In post 186, Firebringer wrote: In post 164, The Silver Bard wrote:This Shiro claim really baffles me. I don't understand why you would claim at this point. The timing of the claim brings very little information to the table, and Shiro was not really pressured. So I find it somewhat suspicious.
On the other hand the claim itself, the flavor of it makes sense, Arthas would need to be turned to be a part of the Undead Scourge, and dieing before this would result in him not having become part of the Undead Scourge. Also the fact that Shiro earlier talked about Arthas makes this claim believable to me.
I find vezopirakas reasoning for voting Shiro after the claim strange though. He says his main reason for voting him is ABR's reasons, which to me seems weak (Trying to hard to appear not dangerous??). He also says he'd vote someone who he beleives isn't scum but thrid party. That seems scummy to me. If Shinro's claim is true then he will clearly be part of the town, and would help to further towns chances to win. Lynching Shiro if you believe him to not be scum is a bad move for town.
So:
VOTE: vezokpiraka
This is L-2 I think.
Trying to put doubt in Shiro claim.
Then votes most obv town in this game so far.
Wow, you look so abd right now.
No, I am not "trying to put doubt in Shiro claim". I am trying to explain why I think he is what he claims.
Claiming out of the blue is something I find suspcious, but what he claims, the flavor of it and his previous mention of Arthas makes me believe the claim.
So to make it clear I am not doubting Shiro's claim.
vezopiraka is trying to paint him as third party and wants to lynch him for it.
So vezo is:
A: Trying to lynch a player who he thinks is not scum.
B: Manipulating the town by calling Shiro third party. While Shiro claims to be town, and his claim and flavor (IMO) is much more likely to be town than third party.
To me this is scummy, and that is why I am voting vezo.
