Mini 1715 - Z - Game over!

[Nachomamma8]

if we lynch him and his town we just basically lost one town for nothing.

This isn't true!

[Thor665]

Sorry that was mean but seriously we were just talking about all the benefits and cons in a lynch and no lynch and everyone admitted that a no lynch was the best option with way better results and no down sides other than the long weight if karmic is scum but the people who want to lynch didn't want to drag this out if he is.

This didn't happen!

Insomuch as not everyone agreed - you are correct.
But you did agree it would lead to a win.

[Garmr]

everyone important agreed that it was a win

[Gimlear]

Why is everyone acting like if we lynch Karmic, we are forced to follow Nacho's plan and lynch every day for the rest of the game? I'm actually ok with lynching Karmic tonight then going into no lynch until we find scum if Karmic flips town.

[Garmr]

i swear you aren't reading the reason we don't want to do a lynch is becuase it's not a optimal play the optimal play is what me and thor suggested if you actually think about it. If any of the power roles are lying it forces them in a bad stance but if karmic is scum then we lose nothing from constantly jail keeping him until scum make a kill. We have nothing to lose and everything to to gain.

It basic logic and it does my head people can't see this simple stuff I noticed that on this site recently people lack the thought process to think things through for optimal play it annoys me.

[Thor665]

Why is everyone acting like if we lynch Karmic, we are forced to follow Nacho's plan and lynch every day for the rest of the game? I'm actually ok with lynching Karmic tonight then going into no lynch until we find scum if Karmic flips town.

[Garmr]

hold me close thor I am dying on the inside

[KarmicGuide]

Sooo, intent to hammer?

don't hammer just no lynch -_-

I've got nothing to add after L1, just for the record. I'm on board with Nacho's plan.

Feel free to hammer if you're in a hammerin' mood.

[Thor665]

Vote yourself or vote no lynch.

[Garmr]

if your town vote no lynch if your scum vote lynch.

[zakk]

EXPERIMENT NOTES 3.4

SUBJECTS ASSERTING AGGRESSIVE ACTIVITY:

KarmicGuide [4] - Gimlear, eventi, pistachi0n, Nachomamma8
No Lynch [3] - Radja, Thor665, Garmr
Bellaphant [0]
davesaz [0]
eventi [0]
Garmr [0]
Gimlear [0]
gummmybear [0]
Nachomamma8 [0]
pistachi0n [0]
Radja [0]
Thor665 [0]

SUBJECTS DISPLAYING PASSIVE TENDENCY:

Bellaphant, davesaz, gummmybear, KarmicGuide

[Radja]

VOTE: Karmic

L-1

This is getting nowhere. Let's end this.

Someone hammer...

[Gimlear]

Unless my count is off, there's 12 people alive which means it takes 7 to lynch not 6.

[Gimlear]

Nevermind. I did miscount. You are correct.

[pistachi0n]

Again, a no lynch means no information, a lynch means we're narrowing down the pool even if Karmic is town.

[Garmr]

Again, a no lynch means no information, a lynch means we're narrowing down the pool even if Karmic is town.

-boinks your head with a squeeky rubber hammer-
We just discussed sigh i swear your not even paying attention to this game.

A no flip is safer because if scum is someone else and they kill tonight karmic gets confirmed town karmic is town. If he is scum it doesn't matter since he can do nothing as everyone else in the game is confirmed.


I swear the newer players don't use there brains in situations like this.

[pistachi0n]

Again, a no lynch means no information, a lynch means we're narrowing down the pool even if Karmic is town.

-boinks your head with a squeeky rubber hammer-
We just discussed sigh i swear your not even paying attention to this game.

A no flip is safer because if scum is someone else and they kill tonight karmic gets confirmed town karmic is town. If he is scum it doesn't matter since he can do nothing as everyone else in the game is confirmed.


I swear the newer players don't use there brains in situations like this.

What prevents the scum from no killing just to screw with us? I recently finished a game where we were in a similar situation and the one remaining scum no killed repeatedly.

[Garmr]

Again, a no lynch means no information, a lynch means we're narrowing down the pool even if Karmic is town.

-boinks your head with a squeeky rubber hammer-
We just discussed sigh i swear your not even paying attention to this game.

A no flip is safer because if scum is someone else and they kill tonight karmic gets confirmed town karmic is town. If he is scum it doesn't matter since he can do nothing as everyone else in the game is confirmed.


I swear the newer players don't use there brains in situations like this.

What prevents the scum from no killing just to screw with us? I recently finished a game where we were in a similar situation and the one remaining scum no killed repeatedly.

if they do that it's perfect lol since we will confirm a bunch of players with a cop and a role cop and if either of you are scum and lie about who is scum then you will be obvious and get lynched. Hell at the end of it we can even confirm karmic as town or scum with the rolecop/cop combo.

In this situation scum can't win with out killing because every vt will get confirmed and if one of the power roles is scum they can't act of line.

If someone does die we get karmic confirmed as town.

[gummmybear]

Hmm. I think I'm still on board with lynching. VOTE: Karmic Karmic is now at L-1. Please declare intent before hammering!

[gummmybear]

OH OOPS crap. I just realised I hammered.

[Radja]

[Thor665]

Night Plan with Karmic Lynch
Pistach targets Eventi.
Radja investigates Gummy/Garmr.
Dave jails Gimlear
Nacho docs Dave.

[Thor665]

That hammer though...

[Thor665]

NEW Night Plan with Karmic Lynch

Pistach targets Eventi.
Radja investigates Gimlear/Garmr.
Dave jails Gummy
Nacho docs Dave.

There.
This is the new plan.
Ignore the old plan - that hammer was ugly and sloppy - I'd like to confirm him or have him on lockdown if Karmic isn't scum.

[Garmr]

This is what happens when idiots put someone at l-1