Mini 1717 Alfred Hitchcock UPick [GAME OVER]

[farside22]

etl's kill + lynch + factional night kill?

Oh I thought you meant during the night.

[hiplop]

yea. thats why I think no lynch here actually makes sense.

usually rigourously oppose them but this is exception

[EspeciallyTheLies]

VOTE: NL

[farside22]

yea. thats why I think no lynch here actually makes sense.

usually rigourously oppose them but this is exception

me too.

Can you tell me one thing because I'm really confused.
Why does nacho's claim make sense to you?
Or does it make sense?

[Ankamius]

Can you point me to his claim?

I'm a modified backup; I can use it before a lynch and I will backup the lynched player before they die. My information on hip-hop is not related to this; I said that it was mine in order to absorb a nightkill, but hiplop and massive are still town regardless.

Add that he didn't go anywhere and he knows that hippy is town because of his role.

Farside, are you scum?

No.

Is there really a point to the question or are you going to explain why I'm wrong or what I"m missing with what you quote.

Your response to Nacho doesn't make sense and I'm getting scum-push vibes from the way you're going about it.

[Ankamius]

I support no lynch.

[farside22]

Can you point me to his claim?

I'm a modified backup; I can use it before a lynch and I will backup the lynched player before they die. My information on hip-hop is not related to this; I said that it was mine in order to absorb a nightkill, but hiplop and massive are still town regardless.

Add that he didn't go anywhere and he knows that hippy is town because of his role.

Farside, are you scum?

No.

Is there really a point to the question or are you going to explain why I'm wrong or what I"m missing with what you quote.

Your response to Nacho doesn't make sense and I'm getting scum-push vibes from the way you're going about it.

I think he is lying scum.
I don't see how what he said makes any sense at all.

[Ankamius]

I don't understand your case. Nacho said his Hiplop read had nothing to do with his role.

[Antihero]

Everyone has somebody that they want to put out of the way. Oh now, surely Madam, you're not going to tell me that there hasn't been a time that you didn't want to dispose of someone. Your husband, for instance.

Strangers on a Train

Vote Count 3.6

Davsto - 1 (hiplop)
farside22 - 1 (massive)
Nachomamma8 - 3 (farside22, Davsto, Vedith)
Thor665 - 1 (Nachomamma8)

No Lynch - 1 (EspeciallyTheLies)

Not Voting: Ankamius, Thor665

5 to lynch
Deadline: (expired on 2015-11-18 22:48:18)

[hiplop]

yea. thats why I think no lynch here actually makes sense.

usually rigourously oppose them but this is exception

me too.

Can you tell me one thing because I'm really confused.
Why does nacho's claim make sense to you?
Or does it make sense?

im scared im wrong about nacho.

still inkling that hes scum, but ya

[farside22]

I don't understand your case. Nacho said his Hiplop read had nothing to do with his role.

He was scum reading hippy day 2.

He said he knew hippy was town due to his role.
He said he went nowhere.

Dear lord do I need to draw a map here?

[farside22]

yea. thats why I think no lynch here actually makes sense.

usually rigourously oppose them but this is exception

me too.

Can you tell me one thing because I'm really confused.
Why does nacho's claim make sense to you?
Or does it make sense?

im scared im wrong about nacho.

still inkling that hes scum, but ya

Okay so some math notes while people ponder all this.

there are 9 players left
no lynch and ETL kills thor, scum kill
that leave 7 players left.
Thor scum means 1/6 in favor of town.
Thor town means 2/5 in favor of town.
Lynch nacho
scum nacho means with thor scum
Town win
Thor town 1/5
Both town 2/4

I'm thinking odds do favor a no lynch looking at the break down.
Let me know if something is wrong with my numbers.

[Ankamius]

I don't understand your case. Nacho said his Hiplop read had nothing to do with his role.

He was scum reading hippy day 2.

He said he knew hippy was town due to his role.
He said he went nowhere.

Dear lord do I need to draw a map here?

Did you forget the post where he said he said that it was his role to absorb a nightkill?

[EspeciallyTheLies]

I thought it was a lynch?

[hiplop]

Numbers should be right !

What character are you etl? Just curious

[EspeciallyTheLies]

I am Mrs. Danvers, Neighborizing Vigilante

[Ankamius]

I don't understand your case. Nacho said his Hiplop read had nothing to do with his role.

He was scum reading hippy day 2.

He said he knew hippy was town due to his role.
He said he went nowhere.

Dear lord do I need to draw a map here?

Did you forget the post where he said he said that it was his role to absorb a nightkill?

uhhhh let me rephrase this so that it makes any sense whatsoever.

Did you forget the post where he said that the information was because of his role so that he could absorb a nightkill?

[farside22]

I don't understand your case. Nacho said his Hiplop read had nothing to do with his role.

He was scum reading hippy day 2.

He said he knew hippy was town due to his role.
He said he went nowhere.

Dear lord do I need to draw a map here?

Did you forget the post where he said he said that it was his role to absorb a nightkill?

uhhhh let me rephrase this so that it makes any sense whatsoever.

Did you forget the post where he said that the information was because of his role so that he could absorb a nightkill?

How does that make sense?

[Ankamius]

My information on hip-hop is not related to this

I said that it was mine in order to absorb a nightkill

[farside22]

My information on hip-hop is not related to this

I said that it was mine in order to absorb a nightkill

Ummmmmm someone died n2 so does that mean the absorbing is night 3?

Or your telling me you believe that Nacho gets info and becomes a lightning rod in one night.
Because if that's what you tell me makes a ton of sense I'm going to look at you like your nuts.

[Thor665]

I find Davsto's play in regards to Nacho terrible, but it actually looks kind of townish due to how terrible it is.
Ank continues to do and say nothing - people continue to act like the slot is town.
The wagons are all being very knee jerk mob rule based off random mob rule attitudes - I do not think that is good for the town. We have one dead scum and three dead town, and people are acting like somehow we're in PoE hoo-hah land? I feel like I've learned to play a different game then everyone else.

Vote: Farside

this is quite possibly the scummiest post I've ever seen you make in all the games we've had together.

This is quite possibly the most empty reinforcement of a gut read while not actually describing why anything I'm doing is scummy in the first place that I've ever seen.
I don't care that you have a gut read on me.
I care that you think you somehow have more than that.

The two commutes are complementary and therefore have to be the same team -- otherwise if Mother / Norma was town, why wouldn't she just commute herself every night? No, the wording of the ability makes it sound much more like the two can coordinate the ability.

That does presume an infinite commuter - so your argument is double scum unlimited commuters?

The answer to your first question is "OK" and the answer to your second question is "I thought Cata going from a very big scum read to a barely-mentioned one was strange, but feel less strongly about the point now that I see you mentioned Cat in an earlier post today".

Naw - c'mon man, talk me through why my Cat read would not change after a Pistach flip. That's what I asked, and you have to be smart enought to know I'd be an idiot *not* to have my read change, so why did you act like me changing it was weird?

Why?

Because he looks derp paranoid - I town read that.
You know I do.
So why question it?

Why did you stop voting me?

Quote me where I voted you besides right now and I'll happily answer this question;

Vote: Nachomamma8

[EspeciallyTheLies]

farside... his claim about hiplop has nothing to do with anything he did last night. it has to do with information he received and he believed it would draw the NK to him.

[EspeciallyTheLies]

ok we absolutely need to get this NL now. look at Thor now pushing for Nacho lynch despite all the new information.

[Thor665]

Oh, and I'm not pushing Ank because I don't strongly scum read him.
I just have no idea why so many people strong town read him.
He agrees with me - so I'm clearly not alone in thinking that read is random and empty. So, questioning me for questioning it while ignoring that he questioned it also is empty.

[EspeciallyTheLies]

he thought the lynch would go through without his support, and when it starts to fall off, he jumps on to give it a push.

bad bad bad.

do not let this happen.