereparrot
Natrish shadowez	Nymphomaniac / Compulsive Bodyguard Survivor	??? / Ascetic Townie	Werewolf Gravedigger / Conspiracy Theorist
Shiro	Town God Father / VT	??? / Vanilla Cop	Bodyguard / VT
BotLane	Vanilla Cop / Conspiracy Theorist	Werewolf / Seer	Alien Vanillaiser / Mafia Cupid
Davsto	Serial Killer (Immune to Mafia Kills) / Mason Lover	Ascetic / Black Goo	Conspiracy Theorist / Alpha Goon
hiplop hippy love	black goo / 1 shot black goo	Town Lover / Town Compulsive Childkiller	VT / Mafia Goon
Inquisitor Farside66	Wereparrot / Wild Card	Mason / VT	Saulus / WW Blocker
firebringer		Joat / Watchlisted Townie
Delenn	Innocent Child / Alien Sympathizer	Mafia Saulus / Bulletproof Townie	Werewolf Godfather / Vanilla Townie
Level 1-1	Vigilante / Mafia Reflexive Doctor	??? / Conspiracy Theorist	Conspiracy Theorist / Mason Lover
T S O		??? / Lover
Vedith Lizard_Buttock	Vengeful Townie / Mafia lover	??? / Werewolf FBI Agent	Survivor Mason / Lyncher
West9	VT / Cop	??? / Watchlisted Townie	Mafia Fruit Vender / Innocent Child
kaboose	Day Vig / Enabler	1-shot Unlynchable / VT	Hider / Gladiator
rabble rabble rabble	Mason / One Shot Commuter	??? / Werewolf	Bodyguard / Cult One Shot Goomaker
purple hero	Black Goo / VT	Vigilant / Alien Sympathiser	Cop / Vanilla Cop
Aristophanes	SK (Alien/Replicant Immune) / 1-shot Townie (turns into Survivor on D2)	Vengeful / Tracker	Alien 1-shot Unlynchable / Mafia 1-shot Governor
Mr Elvis		Nymphomaniac / Cop-of-all-Trades	Mason / Mason
Kthxbye	Bloodhound / Roleblocker	??? / Mafia goon	Mafia Compulsive Hider / Mafia Goon

[Kthxbye]

5 deaths?!?!? LOL

This is your total thought after D1's events and 5 deaths?

VOTE: hiplop

[Luna Fox]

Yeah i'd expect at least 1 scum of each faction on a town wagon, since those are the easiest to push when you have the other faction helping you and you know they aren't your faction.

[Luna Fox]

hiplop was in neither wagon, i don't think voting them atm is a good idea, and they were strongly pushing Delenn.

[Luna Fox]

Aristophanes: T S O, Botlane, Level 1-1, verdith, Shiro, Kaboose, west9, rabble rabble rabble, luna fox, davsto, aristophanes

Breakdown of unknowns:

TSO: Probably town, for reasons already mentioned.
Lv 1-1: was pushed by rabble, so there's some sort of connection there.
Verdith: I can still say with confidence this guy is town for the saulus shot and he can only be mafia or town.
Shiro: Possibly scum here.
west9: Possibly scum here.
Rabble: Connection with Lv 1-1.

Currently voting Gray Hellen because i find it odd that mala's just sitting there doing nothing. Other people i'd be happy voting include Either of Lv1-1/Rabble to see the connection there, Shiro or West.

[hiplop]

5 deaths?!?!? LOL

This is your total thought after D1's events and 5 deaths?

VOTE: hiplop

y do u assume it was my total thoughts?

i didnt say "the sum of all of everything im thinking is in this post"

???

[Kthxbye]

Cuz you said nothing else. Curious how you come in and say something soon as i vote you though....

[Kthxbye]

hiplop was in neither wagon, i don't think voting them atm is a good idea, and they were strongly pushing Delenn.

Could be a Were. Could also be a loner anti town. The real reason for the vote though is lack of readable ( as in getting a read on them) material especially today.

[hiplop]

Cuz you said nothing else. Curious how you come in and say something soon as i vote you though....

almost like i made my regular rounds checking my games

[Kthxbye]

do

you

have

anything

worthwhile

to

say

?

Like reads, thoughts on deaths, suspects, etc or are you just going to continue to barely defend anything said/posted about you and nothing more?

[hiplop]

theres nothing about me except your paranoid ass

like give me some time holy shit its not like ive been lurking this game like you

[hiplop]

ive been in this game 5 days as myself and have almost the same amount of posts as you

you seriously don't have any reason to be calling me out like this. my thoughts on slots are pretty obvious and the fact that you dont realize that shows me you arent reading the game well.

[T S O]

Shiro's still scum.

[hiplop]

@kthxbye

you realize I have been in this game all along? I didn't replace in...right?

if you just made a dumb mistake please apologize because you're acting looney

[T S O]

They shot every single obvtown player. I will admit, I did not think Ank was as town as I said I did, but I needed support from them.

[T S O]

We really need a scum lynch today. I agree the Greys thing is probably scum, but I think Shiro is a significantly better vote for some really awful posts he's made.

[hiplop]

grays or rabble for me. Shri would be third

[T S O]

Kthx - could you kindly explain how you think that your giant list will help at all? In any possible scenario?

[Kthxbye]

TSO - My giant list is keeping track of everything. I'm not claiming it will lead to perfect lynches from D2 on, BUT, if I happen to be murderated, whatever town is left have something to build upon later that will help. You can't tell me you don't see the value in VCA can you? As for the discards/claims lists, it's there to help when someone claims some bullshit PR or VT while discarding some PR. I don't believe for a second someone chooses vanilla over a PR. In fact....*brb

[Kthxbye]

Both West9 and Luna claim to have chosen VT over a PR. Luna claims VT over Were Alpha, which if someone really dislikes playing scum, I can understand, but West9 claiming to have discarded Cop and chose VT on D1? I'd be down to lynch that for that alone. I'll have to look back and when W9 claimed this.

If that isn't going to happen, I'm good with lynching Grey, Shiro or RRR. I'm still unsure on luna. VCA says one thing, but her posting pings town to me. Lynching of the previously mentioned 3 will give good info since they are or are on the only current wagon.

UNVOTE:

@hiplop: I KNOW you didn't replace in, which is why I'm so curious as to why you posted nothing of content so far today. Post count doesn't equal content. Could you explain your reasoning behind your list of lynchable players?