My last substantial post was
501, starting from there:
-ASP enters, mostly straightforward reads but the Hieirama push stands out as Hieirama has been skirting attention up to this point. Hieirama posts in reply but the defense seems weak, like she points out a contradiction in Rob's posting history but doesn't really use it to make a read on his alignment and softly defends herself. ASP comes out looking more town here.
-Big catch up from Aristo. Makes good points about Rob, acknowledges less certainty in his SW read and I like most of
512 - some nuanced points here about the odd confirm post
138 from the hydra - it was an unusual post, although Ari's certainly reading a lot into it. I was scumleaning him early because I thought he was making far too big of a deal about small/trivial things in the early game, but it's becoming a consistent pattern, which indicates it may just be playstyle. Combine that with believable miller crumb and I don't really have any more reason to suspect this slot for now.
-Ah, Rob says pretty much the same thing in
531. More townpoints for Rob.
-
538 is very weak from Hieirama - did you really get a townread off of P_B from that one tiny post?
-PB arrives(?) but Titus makes a push on Flubbernugget instead. I don't understand this - Titus why didn't you talk to PB while you had the chance?
-pistachi0n makes an amazing point in
546 - let's all remember this, everyone. It'll be important later.
-
I REALLY DO NOT LIKE THE PUSH FOR FLAVOR
- if scum have an ability to 'convert' but it only works for a certain/a few people, this is an easy way to find them person. Flavor doesn't tell you anything about alignment and just felt like BS from wgeurts to me.
-I'm liking the cases/push on PB, he definitely needs to be posting more.
Oh hey, he has questions for me:
In post 589, Prolapsed Brain wrote:I'm curious why you thought one player could read another player's mind to answer why a vote was placed. Also, yes, scum could benefit, slightly I suppose, from looking town so early, but this is just Rob. That's how he plays.
Titus seemed convinced that Rob was town, I was trying to show her that I was not the only one who doubted this conviction. pistachi0n's vote was obviously not an RVS vote, so it's clear she had suspicion on him. I wanted Titus to acknowledge this fact, not literally explain to me what pistachion's reasons were.
-More TvT between Titus and SW. Yawn. Btw Titus I'm leaning town on SW now, I can explain it in detail if you want me to but for now I'll leave it at that.
-
611 from Rob, thank you thank you thank you.
-pistachi0n also calls out the flavor thing. More townpoints for pistachi0n.
-wgeurts senses this suspicion from pistachi0n, and asks the mod a gigantic bolded question that he should have considered well before asking for flavor. This seems like a retroactive attempt to justify his bizarre flavor request.
Then we get to my prodge. Catchup on the rest coming shortly.
"I think I no longer believe in monsters as faces in the floor or feral infants or vampires or whatever. I think at seventeen now I believe the only real monsters might be the type of liar where there's simply no way to tell. The ones who give nothing away"
