Mini 1717 Alfred Hitchcock UPick [GAME OVER]

[Concrete Angels]

considering it sprang up when pistachio was getting momentum....

[Thor665]

If I were to make an assumption on who scum was if they chose a Wingback kill for suspect reasons, I'd lean Cataphant or Concrete Angels.

You're voting Pistach though - so...?

please don't quicklynch. I'd like to hear from everyone. thoughts on yesterday's lynch would be grand too. any ideas on the LC wagon specifically is what I'd like to hear.

I think at least one scum was probably on the LC wagon, what of it?

[Davsto]

If I were to make an assumption on who scum was if they chose a Wingback kill for suspect reasons, I'd lean Cataphant or Concrete Angels.

You're voting Pistach though - so...?

Because I decided that reasoning was silly and pistach is worse.

[Concrete Angels]

I think at least one scum was probably on the LC wagon, what of it?

who do you think it is most likely to be?

[Concrete Angels]

what's actually troubling, to be perfectly honest, is that wingback was chosen over dav. wingback flipped flavor cop and someone mentioned that they thought he was the night kill because of his claim, but i dont recall him ever claiming flavor cop or anything close to that, so... dav would have and should have been the logical scum kill choice.

[Davsto]

I was considering whether or not to claim but I suspect the LC votes might trail off and I don't have time to check in tonight.

I will partially claim.

I am not a VT.

With my role, Hecatia's, and Davsto's, it is very unlikely LC has some sort of "confirmable" role. Their behavior points heavily to scum. I don't buy their soft-claim. They better get lynched today.

I'm not an expert on Antihero games but I expect mafia games in general to be balanced. I don't buy that the two roles outed, my role, and another confirmable role all exist in the game.

You are making me very suspicious with this last minute defense on Lying Cat.

Explain how you got to me as town please. Do you normally accuse your townreads of "making noises?"

He did some claimy stuff here, not sure how much he hinted at though. Maybe the fact he claimed he was confirmable worried scum? But idk.

[Davsto]

Wondering why scum made a nightkill is unlikely to result in good results so yeh...

[Concrete Angels]

Maybe the fact he claimed he was confirmable worried scum?

uh... over a full-claimed jailkeeper?


no.

[Concrete Angels]

Wondering why scum made a nightkill is unlikely to result in good results so yeh...

are you actually trying to discourage analysis?

i'll analyze and share whatever the heck i want, tyvm.

[Davsto]

As someone who analysed it and came out with no idea as to why I wasn't killed, I disagree.

[Concrete Angels]

As someone who analysed it and came out with no idea as to why I wasn't killed, I disagree.

In your expert opinion, eh?

[Davsto]

Oh! Look! Discrediting! My favourite!

[Concrete Angels]

With all due respect, I'm going to trust my own analysis and that of other seasoned players over a newbie. No offense or discredit meant, but honestly now...

[Davsto]

I understand.

May I suggest that my newbieness and lack of accurate reads is potentially why I wasn't killed?

[Ankamius]

As someone who analysed it and came out with no idea as to why I wasn't killed, I disagree.

This is a hint from my own experience: If the kill doesn't make sense with your view of the game state, then your view of the game state is wrong.

[Concrete Angels]

Nothing has clicked yet. It's just something I'm thinking about as an unsolved piece of the puzzle.

[Thor665]

I think at least one scum was probably on the LC wagon, what of it?

who do you think it is most likely to be?

If I knew that I'd be voting and screaming about it.
I am content on a chaff lynch today.

[Concrete Angels]

I think at least one scum was probably on the LC wagon, what of it?

who do you think it is most likely to be?

If I knew that I'd be voting and screaming about it.
I am content on a chaff lynch today.

Thor.

That is mafia. Like... literally... play the game.

Don't you have any ideas or suspicions or tin-foil hat theories? Anything?

[Thor665]

Nope, I have not offered a vote nor suggested yesterday a top scumread other than LC.
I am like a hidden wall of no opinion.

[Concrete Angels]

Nope, I have not offered a vote nor suggested yesterday a top scumread other than LC.
I am like a hidden wall of no opinion.

Sarcasm?



Please. I am looking for help to sort this out.

[massive]

Oh! Look! Discrediting! My favourite!

You came out of your "NKA" with a null. You've said that pistachi0n is more suspicious than either of the two you quoted in that. So why the defensive posturing here? If you have CA as a null, why immediately jump to accuse them of discrediting you?

[Davsto]

As someone who analysed it and came out with no idea as to why I wasn't killed, I disagree.

In your expert opinion, eh?

With all due respect, I'm going to trust my own analysis and that of other seasoned players over a newbie. No offense or discredit meant, but honestly now...

To be honest massive, this is discrediting to an extent. Reads more townie though. It's "shit you're right I need to reduce your credibility" and more "look, I'm more experienced than you, don't assume that what you found was the sole truth."

[Thor665]

Nope, I have not offered a vote nor suggested yesterday a top scumread other than LC.
I am like a hidden wall of no opinion.

Sarcasm?



Please. I am looking for help to sort this out.

When did you decide I was town?

[Concrete Angels]

Nope, I have not offered a vote nor suggested yesterday a top scumread other than LC.
I am like a hidden wall of no opinion.

Sarcasm?



Please. I am looking for help to sort this out.

When did you decide I was town?

I haven't yet, not really. I feel like you might be.

[Concrete Angels]

town to null-town:
{davsto, wingback, ankamius, vedith, farside, hecatia}

willing to leave for sorting tomorrow/after flips/night action results:
{massive, thor, LC}

remaining:
{pistachi0n, cataphant, nacho}

Hi Thor.

^ hereabouts though.