Open 612 - Bad Poets Society - Game Over - Town Win

[Brunneis]

Cool.

Any thoughts on Errant today?



(Kling)

[Errantparabola]

Just lost a post because of the horrendously inconsistent wifi in this godforsaken hotel
Literally walking around the entire place to find thst elusive square fucking inch where the wifi works
So im gonna make a shorter one. Im irrationally frustrated.

1036 your first point confuses me. Whats stopping acum from making the same statement? Elaborate please. Also ranger what do you think about my thoughts on everyone else?

1041 i didnt do shit on day 2 due to rl. been trying to make up for it now by posting about my thoughts based on previous days.

1046 now that i am in full control of my senses, i realize thats a shit question anyway.

1050 if we are talking about thoughts on me, what are yours? If youve already answered please point me to that. Phoneposting sucks.

[Brunneis]

I have to eat lunch and do some things, I'll be back directly.

No, I'm not avoiding you, Errant, I'll really be back soon.

[duppin]

No need to vote for anyone yet, kids.

We have 12 days.

Let's spend the first few looking through each of the suspects.

Brunnies goes last.

Alphabetically Errantparabola is next, so today is all about her.

I'm okay with this, but I do believe I've already shared my opinion on Errant. (I have her as leaning town).

[Ranger]

@Ranger You spent all of Day1 and the first bit of Day2 voting for Errant. Please refresh our memories and tell us why. Do you still suspect Errant? Why or why not?

Iso me. 49, 233, 259, 287, 411, 459, 467, 474, 514, 515, 516, 557, 570, 591, 701, 775, 862, 928, 934, 936, 945, 948, 949, 1024, and 1036.

Maybe I should've linked you to my posts that

don't

mention Errant in a negative light; that'd probably have been shorter.

[Ranger]

Whats stopping acum from making the same statement?

A scum player, who has been at risk of being the lynch for a solid two day phases, does

not

, the minute the pressure loosens on them,

question why the pressure has loosened

.

Also ranger what do you think about my thoughts on everyone else?

They did nothing. Not town, not scum, just existing.

[Brunneis]

Just lost a post because of the horrendously inconsistent wifi in this godforsaken hotel
Literally walking around the entire place to find thst elusive square fucking inch where the wifi works
So im gonna make a shorter one. Im irrationally frustrated.

1036 your first point confuses me. Whats stopping acum from making the same statement? Elaborate please. Also ranger what do you think about my thoughts on everyone else?

1041 i didnt do shit on day 2 due to rl. been trying to make up for it now by posting about my thoughts based on previous days.

1046 now that i am in full control of my senses, i realize thats a shit question anyway.

1050 if we are talking about thoughts on me, what are yours? If youve already answered please point me to that. Phoneposting sucks.

I don't know if it's your wifi or not, I've been having trouble getting pages to load.

We didn't post much about you, other than suspicion over the RVS interaction between you, Makara, and Ranger.


There are 3 Scum among us, so I'm trying to spend 1 day on each player so everyone can sort things out. It's easier if we focus on one player at a time. (Tomorrow - Tuesday - is Persivul day, Max on Wednesday, Ranger on Thursday, Brunneis on Friday. Then the better focused discussion and voting can happen.


Does anyone have anything to say about Errant?

[Ika Musume]

i don't think ranger can be scum with anyone besides duppin or maxwell

i'm checking interactions atm

[Brunneis]

I realized

2 people are going to be town in the lynchpool.

I'm doubting a 2 person mafia team unless it's only just Ranger and Duppin, and even that doesn't seem right. Unless I'm reading this weird set-up wrong. Please point out if I am.

Town

Ika Musume
Fire Hermit
Brunneis

We have 5 town.

So 2 town in a 5 person lynchpool.

For those who still want my head,

that's 3 town to look for in the 6 person lynchpool

. Way to make life harder.

>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

@Ika

Yeah, I'm sure at this point that if Duppin or Ranger flips scum, the other probably is too. Not too sure about Max.

>>>>>>>>>>>>>

Going to keep with Klingons theme, however.

Tuesday is Persivul day. yaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay

1)

Did you think the 1v1 of Duppin VS Me was TvT?

2)

835 Tbh, this is one of the few posts that make me curious about you. Why exactly did you jump on the Gray wagon after my push, and Ika's vote?

Plus, Idk if this was lack of paying attention, an expression or phone-posting failure - but this game has only been alive for like a month....

3)

Who out of these:

Errant
Max
Ranger
Duppin
Brunneis

Would you say is where the 2 town lie and why?

@Errant

This head hasn't engaged with you yesterday; sorry. But what do you think about Persivul?

~Taly

[Persivul]

Tuesday - is Persivul day

Let the people rejoice!

[duppin]

@Taly

I'm honestly not entirely sure I understand how the setup works, so I'd like to discuss it.

As far as I can tell the setup is based around 7 letters, correct?

We have a doctor (D), 1-shot cop (C) and IC (M) and Varsoon confirmed we have a roleblocker and based on the setup it has to be a town (b).

That leaves us with TTT, which is: 2 goons + roleblocker and a SK, which means 3 mafias.

So I believe the setup is BCDMTTT but please correct me if I am wrong.
(Town Roleblocker, 1-shot cop, doctor, innocent child, 2 goons + 1 roleblocker and a SK)

[Persivul]

NSS

[Brunneis]

It's Tuesday, so let's see what looks Scummy in Makara/Persivul.

[Persivul]

2) 835 Tbh, this is one of the few posts that make me curious about you. Why exactly did you jump on the Gray wagon after my push, and Ika's vote?

Uh, maybe because:

Notes on grayfox's ISO (chosen first as it's shortest):

Positives: brunn vote was reasonable, he had had a strange exchange with brunn previously and errant was the main wagon at the time

Negatives: commenting on others' conversations rather than directly engaging; 6 fluff posts in a row at one point; votes max out of the blue and announces it's a pressure vote, moves back to brunn in next post

Conclusion: scummy. Grayfox just isn't interested in catching scum, which means he probably is one.

[Brunneis]

@Taly

I'm honestly not entirely sure I understand how the setup works, so I'd like to discuss it.

As far as I can tell the setup is based around 7 letters, correct?

We have a doctor (D), 1-shot cop (C) and IC (M) and Varsoon confirmed we have a roleblocker and based on the setup it has to be a town (b).

That leaves us with TTT, which is: 2 goons + roleblocker and a SK, which means 3 mafias.

So I believe the setup is BCDMTTT but please correct me if I am wrong.
(Town Roleblocker, 1-shot cop, doctor, innocent child, 2 goons + 1 roleblocker and a SK)

Yeah... I'm thinking that's correct, not entirely sure.

(Kind of want a head of Ika to confirm. XP)

NSS

What does this mean? ._.

2) 835 Tbh, this is one of the few posts that make me curious about you. Why exactly did you jump on the Gray wagon after my push, and Ika's vote?

Uh, maybe because:

Notes on grayfox's ISO (chosen first as it's shortest):

Positives: brunn vote was reasonable, he had had a strange exchange with brunn previously and errant was the main wagon at the time

Negatives: commenting on others' conversations rather than directly engaging; 6 fluff posts in a row at one point; votes max out of the blue and announces it's a pressure vote, moves back to brunn in next post

Conclusion: scummy. Grayfox just isn't interested in catching scum, which means he probably is one.

Your vote is 102 posts away from where you gave your reasoning for him as scum.

Why didn't you vote him then instead of when I made the initial push?

Also, you didn't answer your thoughts about the Duppin VS Me TvT or not, nor of what you thought around the lynchpool; so I'm looking for at least a response over that...

>>>>>>>>>

Also, I'm trying to encourage people to add onto discussion here about Pers in any shape or form.

~Taly[/size]

[Persivul]

NSS = No Shit, Sherlock

I worked out the setup shortly after coming in. Ika is a RB because: he mentioned that Bs hadn't been considered during previous setup discussion; and, it's the only option that makes sense considering he targeted my slot N1 and the slot wasn't exactly beloved. Speaking of which:

ika, who did you target last night?

[The Fire Hermit]

I am about ready for a flip in this game to be honest, really has stagnated.

-Fire

[Brunneis]

Love how whenever Klingon and I decide to methodically talk about each individual player in depth to know where we should vote since we're in mylo - not even excluding ourselves from this - this thread becomes dead with little interaction, even on the subject we're engaging on.

Guess the scumteam either shit themselves, or their planning for something.

And Pers, you're dodging my questions - I'd at least like a reason why.

~Taly

[Errantparabola]

Sorry, Brunneis and everyone else. I've been on a long and tiring flight from Connecticut to home, and coupled with some other events I've been too physically and emotionally exhausted to post...
I probably don't have the energy to post in my other games about this either. Oops.

Hopefully I'll be feeling better tomorrow, or even in a few hours.

[Quaroath]

Maxwell has requested replacement.

Looking

[Persivul]

Well, persivul day was a bust. With Max out I believe it's Ranger day today.

[duppin]

Taly, I just don't really have anything to add at the moment. I've already said what I think about Errant and Persivul. I think Persivul is most likely scum, the fact that he is still posting yet ignoring your questions is pretty weird as well.
It sucks that Maxwell is getting replaced, but I really want to speak with that slot.
I don't know about Ranger. The thing is you guys keep saying that me and Ranger have to be scum together for it to make sense, so I know this is not the case. That means if me and Ranger are both town, the team would be Persivul, Maxwell and Errant/Brunneis. I am townreading Errant at the moment, but this might turn out to be a mistake if Brunneis isn't scum. In either case Errant, my answer to your question about the best lynch, I believe now that the lynch should be between Persivul and Maxwell's slot.

[Klingoncelt]

Let's move on to Ranger today.

I just wanted to make this one post for now, I'll come back in hydra later...

[Errantparabola]

A scum player, who has been at risk of being the lynch for a solid two day phases, does not, the minute the pressure loosens on them, question why the pressure has loosened.

Um.
No.
Do you seriously think a scum player, when the pressure loosens on them and they question why, is going to be afraid of people suddenly going "You know what, you're right. Back to pressuring you!" Questioning a townread/lack of scumread seems like something extremely easy for scum to pull off to grab some town points.
Keep in mind that I townread Brunneis and am still nullread on you, but this seems like a good time to go digging for interactions between you and Brunneis.

[Brunneis]

... When I posted my vote on makara, I was convinced everyone who had posted was far more likely to be town than not. (Obviously, can't put much stock in RVS posting, but Ika, makara, Varsoon, and GrayFox all didn't look like scum with their opening votes, and you gotta start

somewhere

.) However, I knew that if I voted for someone who hadn't posted with my "may or may not be serious" disclaimer, everyone would assume it wasn't serious. So I voted makara in spite of not thinking makara was scum, waiting for someone to vote in a manner that looked like scum.

Errant following my vote made me instantly think she was scum.

(Klingoncelt head here.)

This post has been bugging me all game long.

"...I was convinced everyone who had posted was far more likely to be town than not. Ika, makara, Varsoon, and GrayFox all didn't look like scum with their opening votes..."

Why did they not look like Scum?

What made you say "everyone would assume it wasn't serious"?

It looks to me like you were trying to set up the first chump that came along.