In post 449, Soapbar wrote:There's probably a few I'm forgetting but yeah. Scum has close to zero reason to keep her alive. The risks are too high for them.
In post 322, MarioManiac4 wrote:I just realised Shadoxx is actually confirmed scum
VOTE: Shadoxx
1. He knows how to vote.
2. He voted improperly.
3. Scum!Shadoxx does this to appear newb.
4. Town!Shadoxx does this because ?
In post 323, Maxous wrote:In post 301, Annadog40 wrote:Hi Maxous!
well, thanks for the warm welcome
-
i've done an initial read-through and am thinking of voting either Mario or Supercool.
Mario for his poor tunnel and generally not liking how he is formulating his reads, particulary his "meta" read on Radiant Cowbells
Supercool was really awkward and fake early on I thought, but I would like to re-check some of his stuff.
Not enthused by either current wagon, particularly the Soapbar one.
~ more later
-
p-edit: and well *that* doesn't exactly endear me to Mario either
In post 432, makara wrote:Maybe because I am more experienced now???
I don't think you should be using someone's first newbie game as a basis for their meta.
In post 437, Slandaar wrote:In post 427, Firesong wrote:In post 404, Slandaar wrote:Fire do you have an opinion about Mario?
I think he's town. I have you and RC as town, Soapbar and Supercool as scum, everybody else null.
I find this incredibly strange.
In post 322, MarioManiac4 wrote:I just realised Shadoxx is actually confirmed scum
VOTE: Shadoxx
1. He knows how to vote.
2. He voted improperly.
3. Scum!Shadoxx does this to appear newb.
4. Town!Shadoxx does this because ?
In post 324, MarioManiac4 wrote:dislike it more.
see my last post.
there is no reason for shadoxx to ever be town.
none.
In post 377, Firesong wrote:Only scum know Shadoxx's alignment. No one knows his role. Lynching an empty slot is like random lynching, you have no clue who you're taking out. It's lazy and antitown.
If I can get lynched for merely suggesting it, it's because it's something Scum do all the time. So yes, Supercool is scum
etc
Can you explain this to me?
In post 448, MarioManiac4 wrote:In post 447, makara wrote:In post 446, Soapbar wrote:I still think Nos is the best lynch.
He's not the most scummy player, Annadog takes that spot but she either dies tonight as town or lives as scum (and promptly gets lynched the next day)
This doesn't make sense. Wouldn't scum let townAnnadog live so that she would be easy lynch fodder for day 2?
Annadog is pretty obviously not a VT. Just so you know. :/
In post 455, Firesong wrote:In post 432, makara wrote:Maybe because I am more experienced now???
I don't think you should be using someone's first newbie game as a basis for their meta.
I'm using your language, your approach to the game. You were more articulate and confident there than here.
makara wrote:Town Reads
Glork - Strong scumhunting, good insight on the game. There's nothing that I find scummy about his play, so that earns him a strong townread.
Town Leans
Soapbar - I'm not sure what the reason people are scumreading him is. The dayvig gambit seemed town-motivated, but there is a possibility of a Soapbar/supercool scumteam. If one flips scum, the other should probably be looked at much closer. Otherwise, I like much of what he's posting and it makes sense to me. Overall seems town-motivated.
why is it town-motivated?
supercool898 - Same as Soapbar.Although he stuck with claiming town throughout the dayvig gambit his reaction seemed disingenuous, which I talked about in my catch up post, which he didn't respond to either.
Why is he in town leans then?
Slandaar - Again, good logic and insight in the game. Strong scumread, most of what he posts is logical and coherent.
Having a strong scumread is townish?
Null Reads
RadiantCowbells - Started out strong but since then hasn't done much. @RC do you still have no scumreads?
MarioManiac4 - Him not linking the game he was talking about for his meta argument irked me and overall I dislike meta arguments. Otherwise there's not too much else that pops out at me.
If everything you do notice about him bothers you, why is he in null?
Maxous - Shadoxx's RVS vote was scummy but I think that since Maxous has replaced in he has been pretty good with questioning. I'm listing him as null since there's nothing jumping out that's super towny or super scummy.
Scum Leans
Smudger - Barely more posts than Annadog. He barely has any content other than parking a vote on Annadog and then FoSing me for agreeing that Annadog is scummy.
Rory - His scumhunting is weak, and has been tunneling Mario for most of day.
Scum Reads
Firesong - Has been riding on her Soapbar "scumread" all day and I expect her to do the same thing with her "scumread" on me tomorrow.
but Slaandar is being townread for also keeping a strong scumread and sticking with it?
Additionally, has been doing some pretty impressive mental gymnastics to justify a lot of her positions.
Annadog40 - This one doesn't need any explaining. Should be vigged tonight.
Nosferatu - Glork's case on him made sense and he's been kinda "active-lurking" all day. I dislike the way he responded to Glork's case on him.
Do you wanna actually state something original on this one?
In post 466, Nosferatu wrote:makara wrote:Town Reads
Glork - Strong scumhunting, good insight on the game. There's nothing that I find scummy about his play, so that earns him a strong townread.
Town Leans
Soapbar - I'm not sure what the reason people are scumreading him is. The dayvig gambit seemed town-motivated, but there is a possibility of a Soapbar/supercool scumteam. If one flips scum, the other should probably be looked at much closer. Otherwise, I like much of what he's posting and it makes sense to me. Overall seems town-motivated.
why is it town-motivated?
I don't know, maybe because it helps town?
supercool898 - Same as Soapbar.Although he stuck with claiming town throughout the dayvig gambit his reaction seemed disingenuous, which I talked about in my catch up post, which he didn't respond to either.
Why is he in town leans then?
Same as Soapbar. Apply what I said about soapbar to supercool.
Slandaar - Again, good logic and insight in the game. Strong scumread, most of what he posts is logical and coherent.
Having a strong scumread is townish?
It was supposed to say scumhunting
Null Reads
RadiantCowbells - Started out strong but since then hasn't done much. @RC do you still have no scumreads?
MarioManiac4 - Him not linking the game he was talking about for his meta argument irked me and overall I dislike meta arguments. Otherwise there's not too much else that pops out at me.
If everything you do notice about him bothers you, why is he in null?
because there is not much that's alignment indicative from him Imo.
Maxous - Shadoxx's RVS vote was scummy but I think that since Maxous has replaced in he has been pretty good with questioning. I'm listing him as null since there's nothing jumping out that's super towny or super scummy.
Scum Leans
Smudger - Barely more posts than Annadog. He barely has any content other than parking a vote on Annadog and then FoSing me for agreeing that Annadog is scummy.
Rory - His scumhunting is weak, and has been tunneling Mario for most of day.
Scum Reads
Firesong - Has been riding on her Soapbar "scumread" all day and I expect her to do the same thing with her "scumread" on me tomorrow.
but Slaandar is being townread for also keeping a strong scumread and sticking with it?
Read answer above
Additionally, has been doing some pretty impressive mental gymnastics to justify a lot of her positions.
Annadog40 - This one doesn't need any explaining. Should be vigged tonight.
Nosferatu - Glork's case on him made sense and he's been kinda "active-lurking" all day. I dislike the way he responded to Glork's case on him.
Do you wanna actually state something original on this one?
I plead the fifth
My questions on this are in green.
