Micro 547: Searching For Dragons (Game Over)

[Vedith]

All of them.

I'm just 1 hour?

[Chaotic Neutrality]

You can quickly go through all of someone's topics, pick put all their games, ISO the first several posts and compare it to their alignment, and draw a conclusion about how someone plays RVS as scum vs town.

[Vedith]

Do mine next! If you guess my align I'll vote him.

[Firebringer]

Im getting a gut scumread from Persivul. I checked it against his meta and it checks out.

UNVOTE: Guilty
VOTE: Persivul

Serious vote.

Discuss.

Well he opened jokingly, didn't say much and then came in with a "firebringer just coasts by" sad to say it but I actually think he is town mate.

[Persivul]

All of them.

I find it difficult to believe that you've come up with meaningful meta tells at this point in a game. I suspect you rather put this up to see how I'd react.

[Persivul]

You can quickly go through all of someone's topics, pick put all their games, ISO the first several posts and compare it to their alignment, and draw a conclusion about how someone plays RVS as scum vs town.

In this game I started out playful.

In this game:
http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... ct[]=25810

I also started out playful, and I was town.

So, you need to post some specifics if you really think there's merit to the charge.

[Chaotic Neutrality]

gut scumread

based on how you were asking semi-pointless questions. It's really not strong but if anyone has literally any other reads then by all means, speak up.

[FA_Q2]

Im getting a gut scumread from Persivul. I checked it against his meta and it checks out.

UNVOTE: Guilty
VOTE: Persivul

Serious vote.

Discuss.

Discuss what?

You have pot pointed out exactly what it is that you find scummy with his RVS posting. What do you mean with semi-pointless questions? Almost everything in RVS is semi-pointless if you ask me. What does your meta dive say town persivul acts like?

[FA_Q2]

Firebringer is fun. I like him.

Yep...and he uses that to coast, joking around but adding little real content.

And does this with his posting thus far give you any type of read on fire?

[FA_Q2]

Hey all!

VOTE: FA_Q2

Because I have never played with you before.

Well then, now you have

Do you have anything else to say past a single RVS vote because you have not played with me before?



On an unrelated to the game note - you are in the same location as I am. Small world.

[Vedith]

I've not played with FA either.

[Persivul]

You can quickly go through all of someone's topics, pick put all their games, ISO the first several posts and compare it to their alignment, and draw a conclusion about how someone plays RVS as scum vs town.

I just checked your first post on page 3 in every game you've played, and each one of them was moronic.

So, this moronic post is not alignment indicative.

[Vedith]

Was he a mix of town and scum in those games?

[Persivul]

Firebringer is fun. I like him.

Yep...and he uses that to coast, joking around but adding little real content.

And does this with his posting thus far give you any type of read on fire?

His posting since then has been more townie, but that could have been in response to my comment. So, too soon to say.

[Persivul]

Was he a mix of town and scum in those games?

You know I was joking, right?

[goodmorning]

'She made someone haul a rack up eight flights of stairs and down six more, just to dry tablecloths?'
'A very determined woman, your great-grandmother.'

Votecount 1.2

Firebringer [L-3] - The Betting Pool, Vedith

FA_Q2 [L-4] - GuiltyLion
Vedith - [L-4] - Firebringer
The Betting Pool [L-4] - A Simple Plan
A Simple Plan - [L-4] - Persivul
Persivul - [L-4] - Chaotic Neutrality

Not Voting [2] - GrayFoxxxx, FA_Q2

With 9 alive, it takes

5

to lynch. The day will end in (expired on 2015-11-20 08:00:00).

[Vedith]

You know I was joking, right?

Do you think I would have asked if I thought "You know what, he's joking!"?

[Persivul]

Fair enough. I was joking. I didn't really check the first post he made on page 3 in every game to look for a trend.

[Vedith]

That's a shame.
I don't but push anyway

[A Simple Plan]

@Vedith: What's the point of setup spec so early in the game? What do you hope to accomplish from discussing what the mod may or may not have thrown at us other than WIFOM?

Why are you against giving this information? Is it because you didn't want people to know you have day chat?

And for the record, you wouldn't be able to tell the difference between my scum or town game.

So you're dodging my question?

It's not that I'm against giving the information, but how does previous game spec really relate, even if they're the same theme? If I were to run a Harry Potter theme, I could see Harry as 2-shot Deathproof, I could see Harry as a Vig, I could see him as a Follower (seeker)... My point is, what's to say anything is to be similar or the same?

[GuiltyLion]

sorry, been busy with work (and Fallout ) and neglected this game for too long!

Im getting a gut scumread from Persivul. I checked it against his meta and it checks out.

Can you explain what specifically in his meta is indicative of scum alignment?

I find it difficult to believe that you've come up with meaningful meta tells at this point in a game. I suspect you rather put this up to see how I'd react.

This feels a little guarded to me, and

So, you need to post some specifics if you really think there's merit to the charge.

reads like you'd rather dismiss his push than engage with it.

On an unrelated to the game note - you are in the same location as I am. Small world.

awesome, I love it here

Gut townleans on Fire/FA_Q2 at the moment, but I don't have much beyond that. This ASP/Vedith thread could be informative but I want to watch it resolve itself before I jump in with my opinions.

UNVOTE:

VOTE: A Simple Plan

[Persivul]

Yeah, except you cut out the part where I did engage with it by presenting evidence to the contrary.

[GuiltyLion]

It's more about the way you phrased it. You presented a counterexample to several hypotheses that were never explicitly stated (you were playful this game, playful!Persivul = scum!Persivul), and then hit him with "you need to justify it better". By "engage with it" I mean question it, or ask him to explain.

[Persivul]

Oh...sorry I didn't play it exactly the way you would have.

[The Betting Pool]

Prod Dodge... Actual post tomorrow