NY 190: Molla's Large Normal

[Luna Fox]

Luna,

Something like "Skybird is not Evil Faction A" is not a possibility.

Double negaitve, does that imply skybird is evil faction A?

[Luna Fox]

Also i wonder what's the opinion on both FN's messages being different.

[Aj The Epic]

Is he perhaps not a friendly neighbor? I explicitly got his role.

Mailman pops into mind as a role possibility, but mailman generally is clarified not to be written by the mod.

[Luna Fox]

Thing is that i don't remember friendly neighbors specifically mentioning their role to their target, just that they are town.

[Luna Fox]

Like it usually comes in the message of "Hi, i'm -playername- and i'm town" or something like that.

[Luna Fox]

The best solution i can think for this is to have both friendly neighbors target someone together, and have the doctor protect that person, unfortunately im not sure whether this would help.

[Titus]

Luna,

Something like "Skybird is not Evil Faction A" is not a possibility.

Double negaitve, does that imply skybird is evil faction A?

No.

I will rephrase. FNs saying "Skybird is not evil faction A" are impossible.

[Luna Fox]

I'm not sure i understand, but the mafiawiki says that FN is necessarily town (if the claim is true that is)

[Titus]

The best solution i can think for this is to have both friendly neighbors target someone together, and have the doctor protect that person, unfortunately im not sure whether this would help.

If AJ's town that's setting him up for failure.

[Titus]

I'm not sure i understand, but the mafiawiki says that FN is necessarily town (if the claim is true that is)

One isfake if the PMs are different.

Town-aligned Friendly Neighbor is considered Normal on mafiascum.net. Messages sent on behalf of a Friendly Neighbor must be identical.

From the wiki.

[Salamence20]

Luna,

Something like "Skybird is not Evil Faction A" is not a possibility.

Double negaitve, does that imply skybird is evil faction A?

No.

I will rephrase. FNs saying "Skybird is not evil faction A" are impossible.

Omg thats not how a FN works.

FN states that he is town.

Molla isnt changing that.

[Titus]

Is he perhaps not a friendly neighbor? I explicitly got his role.

Mailman pops into mind as a role possibility, but mailman generally is clarified not to be written by the mod.

This sounds like Drug Dealer or Unscrupulous Messenger. Both roles in my Don't Trust Titus Setup.

[Salamence20]

CoughcoughTHEMEcoughcough

[Titus]

Normals can have up to 2 variant roles.

[FA_Q2]

The best solution i can think for this is to have both friendly neighbors target someone together, and have the doctor protect that person, unfortunately im not sure whether this would help.

If AJ's town that's setting him up for failure.

So far we have 2 different claims for what the PM states.

One state player name and town, other states player name, role and town :/

[FA_Q2]

I'm not sure i understand, but the mafiawiki says that FN is necessarily town (if the claim is true that is)

One isfake if the PMs are different.

Town-aligned Friendly Neighbor is considered Normal on mafiascum.net. Messages sent on behalf of a Friendly Neighbor must be identical.

From the wiki.

Sigh. The above post was supposed to go with this quote.

I meant to ask in the above - Why does that set him up for failure?

[Titus]

Lying to players is out so DD is out.
New/variant roles may be included in limited number (no more than 1 in a Mini, 2 in a Large), and should be based on the usual role mechanics: Killing, Protecting, Investigating, Blocking, Voting, Enabling and Communication.

@AJ, Did the role knowledge come in the same PM as the alignment confirmation?

[FA_Q2]

Is he perhaps not a friendly neighbor? I explicitly got his role.

Mailman pops into mind as a role possibility, but mailman generally is clarified not to be written by the mod.

This sounds like Drug Dealer or Unscrupulous Messenger. Both roles in my Don't Trust Titus Setup.

Don't really care what is sounds like - they both explicitly claimed FN.
If one is a lie then it would not have come from town...

[Titus]

I'm not sure i understand, but the mafiawiki says that FN is necessarily town (if the claim is true that is)

One isfake if the PMs are different.

Town-aligned Friendly Neighbor is considered Normal on mafiascum.net. Messages sent on behalf of a Friendly Neighbor must be identical.

From the wiki.

Sigh. The above post was supposed to go with this quote.

I meant to ask in the above - Why does that set him up for failure?

If AJ is honest, scum have a strongman or RB so he will fail in protecting the target and look scummy.

[Aj The Epic]

Lying to players is out so DD is out.
New/variant roles may be included in limited number (no more than 1 in a Mini, 2 in a Large), and should be based on the usual role mechanics: Killing, Protecting, Investigating, Blocking, Voting, Enabling and Communication.

@AJ, Did the role knowledge come in the same PM as the alignment confirmation?

Same pm. The message was just as I stated.

[Titus]

There's almost no way to paraphrase the message.

Playername, rolename , is town.

Literally the only paraphrase I can do of it.

You didn't state the role PM here?

[Performer]

1392 – Sky, what about CDB’s play, makes you scumread him?


@Aj in d1, you’ve been saying I posted unsubstantial things, you mentioned that I’ve “constantly responded to posts directed (at me) only” when I’ve addressed others in d1, you were pushing hard to mislynch me in d1, you’re still believing that I’m scum in d2, and your farfetched role reveal along with a 2nd FN role reveal.

Seeing as others have more experience than I do in large games - new information coming out about the setup - I 'm putting my vote on hold. Also, there's plenty of time to make a decision.

[Performer]

Much like the anticipation of the next thrilling twist in new movie, The Gift, I'm still awaiting your reply to my questions , Vee

[Aj The Epic]

There's almost no way to paraphrase the message.

Playername, rolename , is town.

Literally the only paraphrase I can do of it.

You didn't state the role PM here?

It's a friendly neighbor.

[Titus]

So does it state

Player name is town or Player name is town FN?